NuSTAR detection of a hot stellar superflare with a temperature of 95 MK in hard X-rays

Tomohiro Hakamata, Hironori Matsumoto, Hirokazu Odaka, Shinsuke Takasao · 2025

Read NuSTAR detection of a hot stellar superflare with a temperature of 95 MK in hard X-rays by Tomohiro Hakamata, Hironori Matsumoto, Hirokazu Odaka, Shinsuke Takasao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16710.txt.

Introduction

Astronomers mining the NuSTAR archive found a hard X-ray flare so hot it strains the usual picture of stellar flares. Tomohiro Hakamata and co-authors traced the 2013 outburst to a single M dwarf, a binary, or a young star still forming. Its plasma averaged about 95 million degrees, with an emission measure above typical flares. Modeling the flare loop suggested a structure several times wider than the star itself.

The authors instead propose several linked flares firing together across the surface, a pattern known from the Sun as sympathetic flares. The plasma stayed unusually hot long after the brightness faded, which fits that idea.

Catalog record

CREATORTomohiro Hakamata, Hironori Matsumoto, Hirokazu Odaka, Shinsuke Takasao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16710

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

NuSTAR detection of a hot stellar superflare with a temperature of 95 MK in hard X-rays Tomohiro Hakamata, Hironori Matsumoto, Hirokazu Odaka, Shinsuke Takasao Abstract A search of the hard X-ray archive data of the Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array ( NuSTAR ) found a transient source, NuSTAR J230059+5857.4, during an observation of 1E 2259+586 on 2013 April 25. A multi-wavelength analysis using X-ray, optical, and infrared data, mostly taken in its quiescent phase, was conducted to identify the origin of NuSTAR J230059+5857.4 and elucidate the phenomena associated with the flare activity. The results indicated that NuSTAR J230059+5857.4 was a stellar flare that occurred on a single M-dwarf, M-dwarf binary, or pre-main-sequence star. NuSTAR J230059+5857.4 exhibited the higher emission measure and higher temperature, 8.60 + 2.15 − 1.73 × 10 54 {}^{+2.15}_{-1.73}\times 10^{54} cm -3 and 8.21 − 1.86 + 2.71 {}^{+2.71}_{-1.86} keV, respectively, on average than the nominal values of stellar flares reported in the past. The flare loop size estimated on the basis of the model to balance the plasma and magnetic pressures was larger than the stellar radius by a factor of several. Since based on solar flare loops, this flare loop scale is excessively large, we conjecture that the observed large emission measure is possible to be attributed to the observation of mutually-associated multiple flares simultaneously occurring on the stellar surface, known as sympathetic flares. Thanks to the large effective area of NuSTAR in the hard X-ray band, we are able to conduct detailed discussion about a temperature variation associated with the flare. Investigation of the temperature variation during the flare revealed that the temperature remained significantly higher than during the quiescent phase even after the count rate dropped to around 5% of the peak. The sustained high temperature over the long duration is consistent with the idea of sympathetic flares. We found that it is essential to use theoretical models to evaluate loops and assess temporal changes in temperature as done in this study to determine whether there are multiple flares or not when analyzing flare observation data. 2024 \Received \Accepted \KeyWords X-rays: stars — infrared: stars — stars: flare — stars: late-type — stars: activity 1 Introduction Stellar flares are observed on dwarf stars, which have spectral types of M, K, G, and F (Tsuboi et al. 2016). Stellar flares are also seen in pre-main-sequence stars and RS CVn systems. Pre-main-sequence stars have spectral types ranging from M to K, and RS CVn systems are close binary systems, usually composed of G or K-type giants or subgiants and G, K, or M-type dwarfs or subgiants (Berdyugina 2005). Cool stars, including pre-main-sequence stars with M-type spectra, have the \alpha^{2} dynamo, generating strong magnetic fields and more energetic flares than the Sun. In contrast, hot stars with G-type spectra have the \alpha\Omega dynamo, generating weaker flares (Shibata \& Yokoyama 1999, 2002; Getman et al. 2022, 2023a). In RS CVn systems, tidal forces between binary stars generate strong magnetic fields and energetic flares (Berdyugina 2005). Observations of solar flares have revealed that the hard X-ray emission (above 10 keV) and soft X-ray emission (below 10 keV) originate from the nonthermal plasma accelerated by magnetic reconnections and the thermal plasma heated by the nonthermal plasma, respectively (Veronig et al., 2005). These facts indicate that the softer X-ray flux peak in a flare is expected to lag behind that of harder X-rays, as indeed observed in solar flares (Aschwanden \& Alexander 2001). These suggest that the hard X-ray band is important for understanding physics of stellar flares in general, such as the temporal variation of the plasma temperature in the early phase of a flare. To understand the physics of the early phase of stellar flares, it is crucial to estimate the scale of flare loops using hard X-ray data because the accelerated plasma move along the magnetic fields within the flare loops. In the soft X-ray band, there have been ample detections and observations of stellar flares. Several studies have analyzed temporal variations of the plasma temperatures of flares based on soft X-ray observations that covered the periods from the flux peaks to the decay phases of the flares (e.g., Favata et al. 2000a; Tsuboi et al. 1998). In contrast, observations in the hard X-ray band above 10 keV are very limited. In particular, none of the reported hard X-ray observations of positive detection of stellar flares have covered the entire time period of a flare from the flux peak to the decay phase and revealed a temporal variation in a temperature with high sensitivity, partly because most of them were based on all-sky survey observations (e.g., Tsuboi et al. (2016), and Osten et al. (2007, 2010)), where the telescopes either have a low sensitivity or do not keep exposure for a prolonged time. For example, Tsuboi et al. (2016) failed to measure the temperature variations associated with the flares with a meaningful error in their MAXI observation due to the limited sensitivity of MAXI . Although Osten et al. (2007, 2010) succeeded in obtaining temperature variations of flares on II Peg and EV Lac with Swift /BAT, the observation period did not cover the entire flare duration; in the former study, over a half of the decay phase was not observed, and in the latter study, the observation started after the flux of the flare had already started to decline. Thus, scientists still wait for the first high-sensitivity hard X-ray observations that cover the entire flare period from initial rises to decay phases. In this work, we searched for stellar flare candidates from the archival data of the Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array ( NuSTAR ; Harrison et al. 2013). NuSTAR has the highest sensitivity in the hard X-ray band above 10 keV among the past and currently-operating X-ray satellites, owing to its unprecedented mirror-based X-ray imaging capability in the hard energy band extending beyond well above 10 keV (3–79 keV). It has a large effective area, ten times larger than MAXI . The expected number of serendipitous detections of stellar flares with NuSTAR per unit time is lower than that with MAXI because NuSTAR is designed for pointing observations unlike the all-sky monitor MAXI. In fact, since its launch, NuSTAR has only detected four stellar flares in two pre-main-sequence stars and two protostars, and the detailed temperature variations of these flares have not been analyzed (Vievering et al. 2019; Getman et al. 2023b). With this search, we discovered a transient source of which the light curve resembled a stellar flare, located approximately 5 \arcmin north of the magnetar 1E 2259+586 in the observation on 2013 April 25. No source was detected at the location (see the image in Figure 1 ) before the flaring event, which suddenly began at around 14:00. The source became faint below the NuSTAR detection threshold again approximately 600 seconds later. No prior research had described the counterpart object at the location of this transient source. This flare is hotter and brighter than the flares described in previous studies, resulting in data with many counts in the hard X-ray band thanks to the large effective area of NuSTAR . Consequently, we were able to measure the temperature variations associated with the flare and discuss

Read the complete text