Three flavor QCD phase transition with Möbius domain wall fermions
Yoshifumi Nakamura · 2025
Read Three flavor QCD phase transition with Möbius domain wall fermions by Yoshifumi Nakamura (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15494.txt.
Introduction
Yu Zhang, Yasumichi Aoki, Shoji Hashimoto, Issaku Kanamori, Takashi Kaneko, and Yoshifumi Nakamura wrote a 2025 lattice physics paper on how hot quark matter changes phase. Quantum chromodynamics with three light flavors may switch abruptly or glide smoothly as temperature climbs, and the answer shapes models of the early universe. Their simulations use a fermion formulation that respects chiral symmetry well.
Runs at a temperature near 121 million electron volt equivalent covered several quark masses and box sizes. A new large volume run let them check how a key susceptibility grows with volume, the tell of a true transition. Watching the chiral condensate, that susceptibility, and a standard cumulant together, they find the change looks like a smooth crossover at a light quark mass around four MeV. Residual symmetry breaking effects are also examined.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yoshifumi Nakamura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15494
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Three flavor QCD phase transition with Möbius domain wall fermions Yoshifumi Nakamura Abstract We present an updated study of the N f = 3 N_{f}=3 QCD phase transition using Möbius domain wall fermions. Simulations were performed on N t = 12 N_{t}=12 lattices with aspect ratios ranging from 2 to 4 for various quark masses, at a lattice spacing of a = 0.1361 ( 20 ) a=0.1361(20) fm, corresponding to a temperature of 121(2) MeV. To clarify the nature of the phase transition, a large-volume lattice, 48 3 × 12 × 16 48^{3}\times 12\times 16 , was added to analyze the volume dependence of disconnected chiral susceptibility. By examining the chiral condensate, disconnected chiral susceptibility, and Binder cumulant, and incorporating results from 24 3 × 12 × 16 24^{3}\times 12\times 16 and 36 3 × 12 × 16 36^{3}\times 12\times 16 lattices reported in earlier studies [ 1 , 2 ] , we observe that the transtion is consistent with a crossover at a quark mass of approximately m f MS ¯ ( 2 GeV ) ∼ 4 m_{f}^{\mathrm{\overline{MS}}}(2\,\mathrm{GeV})\sim 4 MeV at this temperature. Furthermore, we discuss the effects of residual chiral symmetry breaking on the chiral condensate and disconnected chiral susceptibility for different sizes in the 5th-direction. [a]Yu Zhang 1 Introduction The nature of the QCD chiral phase transition has been a hot topic in the study of strongly interacting matter for decades. In particular, the phase transition for three degenerate quark flavors in the chiral limit, represented in the lower left corner of the Columbia plot, remains unresolved. Early theoretical work by Pisarski and Wilczek, based on a perturbative renormalization group study of a three-dimensional linear sigma model, predicted a first-order phase transition [ 3 ] . According to their analysis, this first-order transition weakens as one moves away from the chiral limit and eventually terminates at a critical endpoint, where the phase transition becomes second-order, belonging to the three-dimensional Z(2) Ising universality class. In contrast, recent functional renormalization group analysis with all couplings up to \phi^{6} terms included in a three-dimensional Ginzburg-Landau theory [ 4 , 5 ] , numerical conformal bootstrap [ 6 ] , conjectures in Ref. [ 7 ] and extended linear sigma model analysis [ 8 ] , both suggest the possibility of a second-order phase transition in the N_{f}=3 chiral limit if U(1)_{A} symmetry is effectively restored at the critical point. Recent results from the Dyson-Schwinger equations [ 9 ] also found a second-order phase transition in the N_{f}=3 chiral limit. These low-energy effective model analyses can capture qualitative aspects but certainly cannot solve this open problem. Whether the first-order region is tiny or does not exist at all is still an open question. If it exists, what is the value of the critical pion mass that separates the first-order and crossover regions? To answer this quantitative question, we need lattice QCD simulation. Earlier lattice studies using standard staggered [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] , Wilson [ 13 ] and O(a) -improved Wilson