Absence of two-phonon quasi-elastic scattering in the normal state of doped–SrTiO 3 by THz pump-probe spectroscopy

K. Santhosh Kumar, David Barbalas, Rishi Bhandia, Dooyong Lee, Shivasheesh Varshney, Bharat Jalan, N. P. Armitage · 2025

Read Absence of two-phonon quasi-elastic scattering in the normal state of doped–SrTiO 3 by THz pump-probe spectroscopy by K. Santhosh Kumar, David Barbalas, Rishi Bhandia, Dooyong Lee, Shivasheesh Varshney, Bharat Jalan, N. P. Armitage (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15771.txt.

Introduction

Santhosh Kumar and co-authors probe heat flow in a doped crystal metal in a 2025 paper. Doped strontium titanate is a thin metal with odd traits. Its drag grows with the square of heat grade, a mark oft blamed on soft sound wave pairs. Pump-probe terahertz reads gave a sharp test of that tale. A strong third-order reply showed in the cold zone where the square law holds.

One slow drain rate rules the reply, far shy of the drag rates from light reads. That drain speeds as heat climbs, so its source gives up real energy, not soft grazes. Soft pair grazes thus fail as the drag's main well, the team say. Charge-charge hits fit the square law in their place.

Catalog record

CREATORK. Santhosh Kumar, David Barbalas, Rishi Bhandia, Dooyong Lee, Shivasheesh Varshney, Bharat Jalan, N. P. Armitage
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15771

