Thunderdome : Timelock-Free Rationally-Secure Virtual Channels

Zeta Avarikioti, Yuheng Wang, Yuyi Wang · 2025

Read Thunderdome : Timelock-Free Rationally-Secure Virtual Channels by Zeta Avarikioti, Yuheng Wang, Yuyi Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-14418.txt.

Introduction

Zeta Avarikioti, Yuheng Wang, and Yuyi Wang build a payment network with no timelocks in a 2025 paper on blockchain scaling. Payment channels let users trade off-chain at speed. Recent attacks, though, exploit the timelocks and censorship that guard those channels.

Their system, Thunderdome, stacks virtual channels on a timelock-free base channel. That allows multi-hop payments between strangers with no shared channel. A committee of untrusted watchers, called wardens, guards closing so no honest user loses funds, even offline. Pay tweaks keep wardens and users honest by self-interest, backed by a game-theory proof. A test build on Ethereum priced channel opening near fifteen dollars and worst-case closing near seven.

Catalog record

CREATORZeta Avarikioti, Yuheng Wang, Yuyi Wang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE106 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-14418

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Thunderdome : Timelock-Free Rationally-Secure Virtual Channels Zeta Avarikioti, Yuheng Wang, Yuyi Wang Abstract Payment channel networks (PCNs) offer a promising solution to address the limited transaction throughput of deployed blockchains. However, several attacks have recently been proposed that stress the vulnerability of PCNs to timelock and censoring attacks. To address such attacks, we introduce Thunderdome , the first timelock-free PCN. Instead, Thunderdome leverages the design rationale of virtual channels to extend a timelock-free payment channel primitive, thereby enabling multi-hop transactions without timelocks. Previous works either utilize timelocks or do not accommodate transactions between parties that do not share a channel. At its core, Thunderdome relies on a committee of non-trusted watchtowers, known as wardens, who ensure that no honest party loses funds, even when offline, during the channel closure process. We introduce tailored incentive mechanisms to ensure that all participants follow the protocol’s correct execution. Besides a traditional security proof that assumes an honest majority of the committee, we conduct a formal game-theoretic analysis to demonstrate the security of Thunderdome when all participants, including wardens, act rationally. We implement a proof of concept of Thunderdome on Ethereum to validate its feasibility and evaluate its costs. Our evaluation shows that deploying Thunderdome , including opening the underlying payment channel, costs approximately $15 (0.0089 ETH), while the worst-case cost for closing a channel is about $7 (0.004 ETH). 1 Introduction Blockchains have introduced a groundbreaking decentralized financial paradigm through cryptocurrencies, eliminating the need for trusted intermediaries [ 41 ] . However, blockchains face major scalability limitations, primarily due to the requirement that each transaction be validated by all nodes in the network [ 14 ] . As a result, popular cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin [ 30 ] and Ethereum suffer from relatively slower processing speeds and much lower transaction throughput compared to centralized payment systems like Visa, hindering their potential for mass adoption. While solutions such as more efficient consensus protocols [ 12 , 35 , 15 ] can increase throughput, they typically require changes to existing protocols, often causing a hard fork. To overcome these scalability challenges, Payment Channel Networks (PCNs) have emerged as a promising alternative [ 22 ] . A payment channel functions as a secure off-chain "joint account" between two parties, utilizing the blockchain only for the opening and closing phases. This approach substantially reduces the number of on-chain transactions, effectively addressing the scalability issues of the underlying blockchain. Payment channels involve three primary operations: Open , Update , and Close . The channel is opened by locking a certain amount of coins on-chain, referred to as the channel balance. The parties can then transact off-chain by updating their channel balance through the exchange of digitally signed messages that specify the new distribution of coins. Finally, the channel can be closed, settling all off-chain transactions with the final agreed-upon state posted on-chain. To prevent fraud, payment channel protocols often include a dispute period with a timelock , allowing a counterparty to penalize a potentially dishonest party. For example, in the Bitcoin Lightning Network [ 32 ] , a party can claim the entire channel balance if the other party posts an outdated update. An overlay Payment Channel Network (PCN) operates as a Layer 2 solution on top of a single blockchain (Layer 1), primarily functioning off-chain to address the scalability limitations of the base network. Notably, a PCN allows parties with at least one direct payment channel to make payments across the network to other parties, even if they do not share a direct channel. To facilitate multi-hop payments from sender to receiver, a path of sufficiently funded channels is identified. All channels along this path are then updated using lock contracts with a timelock to ensure the atomic execution of the payment. Techniques such as Hash Timelock Contracts (HTLCs), used in the Bitcoin Lightning Network [ 32 ] , and methods like adaptor signatures [ 37 , 3 ] or Verifiable Timed Signatures (VTS) [ 38 ] , are commonly employed in PCNs. These techniques rely on timelocks to ensure that parties can recover their coins in the event of a payment failure. Thus, timelocks are essential for the security of both payment channel primitives and multi-hop payment protocols in PCNs. Recent research reveals that timelocks can introduce new attack vectors, notably censorship attacks such as timelock bribing. These attacks show that PCNs relying on timelock contracts for multi-hop payments might allow an adversary to steal the entire channel balance by delaying the on-chain inclusion of a specific transaction [ 29 , 40 , 13 , 21 ] . Similar vulnerabilities are present in the payment channel primitives, as noted in [ 8 , 9 ] , these issues arise from the design rationale of timelock-based channel protocols: Lighting [ 32 ] and Blitz use a "revoke until time T , else execute" logic, while DMC [ 16 ] employs a "revoke within time T , else execute" logic. In these cases, censoring an honest party’s transaction prevents them from revoking misbehavior. Conversely, Thora [ 2 ] uses an "execute until time T , else revoke" logic, and Perun [ 17 ] follows a "reply within time T , else get punished" logic. In these designs, censoring an honest party’s transaction blocks them from executing the committed transactions, resulting in a loss of funds. These censorship attacks, while difficult to trace as excluded transactions are not reported on-chain, can be practically executed using TxWithhold Smart Contracts, as highlighted by BitMEX Research [ 1 ] . Additionally, the cost of such attacks can be significantly reduced since multiple contracts can be targeted simultaneously (e.g., as many as fit in a block) [ 7 , 40 ] . A common approach to lowering the success probability of censorship attacks is to use longer timelocks [ 29 ] . However, this strategy worsens another significant drawback of timelocks, known as the griefing attack [ 25 ] . In such attacks, the receiver initiates a payment path within a PCN but then aborts the payment, causing intermediaries to incur an opportunity cost as they lock their assets for the timelock duration without receiving any routing fee. Given the inherent instability of real-world networks and the potential for network outages, relying solely on timelocks for secure and efficient PCN implementation proves to be a flawed approach. This raises a critical question: Can secure PCNs be designed without the reliance on timelocks? 1.1 Related work Various solutions have been proposed to counter the rising threat of censorship attacks on Payment Channel Networks (PCNs), many of which exploit miners’ incentives, as miners often control censorship. Nadahalli et al. [ 29 ] were among the first to identify the safety vulnerabilities of Hash Timelock Contracts (HTLCs) under censorship, analyzing parameters like timelock duration and transaction fees to determine when HTLCs remain secure. Building on this, Tsabary et al. [ 40 ] introduced MAD-HTLC, a modified structure that incentivizes miners to act as natural enforcers by penalizing malicious actors. However, the counter-bribing vulnerabilities in MAD-HTLC were later identified, leading to the development of He-HTLC [ 21 ] and Rapidash [ 13 ] . Although these approaches provide secure channel primitives, they rely on specific assumptions, such as

Read the complete text