A Study of Afterglow Signatures in NaI and CsI Scintillator Modules for the Background and Transient Observer Instrument on COSI

Hannah Gulick, Hiroki Yoneda, Tadayuki Takahashi, Claire Chen, Kazuhiro Nakazawa, Shunsaku Nagasawa, Mii Ando, Keigo Okuma, Alyson Joens, Samer Al Nussirat, Yasuyuki Shimizu, Kaito Fujisawa, Takayoshi Kohmura, Kouichi Hagino, Hisashi Kitamura, Andreas Zoglauer, Juan Carlos Martinez Oliveros, John A. · 2025

Read A Study of Afterglow Signatures in NaI and CsI Scintillator Modules for the Background and Transient Observer Instrument on COSI by Hannah Gulick, Hiroki Yoneda, Tadayuki Takahashi, Claire Chen, Kazuhiro Nakazawa, Shunsaku Nagasawa, Mii Ando, Keigo Okuma, Alyson Joens, Samer Al Nussirat, Yasuyuki Shimizu, Kaito Fujisawa, Takayoshi Kohmura, Kouichi Hagino, Hisashi Kitamura, Andreas Zoglauer, Juan Carlos Martinez Oliveros, John A. (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16434.txt.

Introduction

Hannah Gulick, Hiroki Yoneda, Tadayuki Takahashi and colleagues measured afterglow in scintillator crystals for a gamma-ray instrument flying on the COSI space mission in 2025. Afterglow is a lingering false signal after a strong hit, and it can blind a detector or force higher thresholds.

At a Japanese accelerator, helium and carbon beams struck sodium iodide and caesium iodide modules. Both glowed afterwards, but caesium iodide was far worse: its afterglow lasted up to nine times longer and would cost about seven times more dead time per event. Simulations of orbit background rates completed the case. Despite caesium iodide's brighter light, the team recommends sodium iodide for the mission.

Catalog record

CREATORHannah Gulick, Hiroki Yoneda, Tadayuki Takahashi, Claire Chen, Kazuhiro Nakazawa, Shunsaku Nagasawa, Mii Ando, Keigo Okuma, Alyson Joens, Samer Al Nussirat, Yasuyuki Shimizu, Kaito Fujisawa, Takayoshi Kohmura, Kouichi Hagino, Hisashi Kitamura, Andreas Zoglauer, Juan Carlos Martinez Oliveros, John A.
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16434

