Subseries Numbers for Convergent Subseries
Tristan van der Vlugt · 2025
Read Subseries Numbers for Convergent Subseries by Tristan van der Vlugt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15176.txt.
Introduction
Tristan van der Vlugt studies a counting question about infinite series in a 2025 mathematics paper. A conditionally convergent series can be thinned to a subseries that diverges, a classic fact. The subseries numbers ask how few index sets one must choose in advance so that every such series diverges on at least one of them.
Van der Vlugt turns the question around. Taking only index sets that are endless in both directions, he asks how the answer changes when the chosen sets must make every such series converge instead. That number turns out to be a cardinal characteristic of the continuum, one of the standard gauges of infinity's fine structure. He links his new numbers to several known ones and proves matching dual results.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tristan van der Vlugt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15176
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Subseries Numbers for Convergent Subseries Thanks: This research was funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF), grants 10.55776/P33895 and 10.55776/PAT8484324. Tristan van der Vlugt Abstract . Every conditionally convergent series of real numbers has a subseries that diverges. The subseries numbers, previously studied in [ BBH19 ] , answer the question how many subsets of the natural numbers are necessary, such that every conditionally convergent series has a subseries that diverges, with the index set being one of our chosen sets. By restricting our attention to subseries generated by an index set that is both infinite and coinfinite, we may ask the question where the subseries have to be convergent. The answer to this question is a cardinal characteristic of the continuum. We consider several closely related variations to this question, and show that our cardinal characteristics are related to several well-known cardinal characteristics of the continuum. In our investigation, we simultaneously will produce dual results, answering the question how many conditionally convergent series one needs such that no single infinite coinfinite set of indices makes all of the series converge. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 03E17; Secondary 03E05, 03E35 1. Introduction Given a conditionally convergent series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{i} , we can always find some infinite set X\subseteq\omega of indices such that the subseries \sum_{i\in X}a_{i} no longer converges. Sparked by a question from Mohammadpour on MathOverflow, 1 1 1 See: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/221106/ Brendle, Brian and Hamkins [ BBH19 ] wrote an article answering the question how large a family \mathcal{X}\subseteq[\omega]^{\omega} of infinite sets of natural numbers should be such that for every conditionally convergent series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{i} there exists some X\in\mathcal{X} for which \sum_{i\in X}a_{i} is no longer convergent. The minimal cardinality of such a family \mathcal{X} is called the subseries number . It turns out that the subseries number is a cardinal characteristic of the continuum, that is, a cardinality between \aleph_{1} and 2^{\aleph_{0}} whose size is consistently different from either bound, and hence independent from \mathsf{ZFC} . In their article, Brendle, Brian and Hamkins consider some variations of the subseries number depending on the convergence behaviour. For instance, they consider he number of subsets needed such that every conditionally convergent series can be made to diverge by tending to infinity. A closely related family of cardinal characteristics is the family of rearrangement numbers , studied by Blass, Brendle, Brian, Hamkins, Hardy and Larson in [ BBB+19 ] . The rearrangement number answers a similar question: how many permutations \pi of \omega are necessary such that for each conditionally convergent series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{i} the permutation of the indices results in a series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{\pi(i)} that no longer converges to the same limit. Note that Riemann’s rearrangement theorem [ Rie76 ] states that any conditionally convergent series can be rearranged to converge to a different limit or to diverge, which makes this notion well-defined. One particular variation on this theme, is the rearrangement number \mathfrak{rr}_{f} , being the least cardinality of a set P of permutations on the natural numbers, such that for every conditionally convergent series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{i} there is a permutation \pi\in P for which \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{\pi(i)} is still convergent, but has a different limit than the original series. It is noted in the paper on the subseries number that a similar subseries number