Maximal WAP and tame quotients of type spaces
Krzysztof Krupiński, Adrián Portillo · 2025
Read Maximal WAP and tame quotients of type spaces by Krzysztof Krupiński, Adrián Portillo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15632.txt.
Introduction
Krupiński and Portillo present a 2025 paper in model theory, a branch of mathematical logic. They study spaces of types, which collect all consistent descriptions of objects in a large ideal model. Two quotients of those spaces matter for dynamics: the WAP quotient and the tame quotient. Each is the finest split that keeps a group action well behaved in its own sense.
The authors ask what happens when the ideal model grows bigger. They prove the two quotients behave well under that growth. The restriction map from the bigger space carries each quotient exactly onto its smaller twin. The result steadies these tools for work across different model sizes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Krzysztof Krupiński, Adrián Portillo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 116 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15632
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Maximal WAP and tame quotients of type spaces Thanks: Both authors are supported by the Narodowe Centrum Nauki grant no. 2016/22/E/ST1/00450. Krzysztof Krupiński, Adrián Portillo Abstract . We study maximal WAP and tame (in the sense of topological dynamics) quotients of S X ( ℭ ) S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) , where ℭ {\mathfrak{C}} is a sufficiently saturated (called monster) model of a complete theory T T , X X is a ∅ \emptyset -type-definable set, and S X ( ℭ ) S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) is the space of complete types over ℭ {\mathfrak{C}} concentrated on X X . Namely, let F WAP ⊆ S X ( ℭ ) × S X ( ℭ ) F_{\textrm{WAP}}\subseteq S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})\times S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) be the finest closed, {Aut} ( ℭ ) \aut({\mathfrak{C}}) -invariant equivalence relation on S X ( ℭ ) S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) such that the flow ( {Aut} ( ℭ ) , S X ( ℭ ) / F WAP ) (\aut({\mathfrak{C}}),S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})/F_{\textrm{WAP}}) is WAP, and let F Tame ⊆ S X ( ℭ ) × S X ( ℭ ) F_{\textrm{Tame}}\subseteq S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})\times S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) be the finest closed, {Aut} ( ℭ ) \aut({\mathfrak{C}}) -invariant equivalence relation on S X ( ℭ ) S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) such that the flow ( {Aut} ( ℭ ) , S X ( ℭ ) / F Tame ) (\aut({\mathfrak{C}}),S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})/F_{\textrm{Tame}}) is tame. We show good behaviour of F WAP F_{\textrm{WAP}} and F Tame F_{\textrm{Tame}} under changing the monster model ℭ {\mathfrak{C}} . Namely, we prove that if ℭ ′ ≻ ℭ {\mathfrak{C}}^{\prime}\succ{\mathfrak{C}} is a bigger monster model, F WAP ′ F^{\prime}_{\textrm{WAP}} and F Tame ′ F^{\prime}_{\textrm{Tame}} are the counterparts of F WAP F_{\textrm{WAP}} and F Tame F_{\textrm{Tame}} computed for ℭ ′ {\mathfrak{C}}^{\prime} , and r : S X ( ℭ ′ ) → S X ( ℭ ) r\colon S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}^{\prime})\to S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}}) is the restriction map, then r [ F WAP ′ ] = F WAP r[F^{\prime}_{\textrm{WAP}}]=F_{\textrm{WAP}} and r [ F Tame ′ ] = F Tame r[F^{\prime}_{\textrm{Tame}}]=F_{\textrm{Tame}} . Using these results, we show that the Ellis (or ideal) groups of ( {Aut} ( ℭ ) , S X ( ℭ ) / F WAP ) (\aut({\mathfrak{C}}),S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})/F_{\textrm{WAP}}) and ( {Aut} ( ℭ ) , S X ( ℭ ) / F Tame ) (\aut({\mathfrak{C}}),S_{X}({\mathfrak{C}})/F_{\textrm{Tame}}) do not depend on the choice of the monster model ℭ {\mathfrak{C}} . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 03C45, 37B02, 37B05. 