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Study of Afterglow Signatures in NaI and CsI Scintillator Modules for the Background and Transient Observer Instrument on COSI Hannah Gulick, Hiroki Yoneda, Tadayuki Takahashi, Claire Chen, Kazuhiro Nakazawa, Shunsaku Nagasawa, Mii Ando, Keigo Okuma, Alyson Joens, Samer Al Nussirat, Yasuyuki Shimizu, Kaito Fujisawa, Takayoshi Kohmura, Kouichi Hagino, Hisashi Kitamura, Andreas Zoglauer, Juan Carlos Martinez Oliveros, John A. Tomsick Abstract We present measurements of the afterglow signatures in NaI(Tl) and CsI(Tl) detector modules as part of the Background and Transient Observer (BTO) mission detector trade-study. BTO is a NASA Student Collaboration Project flying on the Compton Spectrometer and Imager (COSI) Small Explorer mission in 2027. The detectors utilized in this study are cylindrical in shape with a height and diameter of 5.1 cm and were read out by silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs). We conducted a radiation campaign at the HIMAC accelerator in Japan where the scintillators were irradiated with a 230 MeV/u helium beam (He beam) and 350 MeV/u carbon beam (C beam). We find that both the CsI and NaI scintillators exhibit afterglow signatures when irradiated with the C and He beams. The CsI crystal exhibits a stronger afterglow intensity with afterglow pulses occurring for an average 2.40 ms for C and 0.9 ms for He after the initial particle pulse. The duration of afterglow pulses in CsI is 8.6 × \times and 5.6 × \times the afterglow signal duration in NaI for C and He (0.28 ms and 0.16 ms, respectively). Although CsI has advantages such as a higher light yield and radiation hardness, the stronger afterglows in the CsI detector increase the complexity of the electronics and lead to a ∼ \sim 7 × \times larger dead time per afterglow event or a ∼ \sim 3 × \times higher energy threshold value. We use the measured dead times to predict the amount of observing time lost to afterglow-inducing events for an instrument like BTO in low Earth orbit. We simulate the background rates in a BTO-like orbit and find a total value of 114 counts/s for the full two-detector system. Based on the particle energies in the HIMAC experiment, we then determine that an event with sufficient energy to produce an afterglow signal occurs once every ∼ \sim 70 s and ∼ \sim 1.4 s in NaI and CsI detectors, respectively. Thus, we conclude that NaI is the better choice for the BTO mission. Journal: Nuclear Physics B 1 Introduction Afterglow, in the context of scintillators, is a phenomenon during which light emission in the crystal continues after a high-amplitude signal. Afterglow emission occurs when a delayed charge carrier is thermally released and recombines at a luminescence center causing a pulse ( Koppert et al., 2018 ; Lecoq, 2020 ; Farukhi, 1982 ) . Several factors can influence the delayed recombination of charge carriers, including structural defects or impurities in the crystal and temperature ( Alfassi et al., 2009 ) . The delayed pulses are a concern for high-energy astrophysics instruments for several reasons. In space-based instruments, the energetic particles in Earth’s radiation environment provide a continuous source of scintillation and afterglow light emission. These particles induce phosphorescence in scintillators, thus producing an effective degradation in a detector’s energy resolution ( Dilillo et al., 2022 ) . Additionally, the delayed afterglow pulses can trigger as false \gamma -ray events in the detector electronics. Therefore, the afterglow signature and duration for a given scintillator material must be well understood to minimize false triggers. The work presented in this paper was motivated by a detector trade-study conducted for the Background and Transient Observer (BTO). BTO is the Student Collaboration Project that will fly on the Compton Spectrometer and Imager (COSI) Small Explorer Mission (SMEX) ( Tomsick et al., 2023 ) to study \gamma -ray transients and monitor the soft \gamma -ray background in the 30 keV to 2 MeV range. The BTO detector trade-study includes in-depth analyses of two inorganic crystals —NaI(Tl) and CsI(Tl)— as read out with silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) and corresponding electronics. Both scintillator types have space heritage spanning several decades, high light output when exposed to ionizing radiation, long-term stability and durability, and a low-cost baseline due to commercial availability ( Hawrami et al., 2022 ; Farukhi, 1982 ) . However, while both crystals are generally cost effective, obtaining a high-purity crystal with minimal afterglow-inducing defects and impurities rapidly drives up the price. In this paper, we compare afterglow signatures in waveforms taken with the Scionix NaI(Tl) and CsI(Tl) 51B51/SiP-E3-X cylindrical detector modules with SiPM readouts (see Table 1 and Figure 1 ). The Scionix packages have a built-in, proprietary amplifier circuit, therefore we assess the afterglow signal in the combined output from the crystal, SiPM, and amplifier. Regardless of the built-in shaping parameters, afterglows are long, enduring signals intrinsic to the scintillator that cannot be neglected when designing \gamma -ray missions. This experiment quantifies the severity of afterglows in the Scionix NaI and CsI detectors in order to determine the time period after a heavy ion hit which is lost to afterglows. This work is applied directly to the BTO mission but is also more generally useful to space-based missions using NaI or CsI with SiPM readouts. Typical afterglow signatures were reported to reach fractions of \sim 3–15% after 1–3 ms in NaI(Tl) detectors for X-ray pulses ( Lecoq, 2020 ; Koppert et al., 2018 ; Farukhi, 1982 ) . Studies on the CsI(Tl) detectors report high enough afterglow fractions in high-energy irradiation to prevent its use in most astrophysical and medical applications ( Alfassi et al., 2009 ; Lecoq, 2020 ; Farukhi, 1982 ) . Historically, afterglow studies in the \gamma -ray regime were almost exclusively conducted with photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) or photodiode readouts. However, the newer SiPM technology is becoming popular in space-based applications where their lower weight and volume (compared to a PMT) makes them advantageous. Therefore, a comprehensive study of afterglow in systems utilizing SiPMs is necessary for BTO and other future \gamma -ray missions. To measure and constrain the afterglow signatures in NaI(Tl) and CsI(Tl) scintillators, we conducted an irradiation campaign at the Heavy Ion Medical Accelerator in Chiba (HIMAC). Both scintillator materials were irradiated with a 230 MeV/u (920 MeV) He beam and a 350 MeV/u (4.2 GeV) C beam. This paper describes the measurements, analysis, and afterglow results in Section 2 . Section 3 further describes the BTO instrument with detector trade-study results in Section 3.2 and simulations of the background and afterglow inducing particle rates in the BTO orbit. 2 Measuring Afterglow Signatures in Waveform Data 2.1 Setup and Measurements We took measurements at the HIMAC facility in Japan using both an NaI and CsI based detector module with SiPM readouts. The crystals were packaged by Scionix and cylindrical in shape with a diameter and height of 5.1 cm. The detector modules, shown in Figure 1 , included a hermetically sealed scintillator (NaI or CsI) followed by an optical window, ArrayJ-60035-4P-PCB SiPM, and a built-in amplifier specific to Scionix detectors. The SiPM is PCB mounted with a high ( \sim 90%) fill-factor and a peak wavelength at 420 nm, dark current of \sim 7.5 \mu A, and rise time of 250 ps. The scintillator and electronics were

Read the complete text