is not very interesting, as it is easily observed that for every conditionally convergent series \sum_{i\in\omega}a_{i} there is some n\in\omega such that \sum_{i\in\omega\setminus\mathopen{}\left\{n\right\}\mathclose{}}a_{i} converges to a different limit (namely, by letting n be any index such that a_{n}\neq 0 ), and thus the countable set \mathcal{X}=\mathopen{}\left\{\omega\setminus\mathopen{}\left\{n\right\}\mathclose{}\penalty\ \middle|\penalty\ n\in\omega\right\}\mathclose{} is a witness for this potential variation on the subseries number. In our article we will show that there are ways to define a subseries number such that questions related to convergent subseries produce interesting cardinal characteristics. Our deviation from the original article, is that we will not consider all infinite subsets of \omega , but only those subsets that are also coinfinite, that is, whose complement is infinite as well. We will also investigate dual cardinals to the subseries numbers. These dual subseries numbers answer questions such as: how many conditionally convergent series are needed such that no single infinite subset of \omega makes all of them divergent? As with the subseries numbers, the dual subseries numbers are usually cardinal characteristics of the continuum. Relational systems and Tukey connections between them allow us to show relations between cardinal characteristics and their duals simultaneously, so we will prove our relations in this framework where possible. Outline of the Paper After we introduce our notation in Section 2 , as well as a reminder about relational systems and Tukey connections, we briefly discuss in Section 3 why the change from considering infinite coinfinite subsets of \omega , instead of just infinite subsets, does not affect the cardinality of the original subseries numbers defined in [ BBH19 ] . In Section 4 , we will investigate the cardinals \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{c} , \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{cc} and \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{ac} , defined as subseries numbers for convergent subseries, conditionally convergent subseries, and absolutely convergent subseries respectively. We will show that \mathrm{cov}(\mathcal{M})\leq\text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{c}\leq\text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{cc}\leq\text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{ac}=\mathfrak{d} and that \mathfrak{s}\leq\text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{cc} . In Section 5 we consider subseries numbers \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{e} and \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{l}^{A} that are related to subseries that converge to a specific fixed (set of) limit(s). We provide some sets of limits such that these cardinals are provably equal to either \mathfrak{c} or \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{c} . In Section 6 we consider a subseries number \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{n} related to subseries of conditionally convergent series that are still conditional, but not necessarily convergent. We show that \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{n}=3 for rather pathological reasons. Additionally we consider a subseries number \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{c}^{ui} of subseries that diverge by tending to infinity unconditionally, and show that it equals \mathfrak{d} . Finally, in Section 7 we give an overview of the dual cardinals \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{i,o}^{\bot} , \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{o}^{\bot} and \text{{\swabfamily s}\kern-1.00006pt$\mathfrak{z}$}_{i}^{\bot} to the original subseries numbers from [ BBH19 ] . We modify one of the original proofs in order to show that the dual result holds. 2. Preliminaries The focus of this article is on cardinal characteristics of the continuum, which are generally studied in the context of set theory. We will therefore try to follow the notation from standard set-theoretic literature, such as [ Jec03 ] or [ Kun11 ] . We will denote the set of real numbers by \mathbb{R} , the set of rational numbers by \mathbb{Q} and the set of natural numbers by \omega . We adopt the convention that 0 is a natural number and identify each natural number n\in\omega with the set n=\mathopen{}\left\{0,\dots,n-1\right\}\mathclose{} of natural numbers strictly below n . For real numbers c\in\mathbb{R} we let |c| denote the absolute value of c . We also write \mathbb{R}_{>0} for the set of positive real numbers. If X,Y are sets, we write {}^{X}Y for the set of functions X\to Y and we define {}^{<\omega}Y as \bigcup_{n\in\omega}{}^{n}Y . If \kappa is a cardinality, then [X]^{\kappa} is the set of subsets of X of size \kappa , and [X]^{<\kappa} is the set of subsets of X of size strictly smaller than \kappa . We write [X]^{\omega} for the subsets of X of size |\omega|=\aleph_{0} , and note that if X is countable,