Can we hear beats with pulsar timing arrays?

Shun Yamamoto, Hideki Asada · 2025

Read Can we hear beats with pulsar timing arrays? by Shun Yamamoto, Hideki Asada (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13450.txt.

Introduction

Shun Yamamoto and Hideki Asada ask whether pulsar timing can hear gravitational beats in a 2025 paper. A lone supermassive black hole pair rings spacetime in a steady pattern. That pattern mimics the glow of a random background from the early universe, a deep ambiguity.

Add a second pair with a near-matching tone, and the two waves beat against each other. The beat swells and fades the timing pattern at the difference of the two tones. The authors solve for that wobble in closed form. Reading the wobble would separate one loud pair from a background hum. Pulsar clocks across the galaxy become, in effect, ears for beats.

Catalog record

CREATORShun Yamamoto, Hideki Asada
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13450

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can we hear beats with pulsar timing arrays? Shun Yamamoto, Hideki Asada Abstract An isolated supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) produces an identical cross-correlation pattern of pulsar timings as an isotropic stochastic background gravitational waves (GWs) generated possibly by inflation. Can there remain the identical cross-correlation pattern in the presence of a secondary SMBHB? To address this issue, the present paper considers GWs with slightly different frequencies f 1 f_{1} and f 2 f_{2} coming from two different directions. Beats between the two GWs can modify angular correlation patterns. The beat-induced correlation patterns are not stationary but modulated with a beat frequency f b ​ e ​ a ​ t ≡ | f 1 − f 2 | f_{beat}\equiv|f_{1}-f_{2}| . We obtain an analytic formula to present a proof-of-principle that f b ​ e ​ a ​ t f_{beat} can be measured from the modulated angular correlations. I Introduction The idea of using radio pulse timing to search for gravitational waves (GWs) can be dated back to Reference Estabrook ; Sazhin ; Detweiler . As a pioneering work, Hellings and Downs (HD) found that the sky correlation pattern among pulsar pairs, which depends upon the angle \gamma between the lines of sight to the pulsars viewed from Earth, can be a strong evidence of GWs Hellings , because it reflects the quadrupole nature of GWs CreightonBook ; MaggioreBook ; Anholm2009 ; Jenet . See e.g. Reference Romano ; Romano2024 for a review on detection methods of stochastic GW backgrounds. Eventually, several teams of pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) have recently reported a strong evidence of nano-hertz GWs Agazie2023 ; Antoniadis2023 ; Reardon2023 ; Xu2023 . According to their papers, superpositions of supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) are among possible GW sources, though improved methods, other possible explanations, and new physics have been vastly pursued e.g. Chen2020 ; Ellis ; Smarra ; Gouttenoire ; Franciolini2023 ; DeRocco ; Franciolini2024 ; Figueroa ; Athron ; Shih ; Kumar ; Bian ; Chen2024 . For an isotropic stochastic background of GWs composed of the plus and cross polarization modes in general relativity, the expected correlated response of pulsar pairs follows the HD curve. It is worthwhile to mention that an isolated supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) produces an identical cross-correlation pattern as an isotropic stochastic background Cornish . Can there remain the identical cross-correlation pattern in the presence of a secondary SMBHB? In order to address this issue, the present paper considers GWs with slightly different frequencies f_{1} and f_{2} coming from two different directions. For a model as a confusion-noise case studied in References Allen2023 ; Allen2024 , all sources have an identical fixed GW frequency, such that they all lie in the same frequency bin. The resultant correlation pattern is stationary and identical as the HD curve. Yet, one may ask if the situation can be changed when GWs with slightly different frequencies f_{1} and f_{2} ( f_{1}\approx f_{2} ) are considered. This question arises because an interference (called a beat) between the two GWs can increase (or decrease) the superimposed GW signal. The superimposed GW signal is not stationary but modulated. Figure 1 shows an example of beats between two sinusoidal waves. Figure 1: Beat between two sinusoidal waves traveling along the same line. h_{1} and f_{1} are the amplitude and frequency of the primary wave, while h_{2} and f_{2} are those of the secondary one. Here, h_{2}/h_{1}=0.5 and f_{2}/f_{1}=0.8 are chosen. The