Mode transitions and spoke structures in ๐ ร ๐ \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} Penning discharge
M. Tyushev, M. Papahn Zadeh, N. S. Chopra, Y. Raitses, I. Romadanov, A. Likhanskii, G. Fubiani, L. Garrigues, R. Groenewald, A. Smolyakov ยท 2025
Read Mode transitions and spoke structures in ๐ ร ๐ \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} Penning discharge by M. Tyushev, M. Papahn Zadeh, N. S. Chopra, Y. Raitses, I. Romadanov, A. Likhanskii, G. Fubiani, L. Garrigues, R. Groenewald, A. Smolyakov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15620.txt.
Introduction
Tyushev and co-authors simulate, in a 2025 physics paper, pattern shifts inside a Penning discharge, a plasma held between electric and magnetic fields. An electron beam along the magnetic field keeps the low-pressure plasma alight. The discharge forms rotating structures whose shape depends on the field strength.
Running two-dimensional particle simulations, the team watched the patterns change step by step. At weak fields, multi-armed spirals appeared as confinement improved and the density profile sharpened. Stronger fields replaced the spirals with a single spoke mode. The transitions follow a clear sequence the simulations map out. Understanding these modes matters for plasma devices, where such structures can help or hinder performance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Tyushev, M. Papahn Zadeh, N. S. Chopra, Y. Raitses, I. Romadanov, A. Likhanskii, G. Fubiani, L. Garrigues, R. Groenewald, A. Smolyakov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15620
Browse the full library ยท About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mode transitions and spoke structures in ๐ ร ๐ \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} Penning discharge M. Tyushev, M. Papahn Zadeh, N. S. Chopra, Y. Raitses, I. Romadanov, A. Likhanskii, G. Fubiani, L. Garrigues, R. Groenewald, A. Smolyakov Abstract Two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations in the (radial-azimuthal) plane perpendicular to the axial direction of a cylindrical ๐ ร ๐ \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} Penning discharge are presented. The low-pressure discharge is self-consistently supported by plasma ionization from the electron beam injected axially, along the direction of the external magnetic field. It is shown that with the increasing strength of the external magnetic field, the discharge undergoes a sequence of transitions between several azimuthal modes. Azimuthal m > 1 m>1 spiral arm structures are excited at low magnetic field values as plasma confinement improves and the radial density profile becomes peaked. With a larger field, spiral arms with m > 1 m>1 are replaced by the m = 1 m=1 spoke mode, most clearly seen in plasma density. A transition from spiral arms to the spoke regime occurs when the plasma potential in the center changes from weakly positive (or zero) to negative. Further increase of the magnetic field results in a well-developed m = 1 m=1 spoke mode with additional small-scale higher frequency m > 1 m>1 structures inside and around the spoke. It is shown that while ionization and collisions affect some characteristics of the observed fluctuations, the basic features of the spoke and m > 1 m>1 spiral structure remained similar without ionization. The role of energy conservation in small-scale high-frequency modes and spoke dynamics is discussed. It is demonstrated that in regimes with the m = 1 m=1 spoke mode, additional m = 4 m=4 harmonics of the ion and electron fluxes to the wall appear due to the square boundary. The frequency of the m = 1 m=1 mode is weakly affected by the geometry of the boundary. I Introduction Magnetic fields improve plasma confinement and are often employed to increase plasma density in low-temperature plasma devices. In typical applications with a moderate magnetic field, the electrons are fully magnetized and confined by the magnetic field while ions are only weakly affected by the magnetic field and can be controlled by the electric field. Instabilities that occur in such partially magnetized plasmas due to plasma inhomogeneities and electric fields have long been a subject of active studies, e.g. see Refs. 1 and 2 and references therein. Linear theory [ 3 , 2 ] predicts a variety of instabilities that may occur in partially magnetized plasmas. However, nonlinear regimes and saturation of the instabilities have to be studied with numerical simulations. A straight cylindrical configuration with an axial magnetic field and radial electric field (the so-called \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} configuration) is a prototype for the Penning