Constrained Fuel and Time Optimal 6DOF Powered Descent Guidance Using Indirect Optimization

Nicholas P. Nurre and Ehsan Taheri · 2025

Read Constrained Fuel and Time Optimal 6DOF Powered Descent Guidance Using Indirect Optimization by Nicholas P. Nurre and Ehsan Taheri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-14173.txt.

Introduction

Nurre and Taheri solve the powered descent problem for a rocket that must land with full six-degree-of-freedom motion, not just a point mass. Their setup limits thrust size, gimbal angle, tilt, glide slope, and spin rate, then seeks the path that burns the least fuel, or takes the least time.

Rather than attacking the hard boundary-value problem head-on, they soften the path limits with penalty terms and solve a smooth family of nearby problems, stepping toward the true one. An indirect shooting method with continuation finds the extremal paths, helped by a new formula for the multipliers tied to the softened limits. The results are checked against DIDO, a standard solver.

Catalog record

CREATORNicholas P. Nurre and Ehsan Taheri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-14173

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constrained Fuel and Time Optimal 6DOF Powered Descent Guidance Using Indirect Optimization Nicholas P. Nurre and Ehsan Taheri Abstract Powered descent guidance (PDG) problems subject to six-degrees-of-freedom (6DOF) dynamics allow for enforcement of practical attitude constraints. However, numerical solutions to 6DOF PDG problems are challenging due to fast rotational dynamics coupled with translational dynamics, and the presence of highly nonlinear state/control path inequality constraints. In this work, constrained fuel- and time-optimal 6DOF PDG problems are solved leveraging a regularized indirect method, subject to inequality constraints on the thrust magnitude, thruster gimbal angle, rocket tilt angle, glideslope angle, and angular velocity magnitude. To overcome the challenges associated with solving the resulting multipoint boundary-value problems (MPBVPs), the state-only path inequality constraints (SOPICs) are enforced through an interior penalty function method, which embeds the resulting MPBVPs into a multi-parameter smooth neighboring families of two-point BVPs. Extremal solutions are obtained using an indirect multiple-shooting solution method with numerical continuation. Moreover, an empirical relation is derived for the directly-adjoined Lagrange multipliers associated with SOPICs. The fuel- and time-optimal trajectories are compared against solutions of DIDO — a capable pseudospectral-based software for solving practical constrained optimal control problems. 1 Introduction P owered descent guidance (PDG) has been well studied since the 1960s [ 1 ] and was first implemented when NASA used an explicit guidance law in the Apollo missions [ 2 ] . Nowadays, computational-based guidance methods represent the state-of-the-art [ 3 ] and have enabled, most notably, SpaceX to autonomously and safely perform extremely complicated rocket landings [ 4 ] with convex optimization [ 5 , 6 ] . Unlike three-degree-of-freedom (3DOF) PDG problems, the 6DOF PDG problem allows for the enforcement of non-trivial attitude dynamics constraints [ 7 ] . A difficulty, however, lies in the presence of highly nonlinear couplings between translational/rotational dynamics and existence of various control/state constraints, making 6DOF PDG problems quite challenging to solve. However, direct optimization methods [ 8 ] have been shown to provide reliable solutions. The recent computational advances in convex optimization allow this class of PDG problems to be solved in real time [ 9 ] . For instance, Refs. [ 10 , 11 ] solve the 6DOF PDG problem with a convex-based approach, which is extended to handle state-triggered constraints in Ref. [ 12 ] . Ref. [ 13 ] offers another convex-based approach to the problem using augmented convex–concave decomposition. Direct methods are more practical in tackling 6DOF PDG problems, but may require denser grid points to generate accurate solutions due to discretization errors. They also may have difficulty in solving optimal control problems (OCPs) with singular control arcs [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] and can’t offer concrete insights into the control structure of the problem. As such, Refs. [ 17 , 7 ] point out the optimal solution to the 6DOF PDG problem remains an open problem. Indirect-based methods offer high-resolution solutions that can provide greater