On the development of open geographical data infrastructures in Latin America: progress and challenges

Daniela Ballari, Willington Siabato, Christophe Claramunt, Felix Mata, Roberto Zagal, Rodolfo Franco · 2025

Read On the development of open geographical data infrastructures in Latin America: progress and challenges by Daniela Ballari, Willington Siabato, Christophe Claramunt, Felix Mata, Roberto Zagal, Rodolfo Franco (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13235.txt.

Introduction

Daniela Ballari and co-authors study open map data systems in Latin America in this 2025 paper. Open geographical data infrastructures let the public reach and reuse government map data. Such access can boost openness and sound choices in public life.

The authors review how far these systems have come in the region and where the gaps lie. Few systems in Latin America allow free use and reuse of their data. A wide digital divide shapes what gets built. The team sees early growth, with room for citizens and groups to help shape the work. They call for a shared research plan across borders.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniela Ballari, Willington Siabato, Christophe Claramunt, Felix Mata, Roberto Zagal, Rodolfo Franco
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13235

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the development of open geographical data infrastructures in Latin America: progress and challenges Daniela Ballari, Willington Siabato, Christophe Claramunt, Felix Mata, Roberto Zagal, Rodolfo Franco Abstract Open data initiatives and infrastructures play an essential role in favoring better data access, participation, and transparency in government operations and decision-making. Open Geographical Data Infrastructures (OGDIs) allow citizens to access and scrutinize government and public data, thereby enhancing accountability and evidence-based decision-making. This encourages citizen engagement and participation in public affairs and offers researchers, non-governmental organizations, civil society, and business sectors novel opportunities to analyze and disseminate large amounts of geographical data and to address social, urban, and environmental challenges. In Latin America, while recent open government agendas have shown an inclination towards transparency, citizen participation, and collaboration, only a limited number of OGDIs allow unrestricted use and re-use of their data. Given the region’s cultural, social, and economic disparities, there is a contrasting digital divide that significantly impacts how OGDIs are being developed. Therefore, this paper analyses recent progress in developing OGDIs in Latin America, technological gaps, and open geographical data initiatives. The main results denote an early development of OGDIs in the region. Nevertheless, this opens the door for the timely involvement of citizens and non-government sectors to share needs, experiences, knowledge, and expertise, as well as to address a transboundary research agenda. Challenges are discussed from multiple perspectives: data, methodological, governmental and readiness, and potential impact. This analysis is aimed at researchers, policymakers, and practitioners interested in the specific challenges and progress of OGDIs in Latin America, while also contributing to the global conversation on best practices and lessons learned in implementing OGDIs across different contexts. keywords open data, geographical data, OGDI, Latin America, challenges, government, readiness, impact, open geographical data infrastructures. Uncorrected proof accepted for publication in the Journal of Spatial Information Science (JOSIS). Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License CC. 1 Introduction Over the past years, the extensive worldwide development of Geographical data Infrastructures (GDI) has drastically changed the way geographical data is managed and shared, particularly as digital tools and platforms have made data more accessible to a wider array of users [ 17 ] . Volunteered Geographical Information (VGI) and crowdsourcing applications, generally developed over the Web and mobile applications, have played a key role in shaping the emerging concept of Open Geographical Data Infrastructures (OGDIs), defined as infrastructures that facilitate the management and sharing of geographical data in an open manner, encompassing both governmental repositories and more decentralized citizen-driven initiatives. This includes formal GDIs and ad-hoc project-based platforms that allow for the collection and dissemination of geographical data by a wide range of users, including the public [ 20 , 18 ] . The differences between OGDIs and conventional GDIs hinge on their components, access and integration protocols, and the roles of multi-stakeholders involved in the data lifecycle. The concept of OGDI significantly expands the notion of GDI (also known as Spatial Data Infrastructures - SDI). We suggest that the openness of GDIs can be understood as an evolutionary stage succeeding the three well-known stages defined so far [ 36 ] : a producer-based GDI with a focus on data provision; followed by a process-based GDI with a focus on standard web-based services for discovery, access, and visualization of data; and as third stage a user-based GDI with a focus on the users’ needs. Openness, in this context, arises from the open paradigm and principles [ 44 ] and it is not limited to freely accessible data. In fact, it involves a predominant role of multi-stakeholders (i.e citizens, policymakers, and businesses), in addition to the conventional role of government, for re-using data, generating new data, and actively participating in data governance. The main purpose of OGDIs is to enhance open geographical data access to favor its availability without restrictions on use, re-use, or redistribution. A valuable objective of OGDIs is to promote the implementation of best practices and management procedures that involve citizens in decision-making processes. OGDIs clearly foster novel pathways for decision-making processes that are close to the citizens and accountable. While conventional GDIs may emphasize controlled data-sharing with predefined users, OGDIs broaden this perspective by facilitating public access to data, often integrating VGI and citizen science contributions [ 38 , 21 ] . Such infrastructures often involve both persistent governmental data repositories and ephemeral citizen-driven platforms that enable data sharing through open initiatives and project-based collaborations [ 20 , 57 ] . Making geographical data accessible to all users typically involves ensuring the availability, accessibility, and interoperability of geographical data [ 52 , 25 ] . Therefore, it emphasizes the use of common standards and formats to ensure that different data sources and systems can communicate and work together among the general public, researchers, policymakers, and businesses. The diversity of actors and domains of application requires the development of appropriate methodologies and design approaches for a successful implementation that fully involves citizens and produces reliable OGDIs [ 8 ] . However, the transition from conventional GDI to Open GDIs is not without challenges. While a wide range of open, volunteer-based, and collaborative infrastructures are emerging, questions arise regarding the quality, governance, and long-term sustainability of these, particularly when involving citizen science projects or crowd-sourced data. OGDIs emphasize the use of common standards and formats to ensure interoperability, but the diversity of data sources and actors involved in these initiatives also brings forth issues related to data accuracy, updating, and usability across different contexts. Additionally, unequal access to technological resources in certain regions, especially in developing countries, may perpetuate digital divides rather than eliminate them. In Latin America, while recent open government initiatives and agendas have shown an inclination towards transparency, citizen participation, and collaboration [ 13 , 29 , 52 ] , key challenges still remain. These include ensuring data quality, fostering inclusivity, sustaining volunteer engagement, aligning with technical standards, and addressing legal and privacy concerns. Most conventional GDI primarily focus on geographical data visualization. Unfortunately, only a limited number of them allow data downloading for subsequent analysis, and even fewer operate under open licenses. There is also a lack of standard and common practices that hampers cross-fertilization and successful exchanges at the methodological level. Given the region’s cultural, social, and economic disparities, there is a contrasting digital divide [ 9 , 23 ] , which significantly impacts how OGDIs are being developed across the region. There is a need to identify the models and the local policies that will shape the methodological and technological frameworks on which OGDIs should be based. While the underlying technologies may remain consistent with global standards, their application must be tailored to address the unique challenges and requirements of the region. The focus on Latin America offers a unique perspective and opportunity for developing OGDI in this region. Analyzing the development of OGDIs within this context can provide insights into how these challenges can be addressed using a multi user-centric and data-driven approach, although not limited to purely data exchange issues but also the generation of added value and knowledge. Therefore, the objective of this paper is to showcase the Latin American region by analyzing the recent progress in developing OGDIs, technological gaps among countries

Read the complete text