Comparative analysis of two episodes of strongly geoeffective CME events in November and December 2023
M. Temmer, M. Dumbović, K. Martinić, G.M. Cappello, A.K. Remeshan, F. Matković, D. Milošić, F. Koller, J. Čalogović, R. Susino, M. Romoli · 2025
Read Comparative analysis of two episodes of strongly geoeffective CME events in November and December 2023 by M. Temmer, M. Dumbović, K. Martinić, G.M. Cappello, A.K. Remeshan, F. Matković, D. Milošić, F. Koller, J. Čalogović, R. Susino, M. Romoli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-14295.txt.
Introduction
Temmer and co-authors compare two bursts of solar eruptions in 2025 that struck Earth in late 2023 and caused strong geomagnetic storms. Each episode launched several coronal mass ejections, partly from the same active regions, one solar rotation apart. The team rebuilt each eruption's path in 3D and fed the results into a propagation model. That linked what telescopes saw at the Sun with what probes felt near Earth.
The November episode drove the stronger storm, with aurora-like arcs and a three-step plunge in the storm index. In December, one eruption's shock plowed into an earlier one's structure. Interacting structures and current-sheet effects shaped both impacts. The study sharpens forecasts of storm strength.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Temmer, M. Dumbović, K. Martinić, G.M. Cappello, A.K. Remeshan, F. Matković, D. Milošić, F. Koller, J. Čalogović, R. Susino, M. Romoli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-14295
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparative analysis of two episodes of strongly geoeffective CME events in November and December 2023 M. Temmer, M. Dumbović, K. Martinić, G.M. Cappello, A.K. Remeshan, F. Matković, D. Milošić, F. Koller, J. Čalogović, R. Susino, M. Romoli Abstract Context. In autumn 2023 series of close-in-time eruptive events were observed remotely and measured in-situ. For that period, we study a set of analogous events on the Sun, where several coronal mass ejections (CMEs) were launched partly from the same (active) regions close to a coronal hole. The two episodes of events are separated by a full solar rotation covering the period October 31 – November 3 and November 27– 28, 2023. Aims. Both episodes of eruptive events are related to strong geomagnetic storms occurring on November 4–5 and December 1–2, 2023. We point out the complexity for each set of events and aim to understand how the global magnetic field configuration, solar wind conditions, and interaction between the structures relate to these geomagnetic effects. Methods. We use the graduated cylindrical shell (GCS) 3D reconstruction method for deriving the direction of motion and speed of each CME. The GCS results serve as input for the drag-based model with enhanced latitudinal information (3D DBM), facilitating the assessment of its connection to in-situ measurements. This approach significantly aids in the integrated interpretation of in-situ signatures and solar surface structures. Results. The first episode caused visible Stable Auroral Red (SAR) arcs, with a Dst index that dropped in three steps down to − - 163 nT on November 5, 2023. Close in time two CME-related shocks arrived, separated by a sector boundary crossing (SBC), and followed by a short-duration flux rope-like structure. For the second episode, auroral lights were observed related to a two-step drop in the Dst index down to − - 108 nT on December 1, 2023. A shock from a CME within the magnetic structure of another CME ahead was identified, again combined with a SBC. Additionally, a clear flux rope structure from the shock producing CME is detected. In both events, we observed distinct short-term variations in the magnetic field (“ripples”) together with fluctuations in density and temperature that followed the SBC. Conclusions. The study presents a comparative analysis of two episodes of multiple eruptive events in November and December 2023. Besides interacting CME structures, we highlight modulation effects in the geomagnetic impact due to magnetic structures which are related to the SBC. These most likely contributed to the stronger geomagnetic impact and production of SAR arcs for the November 4–5, 2023 event. At the Sun, we found the orientation of the heliospheric current sheet to be highly tilted, which might have caused additional effects due to the CMEs interacting with it. 1 Introduction Based on results from cycle 23, the rates of