accuracy. It is also possible to obtain entirely new classes of solutions to OCPs which were once believed to have only a particular extremal control profile. For instance, Ref. [ 18 ] used the Uniform Trigonometrization Method (UTM) [ 19 ] to solve a well-known free-flyer problem [ 20 ] . The authors present a completely new solution that consists of a singular control arc, outperforming the bang-bang solutions reported by Betts [ 21 ] (see Chap. 6) and also the solution obtained with GPOPS-II [ 22 ] . Indirect methods can also be used for generating large databases of optimal and near-optimal solutions [ 23 , 24 ] . For these reasons, indirect-based approaches continue to retain their importance, in particular, to determine the theoretically guaranteed extremal solutions. In fact, explicit guidance laws such as the Apollo guidance is proven to be optimal (under certain assumptions) through the application of the indirect method. A recent example of the theoretical insights gained by indirect methods is Ref. [ 25 ] where fuel-optimal 3DOF PDG problems subject to a glideslope angle constraint are studied and it is proved that 1) the optimal thrust magnitude has a bang-bang profile (i.e., no singular control arc), 2) the optimal thrust magnitude can have more than three subarcs, and 3) the glideslope constraint can only be active at isolated points. These theoretical insights into the structure of the optimal solution (e.g., the number of control switches and the time of switches) allows for identifying a number of key features in OCPs and leveraging them for developing new algorithms, as is achieved in [ 26 ] . Indirect approaches involve deriving the necessary conditions of optimality and numerically solving the resulting boundary-value problem, either through root-finding or collocation. Our studies indicate that solving OCPs with different solution methodologies is illuminating and enriches our understanding of the potential solutions. Our goal, however, is not to compare advantages and disadvantages of direct and indirect methods, which are already addressed comprehensively in the literature [ 21 ] , but to advance the state of the art in solving 6DOF PDG problems using enhanced indirect methods. In the literature, translational-only 3DOF PDG problems are studied in Refs. [ 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] using the indirect methods. Ref. [ 27 ] provides a proof for the thrust magnitude switching structure of the 3DOF PDG problem and develops an analytical guidance law based on the structure of the thrust profile. This work is extended in Ref. [ 28 ] by considering the thrust pointing control constraint that leads to approximate open-loop control expressions. The bang-bang thrust control is regularized using the hyperbolic tangent smoothing [ 31 ] . Ref. [ 29 ] derives exact open-loop control expressions for the 3DOF PDG problems under a thrust pointing control constraint and a glideslope constraint. Ref. [ 30 ] develops an indirect method that can rapidly generate solutions to the 3DOF PDG problems. Refs. [ 17 , 32 ] investigate the 3DOF PDG problem with 2 translational and 1 rotational degrees of freedom, which is useful for considering simple attitude constraints. Ref. [ 17 ] solves the problem by deriving the exact open-loop control expressions and also provides a proof on the control structure. Ref. [ 32 ] solved the problem through a generalized vectorized trigonometrization method, which is an advanced indirect method for solving constrained OCPs. The presence of different state-path inequality constraints is another challenging aspect of 6DOF PDG problems, since they can alter the structure of optimal control profiles. Unlike the direct methods, the indirect method still heavily lacks in practical enforcement methods for these types of constraints. Two forms of the necessary conditions that have been derived are the direct and indirect adjoining approaches [ 33 ] . Practical implementation of these necessary conditions using traditional indirect methods has been difficult because the sequence of active and inactive constraints along with their time duration must be known a priori . They can also introduce corner and/or jump discontinuities in the costates/Hamiltonian. These conditions have to be derived depending on the order of the constraints and result in notoriously difficult-to-solve MPBVPs. However, in recent years, notable progresses are made in detecting switch times [ 34 ] and in overcoming the challenges associated

Read the complete text