Hamiltonian chaos for one particle with two waves: Self-consistent dynamics
Matheus J. Lazarotto, Iberê L. Caldas, Yves Elskens · 2025
Read Hamiltonian chaos for one particle with two waves: Self-consistent dynamics by Matheus J. Lazarotto, Iberê L. Caldas, Yves Elskens (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16260.txt.
Introduction
A particle pushed by two waves can settle into step with them or wander into chaos, and when the particle pushes back the dance grows richer. Lazarotto, Caldas, and Elskens studied that self-consistent system in 2025 in its Hamiltonian form. They focused on the locked states, where particle and waves hold fixed relations, and how energy and momentum pass between them.
The model's nonlinearity lets each wave rest at several possible strengths, and the team maps the structure that produces those states. Orderly motion dominates most settings they tried; chaos appears only in narrow slices of the parameters. The paper explains the mechanism that tips the system from one regime to the other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matheus J. Lazarotto, Iberê L. Caldas, Yves Elskens |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16260
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hamiltonian chaos for one particle with two waves: Self-consistent dynamics Preprint: APS/diffusion Matheus J. Lazarotto, Iberê L. Caldas, Yves Elskens Abstract A simple model of wave-particle interaction is studied in its self-consistent form, that is, where the particles are allowed to feedback on the waves dynamics. We focus on the configurations of locked solutions (equilibria) and how the energy-momentum exchange mechanism induces chaos in the model. As we explore the system, we analyse the mathematical structure that gives rise to locked states and how the model’s non-linearity enables multiple equilibrium amplitudes for waves. We also explain the predominance of regularity as we vary the control parameters and the mechanism behind the emergence of chaos under limited parameter choices. When modeling physical systems composed of waves and particles, it is often assumed that the latter are subject to the influence of the former, but not the other way around. In this work, we investigate the effect of considering the mutual interaction between waves and particles, resulting in a self-consistent dynamics. With a Hamiltonian model of the system, we consider the case of one particle interacting with two waves. We first reduce the equations from a 6-dimensional problem to a 4-dimensional one, with one constant of the motion, enabling better handling of equations and visualization of their solutions. While previous studies analyzed how a particle influenced by two free waves – i.e. without mutual interaction – behaves chaotically, here we discuss how the particle serves as a mediator, enabling the exchange of energy and momentum between the waves and propagating its chaotic motion through their evolution. Moreover, we find that several locked states, where both waves travel in equilibrium with the particle, can exist for the same total momentum and energy. I Introduction When describing a plasma on a microscopic scale, a fundamental process is the interaction between its particles (electrons and ions) and waves propagating in the plasma Yves_book ; Escande_1 . In the particular limit of collisionless plasmas, that is when the time scale of particle ‘collisions’ is much longer than the time scale of the interaction with waves, the energy and momentum exchange between particles and waves becomes relevant to the point of generating instabilities, favoring wave amplification or particle acceleration Balescu . For instance, this scenario can be experimentally reproduced in traveling wave tubes (TWT), where a beam of electrons interacts with electrostatic waves in a controllable environment Doveil_1 ; Sousa . This setup enables the analysis of chaotic interactions due to the energy-momentum exchange that may lead to instabilities and further turbulence in plasmas, which in turn correlates to the emergence of chaotic regions in phase space. This chaotic transition can be caused by resonance overlap of waves, nonlinear synchronization by a single nonresonant wave or the ‘devil’s staircase’ mechanism, causing a spread of the velocity distribution of the beam Doveil_2 ; Ott . Stability islands on the other hand can correlate with coherent particle acceleration (beam trapping), and the breaking of barriers (invariant tori in the one-particle phase space) allowing for new ways of chaos control. When modeling such scenarios, the Langmuir waves, that is the collective vibration of electrons in presence of much heavier ions that neutralize the system, are found to be coupled with quasi-resonant particles (i.e. electron’s velocity being close to waves phase