FIT-Print: Towards False-claim-resistant Model Ownership Verification via Targeted Fingerprint

Shuo Shao, Haozhe Zhu, Hongwei Yao, Yiming Li, Tianwei Zhang, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren · 2025

Read FIT-Print: Towards False-claim-resistant Model Ownership Verification via Targeted Fingerprint by Shuo Shao, Haozhe Zhu, Hongwei Yao, Yiming Li, Tianwei Zhang, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15509.txt.

Introduction

Shao and co-authors expose a flaw in methods that fingerprint AI models to prove ownership, in a 2025 paper. Existing fingerprints compare a model's outputs on arbitrary samples, so a dishonest party can falsely claim someone else's independent model as their own. The team's fix makes the fingerprint targeted: an optimization step shapes it into a signature tied to one specific reference.

Two black-box methods built on this idea use output distances and feature attributions as signatures. In tests they blocked every false claim, raised no false alarms on independent models, and still verified genuine ownership in every reuse scenario tried.

Catalog record

CREATORShuo Shao, Haozhe Zhu, Hongwei Yao, Yiming Li, Tianwei Zhang, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15509

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

FIT-Print: Towards False-claim-resistant Model Ownership Verification via Targeted Fingerprint Shuo Shao, Haozhe Zhu, Hongwei Yao, Yiming Li, Tianwei Zhang, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren Abstract Model fingerprinting is a widely adopted approach to safeguard the copyright of open-source models by detecting and preventing their unauthorized reuse without modifying the protected model. However, in this paper, we reveal that existing fingerprinting methods are vulnerable to false claim attacks where adversaries falsely assert ownership of third-party non-reused models. We find that this vulnerability mostly stems from their untargeted nature, where they generally compare the outputs of given samples on different models instead of the similarities to specific references. Motivated by this finding, we propose a targeted fingerprinting paradigm ( i . e . i.e. , FIT-Print) to counteract false claim attacks. Specifically, FIT-Print transforms the fingerprint into a targeted signature via optimization. Building on the principles of FIT-Print, we develop bit-wise and list-wise black-box model fingerprinting methods, i . e . i.e. , FIT-ModelDiff and FIT-LIME, which exploit the distance between model outputs and the feature attribution of specific samples as the fingerprint, respectively. Experiments on benchmark models and datasets verify the effectiveness, conferrability, and resistance to false claim attacks of our FIT-Print. 1 Introduction Deep learning models, especially deep neural networks (DNNs), have been widely and successfully deployed in widespread applications [ 58 , 15 , 19 , 69 ] . In general, obtaining a well-performed model requires considerable computational resources and human expertise and is, therefore, highly expensive. In particular, some models are released to the open-source community ( e.g. , Hugging Face) for academic or educational purposes. However, the development of model reuse techniques, such as fine tuning [ 31 ] and transfer learning [ 76 ] , poses a potential threat to the intellectual property rights (IPR) of these models. With these methods, malicious developers can easily reuse open-source models for commercial purposes without authorization. How to protect their IPR becomes a vital problem. Figure 1: The comparison of untargeted and targeted fingerprinting paradigms. Untargeted methods generally compare the output of given samples. Accordingly, using some transferable samples can lead to false claims. Targeted fingerprinting calculates the similarity to a specific signature, which restricts the fingerprint space around the target and, therefore, mitigates false claim attacks. Currently, ownership verification stands as a widely adopted post-hoc approach for safeguarding the IPR of model developers. This method intends to justify whether a suspicious third-party model has been reused from the protected model [ 73 , 27 , 52 ] . Existing techniques to implement ownership verification can be broadly categorized into two main types: model watermarking and model fingerprinting. Model watermarking [ 1 , 27 , 65 ] involves embedding an owner-specific signature ( i.e. , watermark) into the model. The model developer can extract the watermark inside the model to verify its ownership. On the contrary, model fingerprinting [ 2 , 28 , 21 , 64 ] aims to identify the intrinsic feature ( i.e. , fingerprint) of the model instead