blue, red and black (in color) curves denote the primary, secondary, and sum of sinusoidal waves and respectively, where a green curve means an envelope wave of frequency (f_{1}-f_{2})/2 . The main purpose of this paper is to examine if the beat frequency f_{beat}=|f_{1}-f_{2}| can be measured in principle from modulated correlation patterns. This paper is structured as follows. Section II discusses a modulated angular correlation pattern due to an interference between GWs with slightly different frequencies coming from two sky locations. Section III demonstrates that the beat frequency f_{beat} can be measured in principle from the modulated correlations. Section VI is devoted to Conclusion. Throughout this paper, the unit of c=1 is used and the center of the coordinates is the solar barycenter, safely approximated as the Earth. The superscripts I=1 and 2 refer to the primary GW and secondary one, while the subscripts K=1,2,3 and 4 refer to four equal time domains that are defined in Section II. II Modulating PTA angular correlations II.1 Basic formulation ”Source averaging” is a useful calculational method for isotropic GW sources in PTA e.g. CreightonBook ; MaggioreBook ; Anholm2009 ; Jenet . On the other hand, ”pulsar averaging” was first introduced in Cornish and Sesana (2013) Cornish , where an isolated SMBH is focused on. In the present paper, we use ”pulsar averaging” for monochromatic and planar gravitational waves coming from two sky locations. See References McGrath2021 ; McGrath2022 ; Guo ; Kubo ; D'Orazio for possible corrections by a nearby SMBHB and their cosmological implication. In addition, noise terms are ignored, because the present paper focuses on a proof-of-principle. We consider two compact GW sources represented by SMBHBs, labeled by I (I=1,2) , for which f_{I} , \hat{\Omega}_{I} and h_{IA} for A=+,\times as the plus and cross modes denote the intrinsic frequency of GWs, the source direction with respect to the Earth, and the amplitude of the I -th GW, respectively. The separation angle between the two GW directions is \beta , defined by \cos\beta=\hat{\Omega}_{1}\cdot\hat{\Omega}_{2} Allen2023 ; Allen2024 . The waveform at the Earth is a superposition of GWs from the two sources, which can be expressed as CreightonBook ; MaggioreBook \displaystyle h_{ij}(t)=\sum_{I=1,2}\sum_{A=+,\times}h_{IA}\exp[i2\pi f_{I}(t+t_{I})]e_{ij}^{A}(\hat{\Omega}_{I}), (1) where t_{I} is a time defined by \Phi_{I} denoting the initial phase of the I -th GW ( \Phi_{I}\equiv 2\pi f_{I}t_{I} ), and e_{ij}^{A}(\hat{\Omega}_{I}) denotes the polarization tensor along the direction \hat{\Omega}_{I} . We focus only on the Earth terms because pulsar terms vanish in the full-sky average Hellings ; Cornish ; Romano2024 . At the Earth, the redshift of radio signals from the a -th pulsar due to GWs from the two directions can be written as Anholm2009 z_{a}(t)=\sum_{I=1,2}z_{aI}(t), (2) where the contribution from the I -th direction is denoted as \displaystyle z_{aI}(t)= \displaystyle\sum_{A=+,\times}F_{a}^{A}(\hat{\Omega}_{I})h_{IA}\exp[i2\pi f_{I}(t+t_{I})], (3) and the antenna pattern function in PTAs for a pulsar in the direction \hat{p}_{a} is \displaystyle F_{a}^{A}(\hat{\Omega}_{I})=\frac{1}{2}\frac{\hat{p}_{a}^{i}\hat{p}_{a}^{j}}{1+\hat{\Omega}_{I}\cdot\hat{p}_{a}}e_{ij}^{A}(\hat{\Omega}_{I}). (4) II.2 Factorization of PTA angular correlations A full-sky averaged correlation between the a -th and b -th pulsars (in the directions \hat{p}_{a} and \hat{p}_{b} , respectively) with the separation angle \gamma over the observation duration T_{obs} is \displaystyle\langle z_{a}z_{b}\rangle(\gamma)= \displaystyle\frac{1}{(4\pi)^{2}T_{obs}}\int_{S^{2}}d\Omega_{a}\int_{S^{2}}d\Omega_{b}\int_{0}^{T_{obs}}dt \displaystyle\times\delta(\cos\gamma-\hat{p}_{a}\cdot\hat{p}_{b})[z_{a}(t)z_{b}^{*}(t)], (5) where S^{2} means the 2-sphere centered at Earth, \int_{S^{2}}d\Omega_{a} and \int_{S^{2}}d\Omega_{b} denote the integration of the a -th and b -th pulsars over the full sky, respectively, the asterisk denotes the complex conjugate, and the Dirac’s delta function is inserted to respect the separation angle Cornish . In the presence of a secondary GW, Eq. ( 5 ) is the sum as \langle z_{a}z_{b}\rangle=\langle z_{a1}z_{b1}\rangle+\langle z_{a2}z_{b2}\rangle+\langle z_{a1}z_{b2}\rangle+\langle z_{a2}z_{b1}\rangle . A diagonal term such as \langle z_{a1}z_{b1}\rangle and \langle z_{a2}z_{b2}\rangle is identical as Eq. (18) in Reference Cornish . Figure 2: Geometrical factor \Pi(\gamma) for \beta=0,\pi/4,\pi/2,3\pi/4,\pi , where h_{1+}=h_{1\times}=1 and h_{2}\equiv h_{2+}=h_{2\times}=0.5 are chosen for its simplicity. See

Read the complete text