velocity) Smith . Thus, for simplicity, the usual Hamiltonian models initially consider only the effect of waves on the particles. To give a step ahead, the re-interaction of the particles with the waves can be taken into account, therewith making the dynamics self-consistent Yves_book ; Escande_1 ; Besse . Consequently, electrons (and ions) do not play just the role of test particles but instead promote energy-momentum exchange with the waves, allowing for the aforementioned nonlinear phenomena. To model it, one can consider M independent Langmuir waves behaving as harmonic oscillators and N quasi-resonant free charged particles, with the addition of a coupling term for each wave-particle pair ONeil ; Onishchenko ; Mynick . Gomes et al. Gomes considered two of the simplest cases, namely that of one wave and one particle ( M=1,N=1 ), which is analytically treatable and shows the electron either being trapped (strong resonance) or passing through wave potential wells Adam ; Castillo-Negrete , and the case of one wave interacting with two particles ( M=1,N=2 ), that presents chaotic behavior. We direct the reader to the work of Gomes et al. Gomes for a simple yet broad introduction on the experimental context, modeling and applications of wave-particle dynamics. In this sense, our work is complementary to Gomes’ work, for we consider the remaining case of two waves interacting with one particle ( M=2,N=1 ), aiming to a simple description of the interaction between waves and particles. By studying these simplest cases, one may shed light on the microscopic mechanisms that induce chaos in the macroscopic system and how to prevent (or allow) it. In the current work, for instance, it is shown that equilibrium solutions only come in locked configurations allowing for multiple unstable wave amplitudes combinations. The emergence of chaos in the system is predominantly due to separatrix chaos related to the parameter limit where the non-linear coupling produces energy-momentum exchange. In what follows, Sec. II.1 starts by presenting the generic wave-particle self-consistent Hamiltonian model and Sec. II.2 the particular case studied here (for M=2,N=1 ), along with its mathematical simplification to reduce the number of degrees of freedom and number of parameters. Sec. III presents a global analysis of the equilibrium solutions in parameter space. Sec. IV discusses the emergence of chaos in phase space and the integrable limits of the system. Appendix sections provide more details on the model parameter simplifications, the stability of equilibrium solutions, and the decoupling limit of the system equations of motion. II The wave-particle Hamiltonian II.1 The generic model Within the context of Langmuir waves interacting with ions in plasmas, one can model the self-consistent dynamics of N identical particles traveling in a periodically bounded interval of length L via a coupling with M longitudinal waves. Each particle is described by generalized coordinate-momentum pairs ( x_{i},p_{i} ) and each wave written in phasor formulation as Z_{j}=X_{j}+{\rm i}Y_{j}=\sqrt{2I_{j}}\,\mathrm{e}^{-{\rm i}\theta_{j}} , with either cartesian ( X_{j},Y_{j} ) or polar ( \theta_{j},I_{j} ) canonical variables. Within this interval, wave numbers are given by k_{j}=\frac{2\pi j}{L} , for j\in\mathbb{Z} , and natural frequencies by \omega_{0j} . The system’s Hamiltonian is then Yves_book ; Escande_1 \begin{split}H_{\textrm{sc}}^{N,M}=&\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{p_{i}^{2}}{2m}+\sum_{j=1}^{M}\omega_{0j}\frac{X_{j}^{2}+Y_{j}^{2}}{2}\\ &+\epsilon\sum_{i=1}^{N}\sum_{j=1}^{M}\frac{\beta_{j}}{k_{j}}\left(Y_{j}\sin(k_{j}x_{i})-X_{j}\cos(k_{j}x_{i})\right),\end{split} (1) or equivalently in polar-phasor coordinates \begin{split}H_{\textrm{sc}}^{N,M}=&\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{p_{i}^{2}}{2m}+\sum_{j=1}^{M}\omega_{0j}I_{j}\\ &-\epsilon\sum_{i=1}^{N}\sum_{j=1}^{M}\frac{\beta_{j}}{k_{j}}\sqrt{2I_{j}}\cos(k_{j}x_{i}-\theta_{j}),\end{split} (2) with \beta_{j} as a coupling constant with the j th-wave and \epsilon an overall coupling scale. For the wave degrees of freedom, X_{j} and \theta_{j} are treated as coordinates with Y_{j} and I_{j} as their respective conjugate momenta. The Hamiltonian H_{\textrm{sc}}^{N,M} comprises three contributions: the free motion (kinetic energy) of particles ( m>0 ); the harmonic oscillation of waves ( \omega_{0j}>0 ); and the coupling between particles and waves. Furthermore, the Hamiltonian H_{\textrm{sc}}^{N,M} is invariant under translations in time and in space, so that the total energy E=H_{\textrm{sc}}^{N,M} and the total momentum P=\sum_{i=1}^{N}p_{i}+\sum_{j=1}^{M}k_{j}I_{j} are conserved. The latter constant reveals that the growth or decay of a wave with positive phase velocity ( \frac{\omega_{0j}}{k_{j}}>0 ) is directly balanced