The Strong Cosmic Censorship Conjecture

Maxime Van de Moortel · 2025

Read The Strong Cosmic Censorship Conjecture by Maxime Van de Moortel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13180.txt.

Introduction

Maxime Van de Moortel (2025) reviews the strong cosmic censorship conjecture, an old claim about how gravity must behave. Roger Penrose proposed it in the wake of the relativity breakthroughs of the 1960s. The claim says, roughly, that singularities inside black holes must never leave the future open to arbitrary influence. If it failed, Einstein's theory would lose its power to predict what happens next. The question has driven deep work in mathematics ever since.

The review gathers recent progress made with modern methods for partial differential equations. Those tools let researchers test the conjecture in the setting where it was born: gravitational collapse. Van de Moortel traces how results on black hole interiors have sharpened both the claim and its possible exceptions. The paper is a map of where the conjecture now stands. It shows a physics idea still generating hard, fruitful mathematics sixty years on.

Catalog record

CREATORMaxime Van de Moortel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE123 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13180

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Strong Cosmic Censorship Conjecture Maxime Van de Moortel Abstract In the wake of major breakthroughs in General Relativity during the 1960s, Roger Penrose introduced Strong Cosmic Censorship, a profound conjecture regarding the deterministic nature of the theory. Penrose’s proposal has since opened far-reaching new mathematical avenues, revealing connections to fundamental questions about black holes and the nature of gravitational singularities. We review recent advances arising from modern techniques in the theory of partial differential equations as applied to Strong Cosmic Censorship, maintaining a focus on the context of gravitational collapse that gave birth to the conjecture. 1 Introduction The proving (or disproving) of […] Cosmic Censorship in classical general relativity is perhaps the most important unsolved problem in that theory. Penrose (1982), [ 1 ] 1.1 Cosmic Censorship: from the absence of naked singularities to determinism Penrose held the Cosmic Censorship hypothesis in such high regard because, in his words, “unlike many other problems”, it has “genuine astrophysical significance” [ 1 ] . Cosmic Censorship is indeed inextricably tied to the very question of Laplacian determinism in the general theory of relativity; namely, is “the present state of the universe the effect of its past and the cause of its future” [ 2 ] ? Originally, the idea of Cosmic Censorship broadly asserts that should singularities exist within general relativity, they ought to be confined inside a black hole and, thus, do not affect the observable universe 1 1 1 Before the 1960’s, relativistic singularities were viewed as absurdities that could, however, be ignored providing they were located inside a black hole, which was not then considered as a physically realistic spacetime, see [ 3 ] , Chapter 3.2. . In other words, a cosmic censor conceals any naked (that is to say, visible to infinitely far-away observers) singularity within a black hole [ 4 ] . However, very early on, Penrose motivated cosmic censorship as a way to avoid “the unpredictability entailed by the presence of naked singularities” [ 5 ] . In modern terms, the occurrence of a naked singularity is indeed responsible for the formation of a Cauchy horizon (see [ 6 , 7 ] for a precise definition) emanating from it. Should this Cauchy horizon be a regular hypersurface, the trajectory of observers crossing it is no longer determined by their initial state. In Penrose’s words: “there being no theory governing what happens as the result of the appearance of such a singularity, this particular observer would not be able to account, in scientific terms, for whatever physical behaviour is seen” [ 8 ] . In this situation, the future of spacetime itself beyond the Cauchy horizon cannot, in fact, be predicted from its initial state, in patent violation of the spirit of Laplacian determinism; such considerations will be discussed with greater depth in Section 2 . 1.2 Locally naked singularities and early statements of Strong Cosmic Censorship Penrose realized that a breakdown of Laplacian determinism would also occur if the naked singularity was covered by a black hole, an instance he calls “a locally naked singularity”, namely a singularity that is still visible to observers falling into the black hole [ 5 ] . In his words, “cosmic censorship […] should [..] preclude such locally naked singularities” [ 5 ] , a realization which prompted him to introduce two distinct notions of cosmic censorship [ 9 ] : • the absence of naked singularities in the process of gravitational collapse (the original cosmic censorship [ 4 ] ), dubbed Weak Cosmic Censorship by subsequent authors [ 10 , 11 ] . • the absence of naked or locally naked singularities (possibly inside a black hole) in generic gravitational collapse, called by Penrose “ Strong Cosmic Censorship ” [ 9 , 5 ] . The terminology is fully justified in these original forms because the Strong Cosmic Censorship statement implies that of Weak Cosmic Censorship (see [ 12 ] , section 5 for a historical perspective on this, but already contrast with the modern formulation of Strong Cosmic Censorship in our Section 1.4 below). While originally, Cosmic Censorship concerned the problem of naked singularities globally affecting the universe (especially idealized observers located at infinity), the change of paradigm in Penrose’s work [ 9 , 5 ] refocused Cosmic Censorship on a failure of Laplacian determinism, which can occur locally, with no reference to the observable universe in its globality. 1.3 The interior of the Kerr black hole and the issue of Cauchy horizons The interior of the (sub-extremal) Kerr metric (representing, at the time of Penrose, the most appropriate known model for an astrophysical black hole), which also features a Cauchy horizon, provides a striking case study. Contrary to Cauchy horizons emanating from a naked singularity, the Kerr Cauchy horizon exists 2 2 2 The Kerr Cauchy horizon coincides with its inner horizon, and emanates from timelike infinity. This is another common mechanism for the appearance of Cauchy horizons, see [ 13 , 14 ] . despite the absence of any singularity in its past. In retrospect, this fact demonstrates that the study of determinism (or its breakdown) is not directly tied to naked singularities and falls under more general considerations. That said, the Kerr metric interior (analytically extended to the future of its Cauchy horizon) also features a timelike singularity, which is locally naked from the viewpoint of in-falling observers crossing the Cauchy horizon, see Figure 1 . Penrose found such timelike singularities to be the most physically problematic issue with the Kerr metric (see [ 12 ] , section 6). In [ 15 , 16 ] , he discovered that the Kerr Cauchy horizon suffers from a blue-shift instability (we will return to this in Section 4 ). This instability mechanism gave credence to his original formulation of Strong Cosmic Censorship, which precisely aimed at avoiding locally naked singularities. It is also important to note that the very existence of the Kerr metric already demonstrates that Cauchy horizons (and the breakdown of determinism they cause) cannot be completely ruled out from General Relativity, which mandates a genericity condition in the statement of Strong Cosmic Censorship (see Section 3 ), excluding the Kerr metric (see the related discussion on blue-shift instability in Section 4 ). Figure 1: Future analytic extension of the Kerr metric. \mathcal{CH}^{+} is a (smoothly extendible) Cauchy horizon emanating from timelike infinity i^{+} , and \mathcal{T} a timelike ring singularity. 1.4 The modern statement of Strong Cosmic Censorship via global hyperbolicity Fifty years after its inception by Penrose, the statement of Strong Cosmic Censorship remains true to its original spirit, while benefiting from the modern developments in the theory of the initial value problem for the Einstein equations. In 1974, Penrose already proposed a connection between Strong Cosmic Censorship and “Leray’s condition of global hyperbolicity” [ 9 ] . This insight later allowed for a clear formulation of Strong Cosmic Censorship in terms of the maximal globally hyperbolic development (MGHD), a concept introduced in the work of Choquet-Bruhat and Geroch [ 17 ] . Given a suitable 3 3 3 By suitable initial hypersurface, it is meant a triplet (M,g_{0},K_{0}) , where (M,g_{0}) a complete three-dimensional Riemannian manifold, and K_{0} a

Read the complete text