Reproducing Λ \Lambda CDM-like Solutions in f ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity: A Comprehensive Study Across All Connection Branches
Saikat Chakraborty, Jibitesh Dutta, Daniele Gregoris, Khamphee Karwan, Wompherdeiki Khyllep · 2025
Read Reproducing Λ \Lambda CDM-like Solutions in f ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity: A Comprehensive Study Across All Connection Branches by Saikat Chakraborty, Jibitesh Dutta, Daniele Gregoris, Khamphee Karwan, Wompherdeiki Khyllep (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-15159.txt.
Introduction
Saikat Chakraborty and co-authors ask whether a rival theory of gravity can mimic the standard model of the universe. Their 2025 paper works in f(Q) gravity, where a quantity tied to how rulers twist replaces the usual driver of gravity. The standard model, called LCDM, fits sky data very well.
Three branches of the theory are open under the rules of a smooth, flat cosmos. For each branch the team rebuilds the form of the theory that copies LCDM growth exactly. Two branches yield closed formulas, while the third needs number work. In all three, a match exists at the background level. One rebuilt form also holds steady under small slips in the data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Saikat Chakraborty, Jibitesh Dutta, Daniele Gregoris, Khamphee Karwan, Wompherdeiki Khyllep |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 110 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-15159
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reproducing Λ \Lambda CDM-like Solutions in f ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity: A Comprehensive Study Across All Connection Branches Saikat Chakraborty, Jibitesh Dutta, Daniele Gregoris, Khamphee Karwan, Wompherdeiki Khyllep Abstract Given the remarkable success of the Λ \Lambda CDM model in fitting various cosmological observations, a pertinent question in assessing the phenomenological viability of modified gravity theories is whether they can reproduce an exactly Λ \Lambda CDM-like cosmic background evolution. In this paper, we address this question in the context of f ( Q ) f(Q) gravity, where Q Q denotes the nonmetricity scalar. It is known that there are three possible symmetric teleparallel connection branches that respect the cosmological principles of spatial homogeneity, isotropy, and global spatial flatness. By enforcing a Λ \Lambda CDM-like background evolution via the cosmographic condition j ( z ) = 1 j(z)=1 , where j j is the jerk parameter, we reconstruct the Λ \Lambda CDM-mimicking f ( Q ) f(Q) theory for each of the three possible connection branches. For the first connection branch, also known as the “coincident gauge” in cosmology, we recover the previously known result that a theory of the form f ( Q ) = − 2 Λ + α Q + β − Q f(Q)=-2\Lambda+\alpha Q+\beta\sqrt{-Q} can exactly reproduce a Λ \Lambda CDM-like cosmic evolution. Furthermore, we establish that the stability of the Λ \Lambda CDM-like cosmic solution within this reconstructed f ( Q ) f(Q) , as well as the robustness of the reconstructed f ( Q ) f(Q) form with respect to small errors in the astrophysical measurements of the jerk parameter. For the second connection branch, we analytically reconstruct the Λ \Lambda CDM-mimicking f ( Q ) f(Q) to be of the form f ( Q ) = − 2 Λ + α Q − β Q 2 f(Q)=-2\Lambda+\alpha Q-\beta Q^{2} . For the third connection branch, we could decouple the evolution equation for the dynamical connection function, which enabled us to perform a numerical reconstruction. Our analysis proves that, at least at the background level, it is possible to obtain Λ \Lambda CDM-mimicking f ( Q ) f(Q) models for all the three possible connection branches. These models effectively reduce to (STE)GR in the past while possessing a positive effective gravitational coupling throughout. I Introduction General Relativity (GR), based on the curvature of spacetime, has been fundamental in understanding the physics of gravitational interaction and the dynamics of the universe’s large-scale structure. Its achievements encapsulated within the \Lambda CDM cosmological model include the successful description of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), baryonic acoustic oscillations (BAO), and the accelerating expansion of the universe SupernovaSearchTeam:1998fmf ; SupernovaCosmologyProject:1998vns . Still, specific unresolved theoretical problems such as the cosmological constant problem Weinberg:1988cp and observational tensions such as the Hubble tension Verde:2019ivm provide reasons to study alternatives to GR. The geometric foundation of GR is, however, part of a broader “Trinity of Gravity” that also includes two equivalent formulations of GR: the teleparallel