Revisiting the phonon theory of liquid heat capacity: low-frequency shear modes and intramolecular vibrations
Yu Liu 1, Matteo Baggioli 2,3,4 · 2025
Read Revisiting the phonon theory of liquid heat capacity: low-frequency shear modes and intramolecular vibrations by Yu Liu 1, Matteo Baggioli 2,3,4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-16187.txt.
Introduction
Yu Liu and Matteo Baggioli revisit the phonon theory of liquid heat capacity. Their 2025 paper notes that liquids are hard to model due to strong interactions and wandering particles. The phonon theory treats liquid motion as solid-like, with fair success so far.
Two gaps draw focus. The theory assumes low-frequency shear waves spread like sound with a standard density law, which is doubtful. It also omits vibrations inside molecules, a large term for molecular liquids. The authors try rival views of the low modes: pure motion terms, or damped liquid-like modes with a linear density law. Damped modes match heat data best across all temperatures. Pure gas-like treatment fails badly when hot.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yu Liu 1, Matteo Baggioli 2,3,4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-16187
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting the phonon theory of liquid heat capacity: low-frequency shear modes and intramolecular vibrations Yu Liu 1, Matteo Baggioli 2,3,4 Abstract Modeling the heat capacity of liquids present fundamental difficulties due to the strong intermolecular particle interactions and large diffusive-like displacements. Based on the experimental evidence that the microscopic dynamics of liquids closely resemble those of solids, a phonon theory of liquid thermodynamics has been developed. Despite its success, the phonon theory of liquids relies on the questionable assumption that low-frequency shear excitations are propagating in nature and follow a Debye density of states. Furthermore, the same framework does not capture the contribution of intramolecular vibrations, which play a significant role in molecular liquids. In this work, we revisit the phonon theory of liquid heat capacity, introducing alternative approaches to model low-frequency shear modes. In particular, we consider the recently proposed idea of treating such modes as pure kinetic and we propose a novel approach based on identifying those low-frequency excitations as overdamped liquid-like modes with linear in frequency density of states. Moreover, we complete the theory by incorporating the effects of intramolecular vibrations. By comparing the theoretical predictions from these different approaches with the available data for the heat capacity of several liquids, we present a comprehensive evaluation of the original model and the newly proposed extensions. Despite all approaches perform well at low-temperatures, our results indicate that modeling low-frequency modes as overdamped liquid-like excitations yields the most accurate agreement with the data in the whole temperature range. Conversely, we demonstrate that treating these excitations as purely gas-like leads to significant inaccuracies, particularly at high temperatures. Introduction Heat capacity (or specific heat) c_{v} is a fundamental thermodynamic property of matter. Among the various phases of matter, the heat capacity of (crystalline) solids and gases, and in particular its temperature dependence, are well-understood and indeed successfully described by phonon (Debye) theory Ashcroft and Mermin 1976 and kinetic theory Kauzmann 2012 . Using these formalisms, it is straigthfroward to derive for example that the heat capacity of a monoatomic gas equals c_{v}=3R/2 , with R the ideal gas constant. On the other hand, one can also obtain that the heat capacity of harmonic crystals at high-temperature ( i.e. , in the classical limit above the Debye temperature) is given by the Dulong-Petit law, c_{v}=3R . However, when it comes to liquids, these formalisms incur in several difficulties, leaving the theoretical modeling of the liquid heat capacity as an open question (see for example Trachenko 2008 ). Panel (a) in Fig. 1 shows the heat capacities of several typical liquids taken from the NIST REFPROP database Lemmon et al. 2013 . Overall, the larger the molecular weight, the greater the heat capacity. Moreover, the specific heat of molecular liquids is generally higher than that of monatomic liquids. In addition, it can be observed that for liquids with simple structure, such as Ar, CO, CH 4 , their heat capacities show a decreasing trend with temperature, opposite to the typical behavior in solids. This trend could have been anticipated by extrapolating c_{v} between the high-temperature solid value ( c_{v}=3R ) and the gas-like limit ( c_{v}=3/2R ). Nevertheless, there are some fluids, like CO 2 , for which their heat capacity decreases firstly and then goes up with temperature. Finally, as shown in panel (b) of Fig. 1 , more complex liquids, such as n-pentane (C 5 H 12 ), display a heat capacity monotonically increasing with temperature. In summary, liquids with different structures exhibit different dependencies of the heat capacity on temperature, which makes it difficult to propose a general model for the heat capacity of liquids. Figure 1: (a) Heat capacity of several liquids as a function of temperature T . Data are taken from the NIST REFPROP database Lemmon et al. 2013 . Panel (b) shows the case of n-pentane (C 5 H 12 ) as a representative liquid for which c_{v} grows monotonically with T . Currently, there are different approaches for studying the heat capacity of liquids. One of them approximates liquids with gas-like models focusing on the equation of state (EoS) Sengers et al. 2000 ; Setzmann and Wagner 1991 or using massive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations Todorov et al. 2006 . The equation of state is, in fact, the most conventional method to calculate liquid heat capacity. It is usually expressed as an empirical relation between temperature and pressure, where the empirical parameters are determined by fitting the experimental data. Despite the computational accuracy of this method could be satisfactory, this approach leaves the physical picture completely unclear. Furthermore, the extrapolation performance cannot be guaranteed in high temperature/pressure regions where experimental data are unavailable. As regard to molecular dynamics, due to the strong intermolecular interactions in liquids and their significant dependence on the specific molecular structure, it is very complex and difficult to solve this problem strictly based on interactions and correlation functions. In practical applications, simple forms for the particle interactions (such as pair potential) are often applied to reduce computational difficulty, but this often results in inaccurate predictions. For instance, the uncertainty in calculating the heat capacity of C 3 H 2 F 4 can be as high as 30 % Raabe and Maginn 2010 . A second interesting approach to model liquid thermodynamics is the expression of the excess internal energy and specific heat proposed by Rosenfeld and Tarazona Rosenfeld and Tarazona 1998 using density functional theory and perturbation theory. This method predicts a power-law decay of the excess isochoric heat capacity c_{v}^{ex}\sim T^{-2/5} , which is in good agreement with experimental data, specially for liquids with strong correlations between equilibrium fluctuations of virial and potential energy Ingebrigtsen et al. 2013 . Still this path does not make any reference to the degrees of freedom responsible for the heat capacity of liquids, leaving the physical mechanism behind liquid heat capacity undetermined. Moreover, many systems display a rather different power-law decay (see e.g. Khrapak and Khrapak 2024 ) that is not captured by the model of Rosenfeld and Tarazona. Another successful direction is based on the so-called two-phase model of liquid thermodynamics Lin et al. 2003 ; Pascal et al. 2011 that idealizes a liquid as a superposition of gas-like and solid-like degrees of freedom. The main difficulty in this model is the determination of the fluidity parameter that determines the ratio between the number of these two types of degrees of freedom. We notice that this idea has been recently revisited using instantaneous normal modes Moon et al. 2023 , deriving this fluidity parameter from the fraction of stable and unstable modes (see also Moon for a recent book on the nature of ‘ normal modes ’ in liquids). At the same time, unstable instantaneous normal modes have been proposed as the microscopic origin of the temperature decay of the liquid heat capacity as well Baggioli and Zaccone 2021 . Finally, another approach, and the primary focus of this work, involves studying liquids from a solid-state perspective by adapting the phonon theory of solids to liquids (see Trachenko 2023a for a comprehensive historical overview). The core idea of this model lies in the shared characteristics of collective excitations in both liquids and solids.