intense geomagnetic storms during maximum/declining solar cycle phases are found to be almost three/two times as high as during the rising phase of a solar cycle ( Echer et al., 2008 ) . This is mainly due to numerous eruptive flares occurring close in time and space, resulting in multiple coronal mass ejections (CMEs) that jointly evolve and may interact in interplanetary space ( Lugaz et al., 2017 ; Manchester et al., 2017 ; Zhang et al., 2021 , see reviews by e.g.,) . Increased number of solar eruptions create extraordinary conditions in near-Earth space, commonly known under the term “Space Weather” ( Cliver & Svalgaard, 2004 ; Bothmer et al., 2007 , see e.g.,) . Severe impacts on near-Earth space are usually related to the enhanced strength and complexity of the magnetic field in the impacting solar events (see e.g., the “panoramic” paper by Tsurutani et al., 2023 , presenting in a combined overview our gained knowledge of space physics and space weather over the past 65 years) . The complexity of the interplanetary magnetic field sweeping over Earth typically increases due to the interaction between multiple large-scale magnetic structures. These cover not only CMEs, but also co-rotating interaction regions (CIRs), formed by high-speed solar wind streams originating from coronal holes (CHs), or the heliospheric current sheet (HCS). It is broadly accepted, when all these components evolving together as compound interplanetary magnetic structures, they cause much stronger geomagnetic effects compared to their isolated appearance ( Echer & Gonzalez, 2004 ; Dumbović et al., 2015 , e.g.,) . It should be noted that the occurrence of successive CMEs or merged interaction regions not always cause stronger geomagnetic effects, especially when related to northward B z components ( Burlaga et al., 2002 ; Burlaga et al., 2003 , see) . Propagating shocks caused by energetic CMEs, when penetrating through a CME ahead are prone to enhance the magnetic field complexity ( Lugaz et al., 2016 ) . In-depth case studies investigate the process of CME-CME interaction ( Gopalswamy et al., 2001 ; Temmer et al., 2012 ; Scolini et al., 2020 , e.g.,) , or CME-CIR interaction ( Fenrich & Luhmann, 1998 ; Heinemann et al., 2019 ; Winslow et al., 2021 ; Geyer et al., 2023 , e.g.,) . However, the details of the interaction processes between these different structures are still not well understood. This complicates the interpretation of in-situ measurements and the development of reliable models for forecasting geomagnetic effects. Compared to 20 years ago, during the peak of solar cycle 23, the coverage (multiple viewpoints, varying distances including heliospheric imagers) and quality (temporal and spatial resolution) of solar data have improved substantially. These advancements have been accompanied by significant progress in our investigation techniques and modeling approaches. Solar cycle 24 was notably weak ( McComas et al., 2013 , e.g.,) , which made it challenging to test our understanding of complex solar activity phenomena. The current solar cycle 25 appears to be more similar to cycle 23 in terms of geomagnetic effects and the complexity of the related phenomena ( Berdichevsky et al., 2000 ; Burlaga et al., 2002 ; Burlaga et al., 2003 , see e.g.,) . Recent events occurring at the end of October and beginning of November 2023 produced intricate in-situ measured profiles together with strong auroral light activities. In addition to auroral lights, a special type of atmospheric light phenomena, so-called Stable Auroral Red (SAR) arcs ( Cole, 1965 ) , were observed almost globally on November 5, 2023 reaching even southern Europe. SAR arcs are known to be related to extreme conditions in the Earth’s ring current system ( Kozyra & Liemohn, 2003 , see review by e.g.,) . Besides SAR arcs, on November 5, 2023 also a very rarely observed anisotropic cosmic-ray enhancement (ACRE) was reported by Gil et al. (2024) . A full rotation later, end of November 2023, again a series of CMEs was launched heading towards Earth. These events resulted in strong geomagnetic effects, but to a comparatively weaker Disturbance Storm Time index (Dst of - 108 nT for December 1, 2023 versus - 163 nT for November 5, 2023) and no SAR arcs. In the present study we investigate these two episodes of CME events, to understand their similarities as well as differences. The two episodes are united by the involvement of similar (active) regions and the same CH, but separated in time by a