Programming tools for Analogue Quantum Computing in the High-Performance Computing Context – A Review

Mateusz Meller, Vendel Szeremi, Oliver Thomson Brown · 2025

Read Programming tools for Analogue Quantum Computing in the High-Performance Computing Context – A Review by Mateusz Meller, Vendel Szeremi, Oliver Thomson Brown (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16943.txt.

Introduction

Quantum computers come in two broad styles, and the analogue style, which steers a system with smooth controls rather than step-by-step gates, has been the neglected sibling in software. Mateusz Meller, Vendel Szeremi, and Oliver Thomson Brown survey its programming tools in a 2025 review. Their focus is fit with supercomputing centers, where quantum machines will likely live as accelerators.

The authors catalog the tools that can program analogue machines, from Hamiltonian simulators to quantum annealers, and grade each for readiness to plug into high-performance computing workflows. Circuit-based tools have drawn most integration work, leaving analogue gaps in scheduling, data movement, and hybrid control. The review names those gaps and recommends fixes, arguing analogue machines' simpler abstraction could ease the path to large-scale quantum algorithms if the software stack catches up.

Catalog record

CREATORMateusz Meller, Vendel Szeremi, Oliver Thomson Brown
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE101 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16943

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Programming tools for Analogue Quantum Computing in the High-Performance Computing Context – A Review Mateusz Meller, Vendel Szeremi, Oliver Thomson Brown Abstract Recent advances in quantum computing have brought us closer to realizing the potential of this transformative technology. While significant strides have been made in quantum error correction, many challenges persist, particularly in the realm of noise and scalability. Analogue quantum computing schemes, such as Analogue Hamiltonian Simulation and Quantum Annealing, offer a promising approach to address these limitations. By operating at a higher level of abstraction, these schemes can simplify the development of large-scale quantum algorithms. To fully harness the power of quantum computers, they must be seamlessly integrated with traditional high-performance computing (HPC) systems. While substantial research has focused on the integration of circuit-based quantum computers with HPC, the integration of analogue quantum computers remains relatively unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by contributing in the following way: Comprehensive Survey : We conduct a comprehensive survey of existing quantum software tools with analogue capabilities. Readiness Assessment : We introduce a classification and rating system to assess the readiness of these tools for HPC integration. Gap Identification and Recommendations : We identify critical gaps in the landscape of analogue quantum programming models and propose actionable recommendations for future research and development. 1 Introduction Quantum computing (QC) offers a fundamentally different computational approach with the potential to revolutionise fields such as cryptography, quantum chemistry, and material science [ 1 ] . Major vendors are currently focused on scaling gate-based quantum computers [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . However, fault tolerance is essential to unlocking the full potential of these machines, and while significant progress has been made, substantial challenges remain [ 6 ] . Analogue quantum computing offers a potential solution to some of the challenges gate-based quantum computers face. Recent research [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] suggests that these machines are promising candidates for addressing a range of practical problems, including Quantum Hamiltonian Simulation (QHS) [ 11 ] and combinatorial optimisation [ 12 , 13 ] . However, due to their relatively lower popularity, there is a shortage of software tools which could fully leverage potential of analogue quantum computing [ 8 ] . Regardless of type, quantum devices will not replace classical computers. Instead, they are seen as hardware accelerators, similar to GPUs, capable of boosting the computational power of high-performance computing (HPC) systems [ 14 ] . For instance, quantum computers could accelerate quantum chemistry problems in the strong-correlation regime while leaving the weakly correlated interactions to classical methods [ 15 ] . While the search for specific applications is ongoing, it is clear that quantum computing will require close integration with classical processors, presenting challenges at both hardware and software levels to become effective. In this work, we focus on the software side of things. More precisely, we review existing programming models and tools that target analogue quantum computation and compile to analogue devices. Furthermore, we assess their readiness for HPC-QC integration. Our preliminary research shows that this space is underexplored compared to gate-based quantum computing. As such, there is a need to develop new programming models and frameworks to fully exploit analogue quantum devices. The rest of the paper is organised as follows: In section 2 , we motivate our work and give the necessary background. Next, in section 3 , we cover related reviews on analogue quantum computing, quantum programming models and HPC-QC integration. Then, section 4 outlines a taxonomy and methodology for our analysis. In section 5 , we collect existing quantum software frameworks supporting analogue computation. We perform a detailed analysis of their suitability for HPC environments. We close with a discussion of our results in section 6 and an outlook for future work in section 7 . 2 Background The following section outlines the background for this work. We begin by defining high-performance computing and quantum computing. Then, we introduce the categories of analogue quantum computing, highlighting their potential advantages. Finally, we explore the concept of programming models, their importance, and the motivation for studying them in the context of quantum computing. 2.1 High-Performance Computing The objective of High-Performance Computing (HPC) is to solve problems that are intractable for standard desktop machines. It is generally achieved by partitioning the studied problem and performing massively parallel computation. For years, the dominant approach to realise this was connecting many commodity processors via networks to create large-scale distributed systems. To realise data transfer, the dominant communication protocol is Message-Passing Interface (MPI) [ 16 ] . As such, any software tool hoping for high usage in the HPC domain must be amenable to MPI to be adopted [ 17 ] . However, since 2004, a new paradigm has taken hold where modern HPC systems become more complex and built of specialised devices – so-called accelerators. One such accelerator is a general-purpose graphical processing unit (GPGPU) [ 18 ] . Indeed, in 2018, 40% of systems in the Top500 list [ 19 ] were accelerated predominantly with GPUs [ 17 ] . As of today, most new systems at the top of the list are accelerated. We note that accelerators are not new in the HPC space – in the early 1980s ICL Distributed Array Processors were installed in the physics department at the University of Edinburgh, and the programming model and challenges were remarkably similar to that of modern GPU architectures [ 20 , 21 ] . The total dominance of accelerated architectures however, is a recent development. Given the variety of available hardware, a significant challenge is the portability of the software - making the same code run efficiently on different devices. Moreover, as the complexity of supercomputers grows and emerging accelerator technologies enter the market, the problem will become even more severe [ 17 ] . The main application of HPC is in the fields related to scientific computing, where the problems studied have computational-intensive characteristics. In recent years, interpreted languages such as Python have become popular in scientific computing. The reason being their flexibility and increased developer productivity. However, for the most part, the dominant large-scale codes running on supercomputing systems are compiled, as native code has better performance characteristics [ 22 ] and compilation offers an opportunity to detect and correct errors ahead of runtime. In practice, those codes should be considered the leading candidates for adding quantum routines and using quantum computers at the industrial scale. Summarising, the grand challenges faced by the HPC community are clarity , productivity , portability and performance . There is a lot of legacy baggage, and most practical quantum computing will need to be integrated with existing code rather than focusing solely on developing new applications. Therefore, adhering to the constraints of the HPC field is crucial for emerging technologies and software tools. 2.2 Quantum Computing The fundamental concept of quantum computing is that of a quantum bit, or qubit for short. A qubit is a system living in two-dimensional Hilbert space, which, similar to a classical bit, has two possible states labelled \ket{0} and \ket{1} . Contrary to the classical picture, a qubit can be in any linear combination (or superposition) of

Read the complete text