fermions [ 14 ] support the existence of a first-order phase transition for light quark masses on coarse lattices. However, subsequent studies have shown that the size of the first-order region depends significantly on the formulation of the lattice action and lattice spacing [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Recent studies have not found direct evidence of a first-order transition for pion mass above 50 MeV using highly improved staggered fermions(HISQ) [ 18 ] or 110 MeV using O(a) -improved Wilson fermions [ 20 ] . Another recent study by looking into the position of the tri-critical point as a function of the number of quark flavors, N_{f} , finds that the chiral phase transition is second order for three massless quarks [ 21 ] . Later, a study using HISQ fermions also suggests a second-order phase transition in the chiral limit [ 22 ] . This leaves little room for a first-order region to exist, but it cannot be ruled out; it can be very small. It is important to note that the existing results predominantly originate from staggered or Wilson fermion formulations, which partially or completely break the chiral symmetry at finite lattice spacing. Therefore, it is important to explore this problem further using chiral fermions. Specifically, we use the Möbius domain wall fermion, and some of the preliminary results have been reported in previous lattice conference proceedings [ 23 , 1 , 2 ] . The advantage of the Möbius domain wall fermion is that it has exact chiral symmetry at finite lattice spacing for the size of fifth-dimension ( L_{s} ) goes to infinity, and the reduced chiral symmetry breaking effect parameterized by the residual mass when the size in the 5th-direction, L_{s} , is finite. 2 Lattice Setup We perform N_{f}=3 QCD simulations using the tree-level improved Symanzik gauge action combined with the Möbius domain wall fermion action. The simulations are implemented using the Grid code optimized for the Fugaku CPU A64FX architecture [ 24 ] . The gauge coupling is fixed at \beta=4.0 , corresponding to a lattice spacing a=0.1361(20) fm. This value is obtained from the Wilson flow parameter t_{0} and matches the continuum extrapolated physical point result for N_{f}=2+1 QCD [ 25 ] . In our previous study [ 1 , 2 ] , we performed simulations on 24^{3}\times 12\times 16 and 36^{3}\times 12\times 16 lattices with a range of quark masses. We observed a significant finite-volume effect near the transition point. To study this effect further, in this work, we conducted a larger volume simulation on 48^{3}\times 12\times 16 lattices with two mass points - 0.003 and - 0.004. To evaluate the effects of residual chiral symmetry breaking, additional simulations are performed on 24^{3}\times 12\times 32 lattices with 5 quark masses in the range \left[-0.001,0.003\right] . For each parameter set, we generate about 20,000 thermalized trajectories, with measurements taken every 10 trajectories. In addition to the finite-temperature ensembles, we also generate zero-temperature N_{f}=3 configurations at \beta=4.0 , 4.1 and 4.17 on lattices of size 24^{3}\times 48\times 16 , 24^{3}\times 48\times 16 , and 32^{3}\times 64\times 16 , respectively. These ensembles are utilized to determine the lattice spacing, study the coupling dependence of the residual mass, and remove the ultraviolet divergence contribution from the finite temperature chiral condensate. 3 Numerical results 3.1 Residual chiral violations For domain wall fermions with finite L_{s} , there exists a residual mixing between the two walls, resulting in a breaking of chiral symmetry. The leading effect of this mixing is an additive renormalization to the bare quark mass, commonly referred to as the residual mass, m_{\rm{res}} . The residual mass is defined through the Ward-Takahashi identity of the axial current [ 26 ] : \Delta_{\mu}\langle\mathcal{A}^{a}_{\mu}(x)O(y)\rangle=2m_{f}\langle J_{5}^{a}(x)O(y)\rangle+2\langle J^{a}_{5q}(x)O(y)\rangle+i\langle\delta^{a}O(y)\rangle (1) where J^{a}_{5q} is the pseudoscalar density constructed from the fields at the center of the fifth dimension, and J^{a}_{5} is the physical pseudoscalar density constructed from the fields at the boundary. The J^{a}_{5q} term acts as an additional contribution to the continuum expression and vanishes in the limit L_{s}\to\infty for the non-singlet flavor. Close to the continuum limit, in an effective low-energy Lagrangian, the