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Absence of two-phonon quasi-elastic scattering in the normal state of doped–SrTiO 3 by THz pump-probe spectroscopy K. Santhosh Kumar, David Barbalas, Rishi Bhandia, Dooyong Lee, Shivasheesh Varshney, Bharat Jalan, N. P. Armitage Abstract Multi-pulse nonlinear THz spectroscopies enable a new understanding of interacting metallic systems via their sensitivity to novel correlation functions. Here, we investigated the THz nonlinear properties of the dilute metallic phase of doped-SrTiO 3 thin films using nonlinear terahertz 2D coherent spectroscopy. We observed a large χ ( 3 ) \chi^{(3)} response in the low temperature region where the dc electrical resistivity follows a T 2 -dependence. This is largely a pump-probe response, which we find is governed by a single energy relaxation rate that is much smaller at all temperatures than the momentum relaxation rates obtained from the optical conductivity. This indicates that the processes that dominate the resistive scattering are not the same as those that remove energy from the electronic system. Moreover the fact that the energy relaxation rate is an increasing function of temperature indicates that the excitations that do carry away energy from the electronic system cannot be considered as quasi-elastic and as such soft two-phonon electron scattering does not play a major role in the physics as proposed. This indicates that these materials’ resistive T 2 scattering likely originates in electron-electron interactions despite the very small Fermi wave vectors at the lowest dopings. The temperature dependence of a metal’s electrical resistivity is governed by various types of charge scattering. The low-temperature resistivity of many metals exhibits a dependence \rho(T)=\rho_{0}+A T 2 , where A is a material specific parameter and \rho_{0} is the residual resistivity. T 2 -resistivity arises in conventional metals due to momentum-relaxing electron-electron scattering of either the umklapp variety or Baber’s mechanism of scattering between different anisotropic parts of a Fermi surface Landau 1956 ; Baber 1937 . Normal electron-electron scattering does not relax momentum. Materials with quadratic temperature dependent resistivity have been observed frequently in many interacting fermionic systems, including Sr 2 RuO 4 Barber et al. 2018 ; Stricker et al. 2014 , heavy fermion compounds Pethick et al. 1986 , iron pnictides Rullier-Albenque et al. 2012 ; Taufour et al. 2014 , and even the thermal resistivity in 3 He Behnia 2022 . The interaction itself can be of the direct Coulomb interaction or phonon mediated variety MacDonald 1980 ; Van Der Marel et al. 2011 ; Klimin et al. 2012 . T 2 scattering is quite generic as it arises from phase space considerations of fermion scattering near E F . However, there are also many metals that show anomalous non-Fermi liquid properties in their transport at low temperatures e.g. exponents of temperature’s power law behavior less than two Schofield 1999 ; Stewart 2001 . In this regard it is important to investigate the robustness of Fermi liquid states and departures from canonical behavior. Doped-SrTiO 3 may be said to be the first unconventional oxide superconductor and possesses a number of exceptional properties Schooley et al. 1964 . It exhibits superconductivity in the doping range of \sim 3\times 10 17 /cm 3 - 10 21 /cm 3 making it by far the most dilute carrier density superconductor Schooley et al. 1964 ; Gastiasoro et al. 2020 ; Collignon et al. 2019 . The standard BCS theory cannot simply explain the mechanism of superconductivity owing to the inversion of the relative scales of the Fermi and Debye energies Collignon et al. 2019 . It has long been suspected that there is a connection between the superconductivity in doped materials and aborted ferroelectricity in the parent compound Collignon et al. 2019 . Although undoped-SrTiO 3 approaches a ferroelectric state at low temperature, zero-point quantum fluctuations ultimately prevent long range order. Its optical spectra is dominated by a soft transverse optical (TO) phonon whose frequency does not completely go to zero at the lowest temperatures, but instead stalls out around 1.2 meV (0.29 THz) Yamada and Shirane 1969 ; Fleury and Worlock 1968 ; Van Mechelen et al. 2008 . This low frequency phonon gives a static dielectric constant of greater than 20,000 at low temperature Weaver 1959 , which undoubtedly must influence the effective interactions. The normal state of doped-SrTiO 3 is also interesting. It exhibits a T 2 dependent electrical resistivity, the coefficient of which evolves smoothly from a high density regime where multiple anisotropic bands are occupied to a low density regime where a single isotropic band is occupied Mikheev et al. 2016 ; Lin et al. 2015 ; Behnia 2022 . Although T 2 resistivity is familiar in interacting metals, it remains to be understood how a single isotropic Fermi surface with k_{F} too small to engage in umklapp processes can give electron-electron momentum non-conserving scattering. There have been proposals for a non-electronic origin of the T 2 scattering Kumar et al. 2021 ; Yu et al. 2022 . For electrons near the Brillouin zone center, scattering from a single soft TO phonon is suppressed in a single-band system with weak spin-orbit interaction. However, two-phonon scattering is allowed and has been proposed long ago as a mechanism for superconductivity Ngai 1974 . For temperatures above the soft-mode frequency its contribution to the resistivity is expected to scale with the occupation number of phonons squared , i.e., as T 2 Kumar et al. 2021 . Two-phonon scattering provides a natural scenario for non-electronic T 2 resistivity in a soft mode system. However, it is not clear that doped SrTiO 3 (and even more so the doped films of the present study) have a TO phonon soft enough to be in the equipartition regime. Moreover, a similar T 2 resistivity has also been seen in the low density metal Bi 2 O 2 Se, which has no soft phonons Wang et al. 2020 . Additionally, the observation of a Kadowaki-Woods-like scaling of the coefficient of the resistivity being \propto E_{F}^{-2} and a T 2 -dependent thermal resistivity gives evidence for an electronic contribution to the scattering Lin et al. 2015 ; Jiang et al. 2023 . However, an unconventional scaling of the relative sizes of the T 2 and \omega^{2} dependent scattering rates in our recent THz conductivity measurements indicates physics beyond conventional Fermi liquid theory Kumar et al. 2024 . Therefore, many issues remain regarding the origin of T 2 resistivity in doped-SrTiO 3 . In the present work, we implemented nonlinear THz 2D coherent spectroscopy (2DCS) to understand the energy relaxation rate in the dilute metallic phase of doped-SrTiO 3 thin films. We observed a \chi^{(3)} response, which is largest in the low temperature regime where dc electrical resistivity follows a T 2 -dependence (below 120 K). The relaxation of the THz pump-THz probe response is governed by a single relaxation time, which we can relate to the rate that energy leaves the electronic system. We find the energy relaxation rate is an increasing function of temperature, and in magnitude is much smaller than the momentum relaxation rate observed in the Drude optical conductivity. Its relative scale shows that scatterings that remove momentum from the electronic system largely do not remove energy. Moreover, the fact that the energy relaxation is an increasing function

Read the complete text