Line-of-sight shear in SLACS strong lenses I: shear and mass model parametrisations

Natalie B. Hogg 1,2,3,∗, Daniel P. Johnson 4, Anowar J. Shajib 5,6,7, Julien Larena 4 · 2025

Read Line-of-sight shear in SLACS strong lenses I: shear and mass model parametrisations by Natalie B. Hogg 1,2,3,∗, Daniel P. Johnson 4, Anowar J. Shajib 5,6,7, Julien Larena 4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16292.txt.

Introduction

Natalie B Hogg and co-authors try to measure a faint bending effect in strong gravitational lenses for the first time. Their 2025 paper models twenty-three lenses from the SLACS survey, where a heavy galaxy bends light from a farther source into arcs and rings.

Matter along the line of sight adds a small extra warp, called shear, which may one day help pin down cosmic values on its own. The team used a minimal model for this shear and an automated fitting pipeline to model each lens. They report a mean shear size across the set, and test two refinements. Skipping a correction for foreground shear tangles the result with other model parts. Adding a more complex mass shape did not bring the shear closer to weak lensing hopes.

Catalog record

CREATORNatalie B. Hogg 1,2,3,∗, Daniel P. Johnson 4, Anowar J. Shajib 5,6,7, Julien Larena 4
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16292

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Line-of-sight shear in SLACS strong lenses I: shear and mass model parametrisations Natalie B. Hogg 1,2,3,∗, Daniel P. Johnson 4, Anowar J. Shajib 5,6,7, Julien Larena 4 Abstract Inhomogeneities along the line of sight in strong gravitational lensing distort the images produced, in an effect called shear. If measurable, this shear may provide independent constraints on cosmological parameters, complementary to traditional cosmic shear. We model 23 strong gravitational lenses from the Sloan Lens ACS (SLACS) catalogue with the aim of measuring the line-of-sight (LOS) shear for the first time. We use the ‘minimal model’ for the LOS shear, which has been shown to be theoretically safe from degeneracies with lens model parameters, a finding which has been confirmed using mock data. We use the dolphin automated modelling pipeline, which uses the lenstronomy software as a modelling engine, to model our selected lenses. Across the 23 lenses, we measure the LOS shear with a mean magnitude of 0.056 ± 0.013 0.056\pm 0.013 . Neglecting the post-Born correction to the potential of the main deflector due to foreground shear leads to a propagation of degeneracies in the LOS shear measurement with other lens model parameters, and the inclusion of an octupole moment in the lens mass profile does not lead to shear measurements that are in better agreement with the expectations from weak lensing. ∗ [email protected] keywords Strong gravitational lensing, cosmology 1 Introduction Gravitational lensing provides a unique window into the cosmology of our Universe on a wide range of scales. The strong lensing regime, in which a single massive deflector lenses a single source, has been used to measure the expansion rate of the Universe at z=0 , H_{0} ( Refsdal, 1964 ; Wong and others, 2020 ; Birrer et al., 2024 ; Birrer and others, 2025 ) via observations of the difference in arrival times of images of variable sources. Strong lensing has been used to probe properties of the lens galaxies, such as their density profiles ( Treu et al., 2006 ; Shajib et al., 2021 ; Shajib et al., 2024 ) , and, by studying lens galaxies at different redshifts, their evolution over time ( Chae, 2010 ; Bezanson et al., 2011 ; Sahu and others, 2024 ; Sheu et al., 2024 ) . It has also been used to search for dark matter sub-haloes both within the main deflector halo and along the line of sight between the observer and lens ( Vegetti and Koopmans, 2009 ; Vegetti et al., 2012 ; Vegetti et al., 2014 ; Hezaveh and others, 2016 ; Nightingale et al., 2024 ) . The weak lensing regime probes larger scales. Unlike strong lensing, multiple images of the same source are not produced; rather, small distortions are induced on the single image of each source, artificially squashing and aligning them. The leading order shape distortion is shear, and its effect cannot be disentangled from the intrinsic shape of individual galaxies or their intrinsic alignment. The cosmic shear signal is detected by correlating the shapes of millions of galaxies in a given galaxy survey. Once extracted, cosmic shear can be used to place constraints on cosmological parameters like the matter density \Omega_{\rm m} and the clustering parameter \sigma_{8} . For a recent review of weak gravitational lensing, we refer the reader to Prat and Bacon (2026) . By virtue of their existence in our inhomogeneous Universe, strong lensing images will also experience weak lensing distortions, with Einstein rings in particular supplying the notion of a ‘standardisable shape’ from which shear may be robustly measured 1 1 1 In practice, shear can be recovered even when the image is not a complete Einstein ring, though the precision of the measurement may be degraded ( Hogg et al., 2023 ) . , providing an alternative and independent probe of cosmology to the standard weak lensing shear. There is a twofold benefit to using strong lensing shear data in cosmological analyses: firstly, simply by virtue of enlarging the data vector, there will be an automatic increase in statistical power when constraining cosmological parameters with lensing data; and secondly, whilst systematic uncertainties will undoubtedly be present in such constraints, they will nonetheless be complementary, rather than additive, to the systematics present in standard weak lensing data, such as galaxy bias and intrinsic alignments. The most obvious systematics, shear and lens mass model choice and their subsequent effect on shear measurements, are the focus of this work. The idea of using strong lensing images to measure shear for cosmology was first investigated by Birrer et al. (2017) , who modelled the lens COSMOS 0038+4133 with a shear model that consisted of four parameters: two components to describe the foreground shear as projected onto the lens plane, and two components to describe the background shear as projected onto the source plane. Whilst the shear parameters were shown to be constrained with high precision, this analysis revealed strong degeneracies between the shear parameters and the components of the ellipticity of the lens mass. This implies that, with this model, the constraints on the shear cannot be disentangled from the constraints on the lens mass, and the measurements cannot be safely used to obtain cosmological information. Fleury et al. (2021) developed the minimal line-of-sight shear model to address this problem. Starting with three separate shears, the model exploits a source-position transformation to build a shear parameter, the ‘line-of-sight (LOS) shear’, which is mathematically free from degeneracy with ellipticity in the lens mass. The model fully describes the problem with the fewest possible parameters, and is therefore called the minimal LOS shear model – we will review the formalism behind this model in more detail below. Thanks to this freedom from degeneracies, it is the LOS shear in the minimal model that should be targeted for eventual cosmological inference. It was shown by Hogg et al. (2023) that the LOS shear is indeed free from degeneracies with lens model parameters using mock strong lensing images. It is therefore timely to attempt to measure this quantity in real strong lens imaging data. A further motivation of this work is to explore the effect of different shear and mass model parametrisations, in light of the findings of Etherington and others (2024) , who showed that external shear magnitudes in some strong lenses are suspiciously large. They proposed that unmodelled complexity in the lens mass may be the reason for this. We therefore explore the role of foreground shear in the minimal LOS model, as well as octupolar distortions in the lens mass, in the sample of lenses studied in this work. We note that a number of previous works have also investigated shear systematics in various contexts; for example, Witt and Mao (1997) and Gomer and Williams (2018) studied quadruply imaged systems at the individual and population level, finding that image positions cannot be reproduced in the absence of significant external shear; Wong et al. (2011) studied the local environments of six quads to estimate external shear, finding discrepancies in the magnitude and direction compared to the shears obtained from lens modelling in three of the six cases. Gomer and Williams (2021) showed with mock images that using a purely elliptical mass model plus shear

Read the complete text