PoS(LATTICE2024)323 ADP-25-2/T1264 DESY-25-011 Liverpool LTH 1391 Renormalisation Group Equations for 2+1 clover fermions

J. M. Zanotti · 2025

Read PoS(LATTICE2024)323 ADP-25-2/T1264 DESY-25-011 Liverpool LTH 1391 Renormalisation Group Equations for 2+1 clover fermions by J. M. Zanotti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16920.txt.

Introduction

Can and co-authors derive flow equations for a workhorse setup in lattice studies of quantum chromodynamics. The field simulates quarks and gluons on a space-time grid. Many grid spacings are now available, so how results scale between them matters.

Their equations suit a 2+1 flavor setup with clover-improved fermions. Combined with pion mass and gradient flow data at five spacings, the equations let the team study scaling directly. The work was presented at a lattice conference. Scaling checks separate real physics from grid artifacts. The catalog record names only the last author; the paper itself lists seven. Technical talks like this keep big simulations honest.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. M. Zanotti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16920

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

PoS(LATTICE2024)323 ADP-25-2/T1264 DESY-25-011 Liverpool LTH 1391 Renormalisation Group Equations for 2+1 clover fermions J. M. Zanotti Abstract Many lattice QCD simulations now have many lattice spacings available, and it is of interest to investigate how they scale. In this talk we first derive renormalisation group equations appropriate for 2+1 clover fermions. This is then used together with pion mass and gradient flow results at five lattice spacings to study scaling. [b,1]R. Horsley 1 1 footnotetext: For the QCDSF Collaboration 1 Introduction One of the major difficulties in lattice gauge theories is the extrapolation to the continuum limit. Usually individual fits at a particular lattice spacing are made to, e.g. a hadron mass or matrix element, followed by an extrapolation to the continuum limit (usually in a^{2} ). This is a noisy procedure, involving both the pre-determined a values and also the individual values of the mass or matrix element. To improve the situation often a smoothing procedure is used, for example a joint extrapolation involving both the lattice spacing and mass or matrix element simultaneously. Theoretically this is often not so well justified. A better motivated procedure suggested here is to use the Renormalisation Group (RG) equations to help to achieve this. In this contribution we attempt a first step by deriving and solving the RG equations for the lattice spacing. 2 The RG equation Scaling means that we have lines of constant physics (e.g. constant mass ratios) passing through our parameter space. On one of these lines we can measure the relative rate at which lattice spacing changes by monitoring the rate at which correlation lengths change as we move along the trajectory. Scaling (up to O(a^{2}) violations) are regions where a\Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\ll 1 and am_{q}\ll 1 . For Wilson type fermions considered here we have in g_{0} , \kappa_{q} space \displaystyle\left.a{\partial\over\partial a}\right|_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle physics}=U(g_{0},\{\kappa\})\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial g_{0}}\right|_{\kappa}+\sum_{q}V_{q}(g_{0},\{\kappa\})\left.{\partial\over\partial\kappa_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}}\,. (1) Re-writing this in terms of m_{q}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\equiv am_{q} where \displaystyle am_{q}\equiv{1\over 2}\left({1\over\kappa_{q}}-{1\over\kappa_{0c}(g_{0})}\right)\,, (2) (with \kappa_{0} the hopping parameter on the SU(n_{f}) -flavour symmetric line, with critical point at the chiral limit \kappa_{0c} ) and then Taylor expanding U and V_{q} gives \displaystyle a\left.{\partial\over\partial a}\right|_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle physics} \displaystyle= \displaystyle B_{0}(g_{0})\left.{\partial\over\partial g_{0}}\right|_{\{am\}}+B_{1}(g_{0})a\bar{m}\left.{\partial\over\partial g_{0}}\right|_{\{am\}} (3) \displaystyle+G_{0}(g_{0})\sum_{q}am_{q}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}}+H_{0}(g_{0})a\bar{m}\sum_{q}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}} \displaystyle+G_{1}(g_{0})a\bar{m}\sum_{q}am_{q}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}}+G_{2}(g_{0})\sum_{q}(am_{q})^{2}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}} \displaystyle+H_{1}(g_{0})(a\bar{m})^{2}\sum_{q}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}}+H_{2}(g_{0})a^{2}\widebar{m^{2}}\sum_{q}\left.