of modifying the protected model. The fingerprint can be represented as the outputs of some testing samples at a particular mapping function. Comparing fingerprints enables comparing the source and suspicious models to examine whether the latter is a reused version of the former. Arguably, model fingerprinting is more convenient and feasible than model watermarking since the former does not necessitate any alteration to the parameters, structure, and training procedure and thus has no negative impact on the model. In this paper, we reveal that existing model fingerprinting methods, no matter whether they are bit-wise [ 28 ] or list-wise [ 21 ] ( i.e. , extract the fingerprint bit by bit or as a whole list), are vulnerable to false claim attacks. In general, false claim attacks [ 30 ] allow adversaries to falsely assert ownership of a third-party model that is not a reused model by creating a counterfeit ownership certificate ( i.e. , fingerprint). In particular, false claim attacks can be treated as finding transferable ownership certificates across models since registering the certificate with a timestamp can avoid any false claims with a later timestamp. We show that the adversary can conduct false claim attacks by constructing transferably ‘easy’ samples that can be correctly classified with high confidence (in Section 2.3 ). Existing fingerprinting methods tend to compare the outputs of testing samples, and these elaborated easy samples can have similar high-confident outputs on various models, thus leading to independent models being misjudged as reused models. We argue that this vulnerability mostly stems from the untargeted nature of existing fingerprinting methods. Specifically, they generally compare the outputs of any given samples on different models instead of the similarities to specific references. The untargeted nature enlarges the space of viable fingerprints. It makes adversaries easily find alternative transferable samples that have similar output on independent models, as illustrated in Figure 1 . Motivated by the aforementioned understandings, we introduce a new fingerprinting paradigm, dubbed F alse-cla I m-resistant T argeted model finger Print ing (FIT-Print), where the fingerprint comparison is targeted instead of untargeted. Specifically, we optimize the perturbations on the testing samples to make the output of the fingerprinting mapping function close to a specific signature ( i.e. , the target fingerprint). It restricts the (potential) fingerprint space and significantly reduces the probability of a successful false claim attack. Based on our FIT-Print, we design two targeted model fingerprinting methods, including FIT-ModelDiff and FIT-LIME, as the representatives of bit-wise and list-wise methods, respectively. FIT-ModelDiff exploits the distances between outputs, while FIT-LIME leverages the feature attribution of testing samples as the fingerprint. Our main contributions are four-fold: (1) We revisit existing model fingerprinting methods and reveal that existing methods are vulnerable to false claim attacks due to their untargeted nature. (2) We introduce a new fingerprinting paradigm ( i.e. , FIT-Print), where we conduct verification in a targeted manner with a given reference. (3) Based on our proposed FIT-Print, we design two black-box targeted model fingerprinting methods: FIT-ModelDiff and FIT-LIME. (4) We conduct experiments on benchmark datasets and models to verify the effectiveness and conferrability of FIT-Print, and its resistance to false claims and adaptive attacks. 2 Revisiting Existing Model Fingerprinting In this section, we first formally and comprehensively define the threat model of model fingerprinting. We further categorize existing methods into two types and describe their formulation. Subsequently, based on the aforementioned definition and formulation, we design a simple yet effective false claim attack and reveal the underlying vulnerability of existing fingerprinting methods. 2.1 Threat Model of Model Fingerprinting In this paper, we consider three parties in our threat model, including model developer , model reuser , and verifier . Arguably, including a verifier is necessary and may improve the trustworthiness of model fingerprinting, although there are currently still no mature legal provisions about this. More justification of our threat model is in Appendix A . Assumptions of the Model Developer and Verifier. The model developer is the owner of the source model and can register its model and fingerprint to the trustworthy verifier with a timestamp. The verifier is responsible for fingerprint registration and verification. In case the model is reused by a model reuser, the

Read the complete text