Gravity as emergent phenomena for spherically symmetric black hole accretion of multi-component flow with relativistic equation of state

Tuhin Paul, Aishee Chakraborty, Souvik Ghose, Tapas K. Das · 2025

Read Gravity as emergent phenomena for spherically symmetric black hole accretion of multi-component flow with relativistic equation of state by Tuhin Paul, Aishee Chakraborty, Souvik Ghose, Tapas K. Das (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15676.txt.

Introduction

Tuhin Paul, Aishee Chakraborty, Souvik Ghose, and Tapas Das study how matter falling into a black hole can mimic gravity itself. When gas streams steadily onto a black hole, small ripples in the flow travel like sound waves in a medium. Under the right conditions those ripples face their own horizon, a point they cannot cross, much like light at a real black hole.

The team builds steady, faster-than-sound inflow solutions for a hot, multi-species gas, using stand-in potentials for the black hole's pull, then nudges the flow to test stability. The nudges reveal an acoustic metric, a geometry for sound, with horizons they map using causal diagrams. They also track how the analogue surface gravity of that horizon shifts as the flow's settings change. The work feeds analogue gravity, the effort to study black hole physics through look-alike systems.

Catalog record

CREATORTuhin Paul, Aishee Chakraborty, Souvik Ghose, Tapas K. Das
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15676

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravity as emergent phenomena for spherically symmetric black hole accretion of multi-component flow with relativistic equation of state Tuhin Paul, Aishee Chakraborty, Souvik Ghose, Tapas K. Das Abstract We investigate analogue gravity phenomena arising as a result of the linear perturbation of the spherically symmetric accretion flows onto non rotating black holes, where the gravitational field is determined by a set of post Newtonian pseudo Schwarzschild black hole potentials and the infalling matter is described by a relativistic multi-species equation of state. The stationary transonic integral accretion solutions corresponding to the steady state of aforementioned type of accreting systems are constructed and the stability analysis of such solutions are performed through the time dependent linear perturbation of the accretion flow. Such linear stability analysis leads to the formation of a black hole like sonic metric embedded within the infalling matter. The acoustic horizons are then identified by constructing the causal structure, i.e., the Carter-Penrose diagrams. The variation of the analogue surface gravity corresponding to the aforementioned sonic metric has been studied as a function of various parameters governing the accretion flow. I Introduction Linear perturbation of transonic fluid flow leads to the emergence of a black hole like space time metric inside the fluid. Such metric is perceivable to the perturbation only, and not to the embedding fluid. Study of such emergent metric, commonly known as the sonic, or the acoustic metric, may help to experimentally realize some of the kinematic features of the general theory of relativity within the laboratory framework in terrestrial set up. Such phenomena is known as analogue gravity [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . Even for a Newtonian set up (Minkowskian background), the black hole like acoustic metric is found to mimic the properties of curved space time, and gravity may be manifested as an emergent phenomena in the aforementioned analogue space time, which may allow one to study the horizon related physics within the framework of such emergent gravity. Beyond the terrestrial set up, an analogue model of gravity can be studied for accreting black hole systems as well, where the background spacetime metric is itself curved. Accretion (see, e.g., [ 5 , 6 ] for details about the accretion processes in astrophysics) onto black holes are predominantly transonic [ 7 ] , and hence the linear perturbation of the mass accretion rate, or certain accretion variables, can generate an analogue space time embedded within the accreting fluid (see, e.g., [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] , and references therein). Study of emergent gravity (in the present paper, we shall use the phrases ‘analogue gravity’ and ‘emergent gravity’ synonymously) phenomena for accreting black holes is particularly important, since for such analogue systems, both type of horizons, the usual gravitational horizons corresponding to astrophysical black holes, and the acoustic horizons generated by the perturbation of the accreting matter, are present simultaneously. As of now, all the works present in the literature dealing with the analogue models for accreting black holes, consider the accretion flow to be adiabatic (polytropic) or isothermal, and assume the value of the adiabatic index \gamma (the ratio of the specific heats at constant pressure and constant volume, respectively, i.e., \gamma=c_{p}/c_{v} ) for the flow to be constant in space, i.e., no variation of \gamma with the radial distance (as measured from the black hole event horizon along the flow lines) has been considered in aforementioned works. Also the usual equation of state (EoS hereafter) for polytropic flow, i.e., p=K{{\rho}^{\gamma}} , where p is the fluid pressure, \rho is the density, and K is a constant which is a measure of the entropy of the flow ( [ 15 ] ), does not fully take care of the relativistic state of matter. In addition, accreting matter may consists of various species, like electron, ion, and positron. Considering all such limitations of the equation of state used to describe the accretion flow, it is tempting to introduce an equation of state which will be efficient to describe the thermodynamic properties of relativistically flowing fluid (dynamics of matter at the vicinity of compact objects, being it accreting fluid or astrophysical jets, travel with very large velocity, at a velocity comparable to the velocity of light in vacuum), as well as will be able to take care of the radial variation of the heat capacities (and thus of the corresponding polytropic index) of multi component matter. Several works addressed many of such issues ( [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] ) where attempts were made to propose a relativistic equation of state with variable \gamma , some of them also considering a multi-component fluid. Among such models, the equation of state proposed by Ryu and his collaborators [ 21 , 22 , 25 ] seems to have a relatively simple form (by maintaining all the necessary elegance to handle a relativistic flow with variable \gamma ) suitable to study transonic accretion onto compact objects. In our present work, we shall construct the stationary transonic integral accretion solutions, and draw the corresponding phase portraits for spherically symmetric flow of ideal fluid onto non rotating astrophysical black holes, where the accretion dynamics is governed by all four post Newtonian pseudo Schwarzschild black hole potentials (as proposed by [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] ) available in the literature (see, e.g., [ 29 ] for a detailed description of all such potentials), and the thermodynamics of the flow is controlled by the equation of state as described by Ryu and his collaborators ( [ 21 , 22 ] ). We then perturb the aforementioned solutions to verify whether the assumed steady state remains stable subjected to the introduction of radial perturbation. We observe that the perturbation propagates in the form of the propagation of a massless scalar field in a curved pseudo-Riemannian background, and such propagation is governed by a black hole-like acoustic metric which possesses an acoustic horizon. Causal structures (the Carter-Penrose ( [ 23 , 24 ] ) diagrams) are constructed to identify the sonic horizons and to study the horizon related properties corresponding to the sonic metric. In this way we study the spherically symmetric multi-component black hole accretion as a classical analogue gravity model for relativistic equation of state (with a more realistic description of \gamma ), which has not been done before in the literature. In the next section, following [ 21 , 22 , 25 ] , we describe the basic features of the relativistic equation of state used in our work. In subsequent sections, we describe the nature of the black hole potentials used in the work, the equations governing the dynamics of the accretion flow, and develop the solution scheme which can be used to realize the complete nature of the transonic properties of the stationary integral accretion solutions. We then provide the detailed description of our stability analysis scheme for the flow, and how the emergent gravity phenomena can be conceived from such analysis. Lastly, we define the acoustic surface gravity corresponding to the analogue metric, and will study how the value of such quantity gets

Read the complete text