Engage and Mobilize ! Understanding Evolving Patterns of Social Media Usage in Emergency Management

Hemant Purohit, Cody Buntain, Amanda Lee Hughes, Steve Peterson, Valerio Lorini, Carlos Castillo · 2025

Read Engage and Mobilize ! Understanding Evolving Patterns of Social Media Usage in Emergency Management by Hemant Purohit, Cody Buntain, Amanda Lee Hughes, Steve Peterson, Valerio Lorini, Carlos Castillo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15608.txt.

Introduction

When disaster strikes, emergency agencies increasingly read social media as a sensor network and a loudspeaker in one. Hemant Purohit and five co-authors surveyed about 150 emergency professionals in the United States and Europe in 2025, then interviewed eleven, to map how that use has evolved.

Agencies now weave social feeds into decisions across all four phases, mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery, at county desks and national offices alike. The survey updates earlier attitude studies with actual practice: what gets collected, who watches it, and where it feeds operations and public messaging. Staffing for field collection stays thin, which is the gap social data fills. The authors draw the local and non-local patterns side by side.

Catalog record

CREATORHemant Purohit, Cody Buntain, Amanda Lee Hughes, Steve Peterson, Valerio Lorini, Carlos Castillo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15608

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Engage and Mobilize ! Understanding Evolving Patterns of Social Media Usage in Emergency Management Hemant Purohit, Cody Buntain, Amanda Lee Hughes, Steve Peterson, Valerio Lorini, Carlos Castillo Abstract . The work of Emergency Management (EM) agencies requires timely collection of relevant data to inform decision-making for operations and public communication before, during, and after a disaster. However, the limited human resources available to deploy for field data collection is a persistent problem for EM agencies. Thus, over the last decade, many of these agencies have started leveraging social media as a supplemental data source and a new venue to engage with the public. Such uses present both opportunities and challenges. While prior research has analyzed the potential benefits and attitudes of practitioners and the public when leveraging social media during disasters, a gap exists in the critical analysis of the actual practices and uses of social media among EM agencies, across both geographical regions and phases of the EM lifecycle - typically mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery. In this paper, we conduct a mixed-method analysis to update and fill this gap on how EM practitioners in the U.S. and Europe use social media, building on a survey study of about 150 professionals and a follow-up interview study with 11 participants. The results indicate that using social media is no longer a non-traditional practice in operational and informational processes for the decision-making of EM agencies working at both the local level (e.g., county or town) and non-local level (e.g., state/province, federal/national) for emergency management. Especially, the practitioners affiliated with agencies working at the local level have a very high perceived value of social media for situational awareness (e.g., analyzing disaster extent and impact) and public communication (e.g., disseminating timely information and correcting errors in crisis coverage). Further, practitioners now engage with the public during the preparedness phase to mobilize them during the response phase. We present a model to understand the current practices of communication between agencies and the public, as well as among practitioners while leveraging social media. We also discuss novel challenges, including public fragmentation caused by the increasing use of multiple social media platforms, information integrity, and social listening expectations. We conclude with the policy, technological, and socio-technical needs to design future social media analytics systems to support the work of EM agencies in such communication. Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 2 CSCW067 4 DOI: 10.1145/3710965 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Much has been written about how to use social media platforms in emergency management (EM) before, during, and after disaster events. Early research focused on using Twitter (now X.com) to improve situational awareness ( Yin et al., 2012 ; Vieweg et al., 2010 ) , but over the years, the field of “crisis informatics” ( Palen and Anderson, 2016a ) has branched in many directions, as attested by various surveys spanning multiple editions and years ( Imran et al., 2015 ; Palen and Hughes, 2018 ; Zhang et al., 2019 ; Purohit and Peterson, 2020 ; Saroj and Pal, 2020 ) (see Section 2 for additional references). Despite this abundance of research, EM practitioners have not fully realized the expected transformations from leveraging social media ( U.S. Department of Homeland Security Science and Technology Directorate Virtual Social Media Working Group and First Responder Group, 2014 ) in preparedness, response, and recovery phases of EM for which researchers have strived ( Reuter et al., 2018 ) . Researchers and practitioners have cited numerous reasons for this limited impact, including an over-reliance on Twitter/X data analysis ( Palen and Anderson, 2016a ; Reuter et al., 2018 ) , concerns of information quality ( Lorini et al., 2021 ; Hiltz et al., 2020 ) , information overload ( Lorini et al., 2021 ) , organizational policies that discourage or prevent social media use ( Hughes and Palen, 2012 ; Hiltz et al., 2020 ) , and limited tools to handle visual media ( Lorini et al., 2021 ) , among others. However, most of the proposed solutions to these issues have focused on technical offerings that alleviate data-related problems. This “technosolutionism” or “technochauvinism” ( Broussard, 2018 ) has motivated critical questions, including how EM practitioners have adopted social media for their needs over time, and how they have themselves adapted to the public’s use of these platforms. To address these questions, this paper takes a comprehensive approach to understand the current practices of EM practitioners to incorporate social media into their socio-technical processes, and how these processes have evolved. Specifically, we employ a mixed-method approach in this study. We design and conduct a survey for practitioners across various countries, and engage a subset of them in interviews to learn how they see and use social media in their work. We find new processes wherein practitioners have integrated social media into their outreach plans and performance indicators for public engagement, as well as how they actively use such virtual platforms to mobilize and collaborate with the public, locally, nationally, and internationally. We present a model of the four primary communication channels among agencies and the public. This model is then used to organize our findings and understand the differences in the current practices of agencies across key operational and informational processes such as data collection and public engagement. Our analysis validates long-standing obstacles for EM agencies in leveraging social media. For instance, dealing with incomplete information, determining exact locations of events referenced within social media messages (geolocating), and understanding the motivations and intentions of message posters and audiences. We further discover new issues around policies governing current practices of EM, platform-usage fragmentation among the public, and other barriers that technical solutions alone may be unable to address. Building on these confirmatory and revelatory findings, this paper contributes an updated and more complete understanding of EM practitioners’ current use of social media across different EM phases and also, discusses policy and socio-technical needs for the future. Section 2 describes previous work related to ours and Section 3 presents our methodology, which includes a survey and an interview study. Sections 4 and 5 , respectively, present the insights obtained from the survey and interviews with practitioners. Section 6 presents a discussion of these findings and Section 7 our conclusions. 2. Related Work This work builds on and makes contributions to a community that spans a broad spectrum of researchers, from social science and computational social science researchers studying how social media is used during crises, to computer scientists and developers building new crisis informatics tools to facilitate social media’s use among EM practitioners. As early as 2007, Palen and Liu (2007) outlined how information & communication technology “will give further rise to improvised activities” during crises. They also rightly foresaw how formal response organizations should respond to these activities, even before social media platforms were largely discussed–in fact, their paper does not mention explicitly “social media” at all. Over time, such research has coalesced into the interdisciplinary field of “crisis informatics,” at the intersection of human-computer interaction and social science research ( Palen and Anderson, 2016a ) . Crisis informatics research continues to evolve as well, as social media platforms and EM practitioners’

Read the complete text