discharges used in many technological applications [ 4 ] . One of the intriguing and important phenomena that dominate the radial plasma transport is a large-scale, m=1 azimuthally rotating structure, the so-called spoke, typically observed as a large scale plasma density perturbation. Such spoke-type structures and multiple helicity modes in partially magnetized \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} plasmas were observed experimentally in Penning and other \mathbf{E}\crossproduct\mathbf{B} plasma systems [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] and also studied in numerical simulations under various conditions [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . Here, we study the spoke and spiral arms structures in a 2D radial-azimuthal geometry using Particle-in-Cell (PIC) WarpX code [ 19 ] . We study the square as well as the circular geometry of the external boundary. In both cases, Cartesian mesh is used thus avoiding the issues related to the region near r=0 in the cylindrical coordinates. The code is run on the Mist server, https://docs.scinet.utoronto.ca/index.php/Mist , of the Digital Research Alliance of Canada with one GPU of NVIDIA V100-SMX2-32GB type per one separate simulation. The general setup of simulations is similar to that of Ref. 20 . Here we focus on the conditions for the spoke and spiral arms formations, the role of ionization, and consider the low pressure discharge of 0.44 mTorr while the higher pressure of 40 mTorr was considered in Ref. 20 . In this paper, we propose the mechanism for the spiral arms formation, show the coexistence of the m=1 spoke and m>1 small-scale high-frequency modes, and demonstrate that geometrical effects of the square boundary result in the modulation of the electron and ion fluxes to the wall at the fourth harmonics of the spoke frequency. To clarify the role of the ionization processes in the mechanism of the spoke, we have performed the simulations by turning off all collisional processes (including the ionization) and replacing the ionization with equivalent electron and ion sources. In this study, we observe the formation of the m=1 spoke with roughly similar characteristics, thus demonstrating that the mechanism of the spoke instability is not related to the ionization processes. In Section II , the PIC simulation model, and the parameters of simulations are described in detail. In Section III , we investigate the role of the electric field in the structure excitation and demonstrate the transitions between the m>1 spiral arms and the m=1 spoke regimes. The role of energy conservation in the spoke formation is discussed in Section IV . In Section V , we show the coexisting m=1 spoke and multiple m>1 high-frequency modes. The effect of ionization on the spoke formation is discussed in Section VI . In Section VII , we examine the effects of geometry on the spoke dynamics. Section VIII provides a summary and discussion of the results. II The simulation model Figure 1 : The cross-section of the modeling region. The base case simulations are performed with a square boundary. Section VII simulations are done with a circular boundary. The potential of the boundary is zero in all cases. The setup of our numerical experiments aims to reproduce the conditions similar to experimental conditions for Penning discharges and ion plasma sources [ 7 , 21 , 12 , 13 ] . In our simulations, plasma discharge is supported by the ionization from the energetic electrons injected along the magnetic field in the y-direction (outward of the page in Fig. 1 ). The electron beam is uniform and injected into a circular region of a radius R=1.5\;\text{cm} , Fig. 1 . In addition to one-step electron impact ionization Ar+e\longrightarrow Ar+e+e , for electrons with the energy above 15.7\;\text{eV} , excitation reactions Ar+e\longrightarrow Ar^{*}+e , with the excitation energy of 11.55\;\text{eV} , and elastic collisions are included. The electron-neutral isotropic scattering cross-sections included in WarpX distribution were sourced from Ref. 22 , excitation cross-sections from Ref. 23 , and ionization cross-sections from Ref. 24 . The beam electrons are injected along the magnetic field in the direction opposite to the field with E_{b}=30\;\text{eV} axial energy and Maxwellian T_{e}=5\;\text{eV} temperature throughout the whole simulation duration. The background neutral gas is maintained at a constant density throughout the entire simulation. The injected electron beam is represented by macroparticles introduced at each simulation time step, corresponding to the total beam current of 1\;\text{mA} . Technically, in two-dimensional geometry, which neglects the third direction, the