A Retrodictive Approach to Quantum State Smoothing

Mingxuan Liu, Valerio Scarani, Alexia Auffèves, Kiarn T. Laverick · 2025

Read A Retrodictive Approach to Quantum State Smoothing by Mingxuan Liu, Valerio Scarani, Alexia Auffèves, Kiarn T. Laverick (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15986.txt.

Introduction

Mingxuan Liu, Valerio Scarani, Alexia Auffeves, and Kiarn Laverick redefine quantum state smoothing in a 2025 paper, with two author names carrying diacritics. Smoothing estimates the state of a watched quantum system using measurements from both before and after the moment of interest. Existing quantum versions either return unphysical states or assume unverifiable things about the environment doing the watching.

Their definition borrows the classical backward looking idea through quantum Bayesian retrodiction. It always returns physical states and assumes nothing about the environment. On average, its state is purer than the one built from earlier data alone. The authors also connect their state to a known smoothing theory in a studied regime, showing how it absorbs the later information.

Catalog record

CREATORMingxuan Liu, Valerio Scarani, Alexia Auffèves, Kiarn T. Laverick
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15986

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Retrodictive Approach to Quantum State Smoothing Mingxuan Liu, Valerio Scarani, Alexia Auffèves, Kiarn T. Laverick Abstract Smoothing is a technique for estimating the state of an imperfectly monitored open system by combining both prior and posterior measurement information. In the quantum regime, current approaches to smoothing either give unphysical outcomes, due to the non-commutativity of the measurements at different times, or require assumptions about how the environment is measuring the system, which with current technology is unverifiable. We propose a novel definition of the smoothed quantum state based on quantum Bayesian retrodiction, which mirrors the classical retrodictive approach to smoothing. This approach always yields physical results and does not require any assumption on the environment. We show that this smoothed state has, on average, greater purity than the state reconstructed using just the prior information. Finally, we make a connection with the smoothing theory of Guevara and Wiseman in a well-studied regime, and describe from a purely quantum perspective how it conditions on the posterior information. Smoothing [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , and a related technique called filtering [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] , are estimation techniques that apply to dynamic open systems under continuous-in-time measurements, aiming at constructing an estimate of the system state at any time t based the measurement record. Filtering takes into account only the record prior to t , while smoothing uses the record both prior and posterior to t . Thus smoothing generally yields a state with a lower entropy than filtering due to the additional measurement information. Computing the smoothed state in the classical setting is rather simple. By contrast, defining the analogue of the smoothed state in quantum systems has been the subject of debate over the past decade and a half [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . The first attempt at defining a smoothed quantum state can be traced back to well before the modern debate [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] . The explicit connection to smoothing was made by Tsang in 2009 [ 10 ] . This ‘state’ (first made explicit in the Supplementary of Ref. [ 13 ] and latter symmetrized in Ref. [ 22 ] ), however, yields unphysical results in general. The reason for this is the non-commutativity of the operators describing the future measurement outcomes and the quantum analogue of the filtered state. This operator has been referred to as the smoothed weak-value state, due to its connections to the anomalous weak values of Aharonov et al. [ 23 ] . The current approach to quantum state smoothing was formulated in 2015 by Guevara and Wiseman [ 15 ] . They first noticed that the smoothing problem only makes sense when there is still information missing from the filtered state ( i.e. , it is not pure). They then defined the quantum state of maximal knowledge that one is aiming to estimate, called the true quantum state of the system. To do so, they consider an open quantum system undergoing imperfect continuous-in-time measurement by Alice, who obtains a record {\bf O} . A second observer, Bob, measures the remainder (or some subset thereof) of the environment, obtaining a record {\bf U} that is unknown to Alice. The true state at time t is defined as the filtered quantum state obtained by conditioning on the past records, \overleftarrow{\bf O}_{t} and \overleftarrow{\bf U}_{t} . With the true state defined, the standard filtered quantum state from Alice’s perspective (as given by quantum trajectory theory [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] ) is a classical mixture over the set of possible true states, specified by Alice’s past record \overleftarrow{\bf O}_{t} . Finally, they defined the smoothed quantum state similarly: a classical mixture over the set of possible true states, specified by Alice’s past and future records \overleftrightarrow{\bf O} . It is easy to see that this state is always physical. Numerous properties of the Guevara-Wiseman approach have since been discovered, from the optimality [ 27 ] of the state to the best measurement unravelings for smoothing [ 28 , 22 ] . The approach has also been applied to the specific class of linear Gaussian quantum systems [ 29 ] . However, their smoothed quantum state depends on the particular measurement unraveling chosen by Bob [ 15 , 28 , 22 , 18 ] . The approach thus applies exactly only in the rather artificial setting, in which there are actually two observers measuring the totality of the system. In the more usual setting where the role of Bob is played by the environment, the definition of the true state requires committing to a definition of the environment’s true behaviour, which is an extra assumption. In either case, computing the smoothed state requires going through all possible trajectories, which can only be done, in general, approximately and numerically. In this Letter, we provide an alternative resolution to the debate. We derive a novel solution to the quantum smoothing problem, which is always a valid quantum state and does not require any Bob or any description of the remaining environment. The approach we take is based on an alternative way of looking at the classical smoothing theory as a form of Bayesian retrodiction. For retrodiction we use the Petz recovery map [ 30 , 31 ] . The resulting smoothed state has a very simple analytical, closed-form expression, first obtained by Fuchs as the analog of the Bayes’ rule for a quantum measurement [ 32 ] ; thus, we call our construction the Petz-Fuchs smoothed quantum state . It also satisfies all the desirable properties of a quantum state smoothing theory [ 33 ] . On the canonical example of a resonantly driven qubit coupled to a thermal bosonic environment [ 34 , 26 ] , we show that the Petz-Fuchs smoothed state, on average, yields a purer estimate than filtering, indicating that it, in general, gives a more refined reconstruction of the dynamics than does the filtered state. We conclude by connecting our approach with previous ones, notably the Guevara-Wiseman approach. Classical Retrodictive Smoothing. —We begin by reviewing the classical theory of smoothing, highlighting its connection to Bayesian retrodiction. Consider an open classical dynamical system described by a vector of parameters {\bf x} . For simplicity, we will assume that the elements x_{i} are discrete variables taking values in a set {\mathbb{X}} . The value of {\bf x} is stochastic and generally unknown due to the interactions with the environment, therefore, we can only describe the system probabilistically \wp({\bf x};t) . The dynamics of this classical state \wp({\bf x};t) are assumed to be Markovian, governed by the rate equation [ 35 , 8 , 36 ] \wp({\bf x}^{\prime};t+{\rm d}t)=\sum_{{\bf x}\in{\mathbb{X}}}\varphi({\bf x}^{\prime};t+{\rm d}t|{\bf x};t)\wp({\bf x};t)\,, (1) with initial condition \wp({\bf x};t_{0}) . The dynamical matrix must satisfy the completeness condition \sum_{{\bf x}^{\prime}\in{\mathbb{X}}}\varphi({\bf x}^{\prime};t+{\rm d}t|{\bf x};t)=1 . Without any additional information about the system, this is the most accurate description possible. If we have access to the outcomes of a continuous-in-time measurement, generally imperfect, we can refine our description of the system by

Read the complete text