equivalent of GR (TEGR) and the symmetric teleparallel equivalent of GR (STEGR) BeltranJimenez:2019esp . In the TEGR framework, gravity is described through the torsion of the spacetime Aldrovandi:2015wfa , while in STEGR, it is interpreted in terms of nonmetricity of the spacetime BeltranJimenez:2017tkd . These alternative formulations of non-Riemannian geometry provide fertile grounds for developing modified gravity theories based on arbitrary scalar functions of their respective scalar quantities, such as f(T) or f(Q) , where T and Q represent the torsion and nonmetricity scalars, respectively Boehmer:2023fyl ; Boehmer:2021aji ; Boehmer:2022wln . There has been tremendous interest in f(Q) gravity in recent years due to its exceptional geometric interpretation without using curvature or torsion. However, we point out that recently there has been a discussion about potential presence of ghost and strong coupling issues in f(Q) gravity Gomes:2023tur , and whether such ghost degrees of freedom can actually propagate Hu:2023gui . In fact, similar issues also showed up in the study of f(T) gravity, where certain degrees of freedom lose their kinetic terms on the FLRW background BeltranJimenez:2020fvy . It was pointed out in Heisenberg:2023wgk that a direct coupling of the matter field to the connection or a nonminimal coupling between the matter and the geometry sector might alter the situation leading to a healthy theory. A class of ghost free theories in symmetric teleparallel geometry was recently investigated in Bello-Morales:2024vqk . Strong coupling and ghost issues, as well as the question of the actual number of propagating degrees of freedom underscore the need for perturbative stability analysis and Hamiltonian analysis in f(Q) theory. Investigating these issues are important from the theoretical point of view for establishing the viability of modifying gravity in the symmetric teleparallel framework. Indeed, this is an active area of research currently. Although we are aware of the above theoretical issues, this is not the main focus of our investigation here. Rather, our focus is to examine the phenomenological viability of modifying gravity in the symmetric teleparallel framework, along a line of similar works Anagnostopoulos:2021ydo ; Atayde:2021pgb ; Albuquerque:2022eac ; Sahlu:2024pxk ; Goncalves:2024sem ; De:2022jvo . The framework of symmetric teleparallelism gives promising insights into cosmological dynamics. f(Q) gravity has proven to be compatible with the observational data at the level of the background and of the perturbations, such as CMB, supernovae, BAO, redshift-space distortions, growth measurements Lazkoz:2019sjl ; Ayuso:2020dcu ; Frusciante:2021sio . In addition, it does not have problems with the constraints imposed by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis, which means it could successfully compete with other modified gravity theories Anagnostopoulos:2022gej . The \Lambda CDM model based on Einstein’s GR remains a very good fit with available cosmological datasets at least according to Planck 2018 Planck:2018vyg 1 1 1 The recent DESI data DESI:2023ytc apparently favours an evolving dark energy, although there has been arguments that their conclusion is highly driven by the choice of the priors Cortes:2024lgw . 2 2 2 An interesting model was proposed in Anagnostopoulos:2022gej : f(Q)=Qe^{\lambda\frac{Q_{0}}{Q}} . This model, in coincident gauge, although not having any \Lambda CDM-limit in the FLRW cosmology at all, was slightly preferred against the standard cosmological model in fitting various datasets according to the information criteria. . In the context of modified gravity theories, from a phenomenological point of view, an important question is whether a modified gravity theory can give rise to exactly the same kind of background evolution as the GR-based \Lambda CDM model. Such modified gravity theories will then be indistinguishable from the \Lambda CDM model at the background level, and typically one needs to go to the perturbation level to find any distinctive signature. This particular question has been addressed in the context of f(R) gravity Dunsby:2010wg ; He:2012rf ; Fay:2007uy , F(R,G) and modified Gauss-Bonnet gravity Elizalde:2010jx and coincident gauge f(Q) gravity (i.e. considering only the trivial connection branch where Q=-6H^{2} ) Gadbail:2022jco ; Albuquerque:2022eac . However, in general there are three different symmetric teleparallel connection branches respecting spatial flatness, homogeneity and isotropy Hohmann:2021ast , which we denote later as \Gamma_{1},\,\Gamma_{2},\,\Gamma_{3} , with \Gamma_{2},\,\Gamma_{3} commonly being referred to in the literature as the so-called non-coincident gauges Paliathanasis:2023hqq 3 3 3 There is a