1. Introduction The project is to study maximal WAP and tame quotients (in the sense of topological dynamics) of type spaces over sufficiently saturated models (in the sense of model theory). In this paper, we show the fundamental property of “model-theoretic absoluteness” of Ellis groups of such quotients, i.e., that they do not depend on the model for which they are computed. Recall that a flow is pair (G,X) , where G is a topological group acting continuously on a compact (Hausdorff) space X . The essential for this paper terms appearing in this introduction are defined in Section 2 . Weakly almost periodic (or WAP ) flows form a well-behaved family, playing a fundamental role in topological dynamics with applications to other areas, e.g. to ergodic theory (see [ EN89 ] ). The minimal WAP flows are known to be equicontinuous and have been been classified as homogeneous spaces for compact groups [ Aus88 , Chapter 3, Theorem 6] . Tame flows , originating in [ Kö95 ] , form a wider important family, intensively studied in recent two decades by Glasner, Megrelishvili, and others (see e.g. [ Gla07 , GM13 , Gla18 , GM18 ] ). In the case of metrizibale flows, tameness corresponds to one of the two situations in the so-called dynamical Bourgain, Fremlin, Talagrand dichotomy (see [ GM04 , Theorem 3.2] ). A deep structure theorem on tame, metrizable, minimal flows was obtained by Glasner in [ Gla18 ] . Tame flows are related to several other areas, e.g. Banach spaces, circularly ordered systems, substitutions and tilings, quasicrystals, cut and project schemes (so to the so-called theory of aperiodic order); see [ Auj15 ] and the survey [ GM13 ] . From the point of view of this paper, it is important that there exist direct correspondences between model-theoretic stability and WAP flows (discovered in [ BY14 , BYT16 ] , see also [ Con21 , HKP22 ] ), and between model-theoretic NIP and tame flows (discovered independently in [ CS18 ] , [ Iba16 ] , and [ Kha20 ] , and further developed e.g. in [ KR20 ] and [ CH23 ] ). One of the well-known forms of these kind of correspondences is that stability [resp. NIP] of a theory T is equivalent to saying that all flows of the form (\aut(M),S(M)) (where M is a model of T , \aut(M) is the group of automorphisms of M , and S(M) is the space of complete types over M in a fixed tuple of variables) are WAP [resp. tame] (e.g., see [ KR20 , Section 5] ). Stability theory is the core of model theory [ She90 , Pil96 ] , and in the last three decades model theory has been focusing on extending the context of stability theory to wider classes of theories, which often requires new ideas and tools, and has applications to other branches of mathematics (e.g. to algebraic geometry and additive combinatorics). And one of the most deeply studied classes of theories extending stable theories is the class of theories with NIP (the non independence property); e.g., see [ She05 , HPP08 , HP11 , CS18 ] . Around 2005, Newelski came up with an idea of using tools from topological dynamics in order to extend some aspects of stability theory to much wider unstable situations [ New09 ] . The point is that various spaces of types can be naturally treated as flows and so become objects of topological dynamics. Since then, the topic has been broadened by a multitude of authors: Ben Yaacov, Chernikov, Hrushovski, Krupiński, Newelski, Pillay, Rzepecki, Simon, and others (e.g., [ CS18 , BYT16 , KNS19 , KPR18 , Pil13 ] ). This led not only to essentially new results in model theory (e.g. on the complexity of strong types in [ KPR18 , KR20 ] ) but also to applications to additive combinatorics in [ KP23a ] . Both in topological dynamics and in model theory, it is natural to study quotients by suitable equivalence relations. In topological dynamics, these are quotients of flows by closed, invariant equivalence relations (equivalently, homomorphic images of flows). In model theory, these are quotients of a sufficiently saturated model (or a subset of such a model) by nice (definable, type-definable, invariant, …) equivalence relations. This includes strong types, hyperimaginary sorts, or quotients of definable groups by various model-theoretic connected components. A particular role is played by quotients by bounded (i.e. with few classes comparing to the degree of saturation of the model) equivalence relations; see e.g. [ LP01 , HPP08 , HP11 , KPR18 ] . In recent papers [ HP18 , KP22 , KP23 ] , also maximal stable quotients entered the picture, mostly in the NIP context.