{\partial\over\partial am_{q}}\right|_{g_{0}}\,, where \displaystyle a\bar{m}\equiv{1\over n_{f}}\sum_{q}am_{q}\,,\qquad a^{2}\widebar{m^{2}}\equiv{1\over n_{f}}\sum_{q}a^{2}m_{q}^{2}\,. (4) The B_{0} , G_{0} , H_{0} coefficients are usually referred to as ‘renormalisation’, while the B_{1} , G_{1} , G_{2} , H_{1} , H_{2} coefficients are the ‘improvement’ terms, so in principle this treats both the renormalisation and improvement terms in a unified fashion. For chiral fermions all the coefficients vanish, except for B_{0} and G_{0} . It is sufficient to only consider here the leading terms (ie O(am_{q}) ), although the higher order terms can be considered, [ 1 ] . The leading functions are related to the usual renormalisation coefficients \displaystyle B_{0}(g_{0})=-\beta(g_{0})\,,\quad G_{0}(g_{0})=1-\gamma_{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle NS}(g_{0})\,,\quad H_{0}(g_{0})=\gamma_{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle NS}(g_{0})-\gamma_{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle S}(g_{0})\,, (5) with \displaystyle\begin{aligned} \beta(g_{0})&=-b_{0}g_{0}^{3}-b_{1}g_{0}^{5}-b_{2}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}g_{0}^{7}+O(g_{0}^{9})\,,\\ B_{1}(g_{0})&=\phantom{-}b^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}_{10}g_{0}^{3}+O(g_{0}^{5})\,,\end{aligned}\qquad\begin{aligned} \gamma_{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle NS}(g_{0})&=d_{0}g_{0}^{2}+d_{1}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle NS\,lat}g_{0}^{4}+O(g_{0}^{6})\,,\\ \gamma_{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle S}(g_{0})&=d_{0}g_{0}^{2}+d_{1}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle S\,lat}g_{0}^{4}+O(g_{0}^{6})\,,\end{aligned} (6) where b_{0} , b_{1} and d_{0} are known universal coefficients. 2.1 Renormalised quark masses For Wilson-like fermions, which have no chiral symmetry, the singlet and non-singlet quark mass pieces evolve differently \displaystyle\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}=a\bar{m}\,u(g_{0})\,,\qquad m_{q}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}-\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}=(am_{q}-a\bar{m})\,v(g_{0})\,. (7) For simplicity we consider the Renormalised Group Invariant (RGI) quark mass, alternatively the same equations hold for the quark mass in a given scheme at a given scale. Also to simplify the notation somewhat we have absorbed \Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat} into the definition of \bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi} , i.e. we measure the quark mass in units of \Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat} . Note, in particular, that \bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}\propto a\bar{m} . We now solve the RG equation \displaystyle a\left.{\partial\over\partial a}\right|_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle physics}m_{q}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}=0\,, (8) to give \displaystyle u(g_{0})=C(g_{0})\exp\left[\int_{0}^{g_{0}}d\xi\left\{{1\over b_{0}\xi^{3}}-{b_{1}+b_{0}d_{0}\over b_{0}^{2}\xi}-{G_{0}(\xi)+H_{0}(\xi)\over B_{0}(\xi)}\right\}\right]\,, (9) and \displaystyle v(g_{0})=C(g_{0})\exp\left[\int_{0}^{g_{0}}d\xi\left\{{1\over b_{0}\xi^{3}}-{b_{1}+b_{0}d_{0}\over b_{0}^{2}\xi}-{G_{0}(\xi)\over B_{0}(\xi)}\right\}\right]\,, (10) where \displaystyle C(g_{0})=\Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\left[2b_{0}g_{0}^{2}\right]^{d_{0}\over 2b_{0}}\left[b_{0}g_{0}^{2}\right]^{b_{1}\over 2b_{0}^{2}}\exp\left[\frac{1}{2b_{0}g_{0}^{2}}\right]\,. (11) These are the usual type of equations, arranged so that there is no singularity in the integral as g_{0}\to 0 . Again, for simplicity, as for \bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi} we shall in future measure u (and v ) in units of \Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat} , so u\to u/\Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat} . Similar equations (with appropriate \gamma s) also hold for the renormalisation of operators m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}\to O^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi} . However we shall not consider this further here. 2.2 Coupling constant Rather than considering the renormalised coupling, we consider here the relation between the lattice spacing and lattice coupling. There are two possibilities. First we consider changing lattice spacing (i.e. including a\bar{m} in the definition, but keeping the coupling constant). Setting \displaystyle a=s(g_{0})\left\{1+a\bar{m}\,r(g_{0})\right\}\,, (12) and solving \displaystyle a\left.