Comparative Withholding Behavior Analysis of Historical Energy Storage Bids in California

Neal Ma, Ningkun Zheng, Ning Qi, Bolun Xu · 2025

Read Comparative Withholding Behavior Analysis of Historical Energy Storage Bids in California by Neal Ma, Ningkun Zheng, Ning Qi, Bolun Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13324.txt.

Introduction

Neal Ma and co-authors study how battery owners bid in California power markets in a 2025 paper. Using market data from July 2023 to October 2024, they ask whether storage firms hold back supply to lift prices. The concern grows as more batteries join the grid and can shape prices.

Bids tracked market prices closely and rose sharply during price spikes. Tests showed a strong link between spikes and held-back capacity, which suggests firms can foresee surges. A daily pattern also stood out when bids were compared with the best bids made with hindsight. Readers get clear evidence of profit-driven holding back, plus a case for tighter market rules as storage grows.

Catalog record

CREATORNeal Ma, Ningkun Zheng, Ning Qi, Bolun Xu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13324

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparative Withholding Behavior Analysis of Historical Energy Storage Bids in California Thanks: This work was partly supported by the National Science Foundation under award ECCS-2239046. Neal Ma, Ningkun Zheng, Ning Qi, Bolun Xu Abstract The rapid growth of battery energy storage in wholesale electricity markets calls for a deeper understanding of storage operators’ bidding strategies and their market impacts. This study examines energy storage bidding data from the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) between July 1, 2023, and October 1, 2024, with a primary focus on economic withholding strategies. Our analysis reveals that storage bids are closely aligned with day-ahead and real-time market clearing prices, with notable bid inflation during price spikes. Statistical tests demonstrate a strong correlation between price spikes and capacity withholding, indicating that operators can anticipate price surges and use market volatility to increase profitability. Comparisons with optimal hindsight bids further reveal a clear daily periodic bidding pattern, highlighting extensive economic withholding. These results underscore potential market inefficiencies and highlight the need for refined regulatory measures to address economic withholding as storage capacity in the market continues to grow. I Introduction With the rapid integration of energy storage resources into power systems, especially within the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), understanding the strategic behavior of energy storage systems (ESS) and their impact on market operations is increasingly critical. From 2020 to 2024, CAISO interconnected over 10,000 MW of battery capacity [ 1 ] . With this growing influx of Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) in wholesale markets, most BESS units now prioritize price arbitrage within the energy market, charging during low-price periods, driven by zero-marginal cost solar and wind generation, and discharging during high-price periods, such as the rapid ramping intervals in the evenings in California. BESS bids differ fundamentally from those of conventional generators due to the distinct physical and economic properties of storage systems [ 2 ] . Unlike traditional bids based on fuel costs and system constraints, which are well-understood by system operators, BESS bids rely on private market condition forecasts and strategic timing to maximize profit potential [ 3 ] . Market design studies [ 4 ] and CAISO regulations [ 5 ] acknowledge that energy storage bids should be guided by predicted price trends, given their limited energy supply and unique ability to target high-price periods, aligning with market conditions where supply-demand imbalances intensify. In CAISO, BESS operators are required to bid their full capacity, precluding physical withholding but allowing for economic withholding—bids crafted not on operational costs but on anticipated market opportunities. While economic withholding by storage systems is legitimate within regulatory frameworks, it does not eliminate the risk of inefficiencies and potential market power abuse. Some BESS units may lack advanced forecasting tools or sophisticated bidding software, relying instead on ad hoc strategies. Meanwhile, others may exercise market power similarly to conventional generators, potentially inflating prices, making it challenging to differentiate between various bidding motivations. Although emerging research examines the strategic bidding and potential market power of storage systems [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , little has been done to analyze the actual bidding behavior of current market-participating energy storage systems. In this study, we collect public BESS bid data from CAISO and analyze bidding patterns with the following key findings: • BESS participants engage in extensive economic withholding to strategically charge during mid-day and discharge in late evenings, with withholding more prevalent in the day-ahead markets due to lower price volatility. • Through comparisons with hindsight optimal bids generated using historical prices, we show that BESS bids are significantly inflated beyond what is required to reflect future opportunity value. • This inflated withholding may reduce market efficiency, as BESS units can miss price spikes when these occur outside typical late evening discharge windows. We support our analysis with an extreme example day of Aug 16, 2024, in which storage failed to mitigate system price spikes that occurred outside their preferred discharge hours. • Comparative analysis between price spike and non-spike days shows that BESS participants design bids in anticipation of price spikes, with notably higher discharge bids on spike days than on regular days. This raises concerns about market power exercise and underscores both the urgency and complexity of regulating storage market power. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II introduces the methodology of data collection and analytic methods. Section III presents the analysis results, and Section IV discusses key findings and provides the conclusion. II Methodology II-A Data Collection We collect from published energy storage bid data from between July 1, 2023 until October 1, 2024. These data are scraped directly from Daily Energy Storage Reports [ 12 ] and include aggregated energy storage bids 1 1 1 Code and data: [https://github.com/nmadev/CAISO-EnergyStorage] . Bid data are binned into 11 discrete segments, as detailed in Table I , and a self-schedule segment, where BESS schedules available capacity and operates as price-takers. The self-schedule segment never exceeds 6 % of the total bid capacity and thus is excluded from these analyses. Additionally, during the period of interest, there are no bids that fall in the highest-valued bid segment, segment 11 . While we primarily analyze charge and discharge bid segment data for both the integrated forward market (IFM) and real-time pre-dispatch (RTPD), the published data also includes energy and state of charge awards, ancillary service awards, and hybrid resource data. These data are aggregated across CAISO so we do not have transparency into the spatial distribution of bids, awards, and capacity. TABLE I: Bid Segment Definitions Segment Label Range ($/MW) Segment Label Range ($/MW) 1 [-150, -100] 7 (50, 100] 2 (-100, -50] 8 (100, 200] 3 (-50, -15] 9 (200, 500] 4 (-15, 0] 10 (500, 1000] 5 (0, 15] 11 (1000, 2000] 6 (15, 50] From these bid segments, we define a weighted average bid from the average value of each individual bid segment, v_{i} , and proportion of total segmented bids, p_{i} , that a certain bid segment constitutes. The weighted average bid, \overline{v} , can be expressed as: \overline{v}=\sum_{i=1}^{11}p_{i}v_{i},p_{i}=\frac{\text{Bid segment quantity in MW}}{\text{Total bid quantity in MW}} (1) This weighted average is sensitive to economic withholding for both charge and discharge bids. Discharge bids that are shifted to higher segments to withhold capacity will artificially inflate the average discharge bid while charge bids moved to negatively-priced segments to prevent charge capacity will lower the average bid price. We also define the bid spread at a given time as the difference between weighted average discharge and weighted average charge bids, or: \overline{v}_{\mathrm{spread}}=\overline{v}_{\mathrm{discharge}}-\overline{v}_{\mathrm{charge}} (2) For periods where BESS operators are withholding capacity, we expect the bid spread to increase through the inflation of discharge bids, deflation of charge bids, or both. Real-time and day-ahead price data are obtained for all three zones and four hubs in CAISO, respectively. Real-time price data are taken at 5-minute granularity while day-ahead prices are hourly. For each, a minimum, maximum, and average aggregation is constructed from the instantaneous minimum, maximum, and unweighted average price across all zones/hubs. Temporal aggregations are taken as the mean price over the aggregated time-period. II-B Hindsight Optimal

Read the complete text