Bailout Embedding and Stability Analysis of a Dynamical Mean-Field Ising Model of Opinion Dynamics

Senbagaraman Sudarsanam · 2025

Read Bailout Embedding and Stability Analysis of a Dynamical Mean-Field Ising Model of Opinion Dynamics by Senbagaraman Sudarsanam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13078.txt.

Introduction

Senbagaraman Sudarsanam studies a math model of how views spread in markets. His 2025 paper uses an Ising model, a grid of agents that flip between two stances under peer pull and noise. Such models can mimic real market swings, where calm spells bunch with wild ones.

The author lifts the model into a larger system with a trick called bailout embedding. That move splits off the bubbling behavior that sparks bursts of wild swings. A single dial in the trick can push the model through set grades of stability. Under the right settings, the model shows bursts that look like real price swings. He reads the dial as a gauge of how slow traders are to change course.

Catalog record

CREATORSenbagaraman Sudarsanam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13078

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bailout Embedding and Stability Analysis of a Dynamical Mean-Field Ising Model of Opinion Dynamics Senbagaraman Sudarsanam Abstract We study the stability of a discrete-time dynamical mean-field Ising model to perturbations. This model belongs to a broader class of models often used in the study of opinion dynamics in financial markets. In the presence of noise, these iterated maps are known to exhibit dynamics which resemble empirically observed behavior of financial markets, such as volatility clustering. Research in the recent past has identified attractor bubbling as one of the underlying mechanisms that lead to clustering of high volatility events in models of opinion dynamics. In this work, we employ the method of bailout embedding to create an extended, higher-dimensional system of iterated maps where the bubbling dynamics is isolated from dynamics in the original lower-dimensional space. The bailout embedding technique also introduces a bailout parameter and an associated bailout function which allows us to systematically induce several regimes of stability in the opinion dynamics and thus enables us to better understand the onset of attractor bubbling in this system. We demonstrate the occurrence of intermittency in opinion dynamics under appropriate conditions, with the discrete opinion dynamics sharing characteristics of empirically observed financial time series with volatility clustering. Inspired by the original context under which bailout embeddings were introduced, we propose an interpretation of the bailout function as a measure of investor inertia in the markets. This work hopes to demonstrate the usefulness of bailout embeddings as a tool to study mathematical models of financial market dynamics. There is mounting evidence suggesting that one of the mechanisms that lead to volatility clustering and power law distribution of returns in financial markets resembles attractor bubbling and on-off intermittency in dynamical systems. A physical system that is known to exhibit attractor bubbling and on-off intermittency is the dynamics of finite sized particles in fluid flows which is modeled using the Maxey-Riley equation. Bailout embedding is an analytical embedding technique inspired by the dynamics of finite sized particles and is useful for separating out bubbling dynamics from the underlying dynamics on invariant manifolds with locally unstable subsets. We use this framework to probe a discrete-time mean-field model of interacting agents in financial markets and find that the bailout function can be varied to induce various levels of stability in the underlying dynamics. We also demonstrate that the model of opinion dynamics chosen for this study exhibits intermittency and power law behavior upon perturbation under appropriate conditions, similar to empirically observed financial time series data. We hope to demonstrate the utility of bailout embeddings as an effective tool for the study of volatility clustering and other extreme events in models of financial markets. I Introduction The Ising model is a well-known mathematical model that is most often used in statistical physics but has also found extensive application in models of social interactions [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . The collective evolution of opinions among market participants, who each hold individual positions that evolve through interactions with their environment and external ordering forces such as news, is crucial to the understanding of financial market dynamics [ 6 ] . An empirically observed market phenomenon that has received a lot of attention is the clustering of large volatility events in financial time series data [ 7 , 8 ] . Ising like models of opinion dynamics are often used to model returns time series and are known to be able to reproduce intermittent dynamics and volatility clustering observed in returns data [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . In this work, we are particularly interested in a mean-field version of the Ising model which provides a concise, discrete-time model of opinion dynamics in financial markets. One of the mechanisms underlying volatility clustering in opinion dynamics has been demonstrated to be similar to attractor bubbling in dynamical systems theory [ 12 ] . Attractor bubbling is known to occur in dynamical systems possessing a lower dimensional invariant manifold with subsets that are unstable [ 13 , 14 ] . When trajectories of such systems pass through a region of instability, any perturbation away from the invariant manifold grows and causes the trajectory to deviate from its original path on the invariant manifold [ 15 , 16 ] . Depending on the extent of such unstable sets, a system may exhibit highly intermittent behavior which resembles volatility clustering commonly seen in financial time series data. To investigate the phenomenon of volatility clustering in mean-field Ising models of opinion dynamics, we use a bailout embedding [ 16 ] . The bailout embedding is an analytical technique inspired by the dynamics of finite sized particles in fluids [ 17 , 18 ] and was developed to enable the study of dynamical systems with an underlying structure that gives rise to behaviors such as attractor bubbling and intermittency [ 16 , 19 ] . Using a bailout embedded version of the discrete-time map under study, we are able to classify subsets of phase space as either stable or unstable to perturbations for a given range of parameters. This allows us to understand the role played by these phase space regions in determining the overall dynamics of the system. At this point it is important to emphasize that the connection between attractor bubbling and volatility clustering has been known for over two decades [ 12 ] and this work investigates this connection further for a particular model of interest within the framework of a bailout embedding. Doing this exercise offers us novel insights into the relationship between an inertia like parameter and the onset of volatility clustering in collective dynamics. In addition, some observations are made about the nature of forcing required to induce intermittent dynamics. The paper is organized as follows. Section II presents the discrete-time mean-field Ising model chosen for study in this paper. This section also introduces the idea of a bailout embedding, followed by its application to the discrete time map under consideration. Section III demonstrates the application of transversal Lypaunov exponents to classify the underlying phase space into stable and unstable sets. The influence of the stable and unstable sets on the dynamics of individual trajectories is presented for the case of an isolated perturbation ( subsection (A) ) as well as the case of sustained perturbation ( subsection (B) ) . We also demonstrate the role of the bailout function in the onset of volatility clustering. In Section IV , we draw parallels between the dynamics of the bailout embedded Ising model and the dynamics of inertial particles in fluids. This leads us to an interpretation of the bailout function as a parameter that quantifies investor inertia. Finally, in Section V we offer some concluding thoughts while the Appendix shows details of bailout embedding of the system in ( 1 ). II Description and bailout embedding of a 2D map We begin with the description of a 2D map that was originally presented in [ 20 ] . The map is given by, \displaystyle s(n+1)=\tanh\big(a\cdot s(n)+b\cdot H(n)\big) (1) \displaystyle H(n+1)=\theta\cdot H(n)+(1-\theta)s(n) where s(n) is the state variable reflecting the prevailing opinion at iteration n , of a representative agent in the

Read the complete text