Systematic comparison of gender inequality in scientific rankings across disciplines

Ana Maria Jaramillo, Mariana Macedo, Marcos Oliveira, Fariba Karimi, Ronaldo Menezes · 2025

Read Systematic comparison of gender inequality in scientific rankings across disciplines by Ana Maria Jaramillo, Mariana Macedo, Marcos Oliveira, Fariba Karimi, Ronaldo Menezes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-13061.txt.

Introduction

Ana Maria Jaramillo and co-authors compare gender gaps at the top of science across eighteen fields in a 2025 paper. Women's share of academia has grown for decades, but whether that reaches the highest ranks of productivity and citations was unclear. The team mined nearly sixty-eight million papers from 1975 to 2020, inferring author gender from names.

Women stayed underrepresented in top-ranked spots in every field, even where their overall share was high. Rankings themselves grew more rigid over time, with less churn at the top. Highly productive men drew more citations than comparable women, though matching on career stage, output, venue, and authorship position shrank the gap and sometimes reversed it. The authors conclude raw output differences do not fully explain citation gaps among top researchers.

Catalog record

CREATORAna Maria Jaramillo, Mariana Macedo, Marcos Oliveira, Fariba Karimi, Ronaldo Menezes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-13061

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Systematic comparison of gender inequality in scientific rankings across disciplines Ana Maria Jaramillo, Mariana Macedo, Marcos Oliveira, Fariba Karimi, Ronaldo Menezes Abstract The participation of women in academia has increased in the last few decades across many fields (e.g., Computer Science, History, Medicine). However, this increase in the participation of women has not been the same at all career stages. Here, we study how gender participation within different fields is related to gender representation in top-ranking positions in productivity (number of papers), research impact (number of citations), and co-authorship networks (degree of connectivity). We analyzed over 80 million papers published from 1975 to 2020 in 19 academic fields. Our findings reveal that women remain a minority in all 19 fields, with physics, geology, and mathematics having the lowest percentage of papers authored by women at 14% and psychology having the largest percentage at 39%. Women are significantly underrepresented in top-ranking positions (top 10% or higher) across all fields and metrics (productivity, citations, and degree), indicating that it remains challenging for early researchers (especially women) to reach top-ranking positions, as our results reveal the rankings to be rigid over time. Finally, we show that in most fields, women and men with comparable productivity levels and career age tend to attain different levels of citations, where women tend to benefit more from co-authorships, while men tend to benefit more from productivity, especially in pSTEMs. Our findings highlight that while women’s participation has risen in some fields, they remain under-represented in top-ranking positions. Greater gender participation at entry levels often helps representation, but stronger interventions are still needed to achieve long-lasting careers for women and their participation in top-ranking positions. keywords Science of Science, Gender Inequality, Network Science, Complex Systems Introduction Recently, academia has witnessed a notable surge in women’s participation [ 1 ] . There has been an increase in research directions aligned with issues concerning women, such as the exploration of women’s health within the domain of medicine [ 2 ] , leveraging women’s experiences to create interventions and shape public policies addressing social inequalities [ 3 ] and peace agreements with feminist perspectives [ 4 ] . However, the rise in women’s participation in academia varies across fields [ 5 , 6 ] , with extensive evidence highlighting persistent disparities between men and women regarding academic productivity, career length [ 7 , 6 , 8 , 9 ] , cumulative advantages [ 10 ] , and research agendas [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Notably, existing literature has failed to adequately investigate (i) the relationship between increased participation and the top-ranking representation of women in the research landscape [ 6 ] and (ii) the broad spectrum of fields beyond specific areas (e.g., Computer Science) [ 8 , 14 ] . Participation refers to the proportion of a group within a field (i.e., 40% of a field comprises women), while representation concerns visibility in top-ranking positions [ 8 ] . A large proportion of women in a field does not necessarily equate to their advancement to senior or top-ranking positions in terms of productivity, visibility, and recognition. Also, as datasets and methodologies differ across studies, there is a lack of comprehensive analyses comparing fields from the Humanities & Social Sciences to the Physical Sciences. This paper addresses all these gaps by investigating the gender differences in the interrelations between participation/representation and visibility/performance in academia across various fields, years, and career stages. Based on public and privately owned databases, previous studies have consistently found that the gender gap in scientific productivity is due to women having shorter careers than men [ 6 , 8 , 14 ] . Recent research, particularly in Physics and Computer Science, has also demonstrated that women tend to have smaller and less diverse co-authorship networks than their male counterparts [ 8 , 14 ] . These disparities are believed to arise from barriers related to integration, social acceptance, and peer recognition, all exacerbated in fields with high underrepresentation of women [ 15 ] . Despite efforts to improve gender diversity in specific disciplines, there remains a need for systematic investigations into how this increased participation correlates with women’s underrepresentation in top positions and their shorter career durations across various fields. To succeed in academia and attain the status of a senior, top-ranked scientist, it is crucial to maintain high levels of publications, citations, funding, and established collaborations [ 6 ] . These achievements result from a combination of individual and collective efforts. However, these efforts do not appear to lead to the same benefits for all researchers, with historically underrepresented groups (i.e., women [ 16 ] , non-white [ 17 ] or non-western countries [ 18 ] –with even less representation for intersectional groups) experiencing thicker glass ceilings because they have to make significantly more effort than others to achieve similar levels of success in academia, measured by citations or reaching higher career stages. Here, by analyzing datasets from 19 different academic fields and over 80 million papers, we find that despite the increasing trend in women’s participation up to 2020, senior women researchers only reached up to 25% representation in top-ranked positions in any discipline. We also find that all fields exhibit rigid ranking structures, where the top 1,000 researchers remain relatively stable over time, suggesting that achieving a top-ranked position is increasingly difficult, as shown in ranking in other contexts [ 19 ] . Finally, we demonstrate that women have a higher impact from their co-authorships than men in gaining citations, while men in pSTEMS have a higher impact from their productivity. To date, our study encompasses the largest dataset of scientific publications (80,032,675, representing 40% of the total number of publications in Semantic Scholar) with gender-identified authors, including more than 4 million women and 9 million men. Results Growth of women’s participation Our dataset shows that women remain a minority in academia with respect to publications and authorship across all fields from 1975 to 2020, with different values per field (Figure 1 ). Specifically, to compare the participation of women across fields, we ordered the fields by the percentage of papers with at least one woman author. This approach ranks papers authored by women from highest to lowest, including those with women as first or last authors, or papers authored exclusively by women. In our dataset, Physics, Geology, and Mathematics have the lowest participation of productivity (14%), while Psychology has the highest (39%) (Figure 1 A ). This ordering grouped fields with similar gender representation; for instance, pSTEM fields (e.g., Physics, Geology, Mathematics, Engineering, Materials Science, and Computer Science) displayed the lowest participation of women. In contrast, the Social Sciences (e.g., Political Science, Sociology, and Psychology) had the largest one. When reordering the fields by the percentage of women authors (considering any position in the authorship list), the order of the fields changes (Figure 1 B -left). Medicine, the field with the largest number of researchers and publications, exhibits the most significant shift: it ranks seventh in the percentage of papers with at least one woman author but third in the percentage of women authors. This example suggests that the representation of women as authors is not always proportional to the number

Read the complete text