{\partial\over\partial a}\right|_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle physics}a=a\,, (13) gives \displaystyle s(g_{0}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle A(g_{0})\exp\left(\int^{g_{0}}_{0}d\xi\left\{{1\over B_{0}(\xi)}-{1\over b_{0}\xi^{3}}+{b_{1}\over b_{0}^{2}\xi}\right\}\right)\,, (14) \displaystyle r(g_{0}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-u(g_{0})\int_{0}^{g_{0}}d\xi{B_{1}(\xi)\over u(\xi)B_{0}^{2}(\xi)}\,\,\,\underbrace{=}_{g_{0}^{2}\to 0}\,\,\,-{b_{10}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\over b_{0}}g_{0}^{2}+O(g_{0}^{4})\,, (15) with \displaystyle A(g_{0})={1\over\Lambda^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}}\left[b_{0}g_{0}^{2}\right]^{-{b_{1}\over 2b_{0}^{2}}}\exp\left[-\;{1\over 2b_{0}g_{0}^{2}}\right]\,. (16) Note that s(g_{0}) is the standard RG solution to the \beta -function. Alternatively a second possibility would be to re-define the coupling constant by setting (e.g. [ 2 ] ) \displaystyle\tilde{g}_{0}^{2}=g_{0}^{2}\left\{1+b_{g}(g_{0})a\bar{m}\right\}\,, (17) and now solving \displaystyle a\left.{\partial\over\partial a}\right|_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle physics}\tilde{g}_{0}=B_{0}(\tilde{g}_{0})\,, (18) gives \displaystyle b_{g}(g_{0})=2{B_{0}(g_{0})\over g_{0}}\,r(g_{0})\underbrace{=}_{g_{0}^{2}\to 0}-2b_{10}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}g_{0}^{4}+O(g_{0}^{6})\,. (19) As anticipated we have b_{g}\propto r . As discussed in e.g. [ 3 , 4 ] we expect b_{g} (and hence r ) to be numerically quite small. 3 Lattice data For n_{f}=2+1 , q=u , d , s flavours ( am_{u}=am_{d}\equiv am_{l} ) the QCDSF strategy [ 5 ] is to consider a flavour singlet quantity X_{s}(m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{u},m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{d},m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{s}) for example X_{\pi}^{2}=\left(2M_{K}^{2}+M_{\pi}^{2}\right)/3 , X_{t_{0}}^{2}=1/t_{0} , X_{N}^{2}=(M_{N}^{2}+M_{\Sigma}^{2}+M_{\Xi}^{2})/3 . These are invariant under all u , d , s quark interchanges (by definition) and have the useful property that they have a stationary point on the SU(3) -flavour symmetric line when all the quark masses are equal. This means that X_{s}(\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}+\delta m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{u},\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}+\delta m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{d},\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}+\delta m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{s})=X_{s}(\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi},\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi},\bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi})+O((\delta m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{q})^{2}) where \delta m^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}_{q} is the ‘distance’ from the SU(3) -flavour symmetric line, \bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi} being held constant (otherwise additional terms arise) [ 5 ] . As from eq. ( 7 ) \bar{m}^{\rm\scriptscriptstyle rgi}\propto a\bar{m} , this result is valid whether renormalised or lattice is being considered. This is shown in the LH panel of Fig. 1 . Figure 1 : Left panel: X_{s}^{{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\,2} for s=t_{0} , N , w_{0} , \rho , \pi , f_{\pi} , for (\beta,\kappa_{0})=(5.50,0.120900) , together with constant fits. The opaque points have M_{\pi}L\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\lower 4.0pt\hbox{\hskip 1.0pt$\sim$}\hss}\raise 1.0pt\hbox{$<$}}4 and are not considered in the fit. The vertical line is approximately the physical mass ratio value. The plot is taken from [ 6 ] , to which we refer to for further details. Right panel: X_{\pi}^{{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\,2} along the SU(3) -flavour symmetric line, blue triangles (with a linear fit) and along a\bar{m}=\mbox{const.} lines starting from \kappa_{0}=0.120900 , cyan horizontal triangles and \kappa_{0}=0.120950 , orange horizontal triangles (both together with a constant fit). Also shown are the M_{\pi}^{{\rm\scriptscriptstyle lat}\,2} lines for constant \kappa_{0}=0.120900 , \kappa_{0}=0.120950 and varying \kappa_{u}=\kappa_{s}\equiv\kappa_{l} , cyan and orange triangles (both with a linear fit). We use an O(a) non-pertubatively improved clover action, [ 7 ] , with \beta=10/g_{0}^{2}=5.40 , 5.50 , 5.65 , 5.80 and 5.95 on a variety of lattice sizes ( 24^{3}\times 48 , 32^{3}\times 64 and 48^{3}\times 96 ) with M_{\pi}L\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\lower 4.0pt\hbox{\hskip 1.0pt$\sim$}\hss}\raise 1.0pt\hbox{$>$}}4 . Little evidence of any quadratic term O((\delta(am_{l}))^{2}) and any systematic effect is seen for

Read the complete text