Does multi-block MEV exist? Analysis of 2 years of MEV Data

Pascal Stichler · 2025

Read Does multi-block MEV exist? Analysis of 2 years of MEV Data by Pascal Stichler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12827.txt.

Introduction

Pascal Stichler asks whether anyone extracts value from Ethereum across several blocks in a row, a pattern called multi-block MEV. After Ethereum's merge in September 2022, block builders compete to order transactions, and holding a streak of blocks could in theory raise profits. Stichler studied two years of proposer-builder and payment data to look for such streaks.

He found fewer builder streaks than a random simulation predicted, with the longest run spanning 25 slots. Average payments did grow with streak length, from about 0.05 ether for a single slot to 0.08 ether for nine in a row. Payments within long streaks also crept up slightly by slot. A weak link between one payment and the next argues against alternating calm and busy periods. Builders showed no real split by how wildly the base fee moved. The study gives a measured answer to a debated question in blockchain market design.

Catalog record

CREATORPascal Stichler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12827

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Does multi-block MEV exist? Analysis of 2 years of MEV Data Pascal Stichler Abstract This study analyzes proposer-builder data and MEV-Boost payment data following the Ethereum merge in September 2022 to identify patterns of multi-block MEV. Our findings reveal fewer multi-slot sequences of builders than predicted by a random Monte Carlo simulation, with the longest observed sequence spanning 25 slots. Additionally, we observe that average MEV-Boost payments increase with the length of consecutive sequences from approximately 0.05 ETH for single slots to 0.08 ETH for nine consecutive slots. Within longer sequences, payments per slot show a slight increase, suggesting that builders bid higher for longer sequences or the first slot after a longer sequence. A weak positive autocorrelation is found between subsequent MEV-Boost payments, challenging the hypothesis of alternating periods of low and high MEV. Finally, our comparison of builders during periods of low and high base fee volatility reveals minimal correlation, indicating the absence of builder specialization based on base fee volatility. The detailed results can be found in the Jupyter notebook on Github or Google Colab . 1 Background Multi-block Maximal Extractable Value (MMEV) occurs when one party controls more than one consecutive block. It was first introduced in 2021 by [ 1 ] as k-MEV and further elaborated by [ 2 ] . It is commonly assumed that controlling multiple slots in a sequence allows to capture significantly more MEV than controlling them individually. This derives from MEV accruing superlinearly over time. The most discussed multi-block MEV strategies include TWAP oracle manipulation attacks on DEXes and producing forced liquidations by price manipulation. After the merge, [ 3 ] have looked into the first four months of data on multi-block MEV and summarized it as “ preliminary and non-conclusive results, indicating [that] builders employ super-linear bidding strategies to secure consecutive block space ". With the recent Attester-Proposer-Separation (APS) and pre-confirmation discussions, multi-block MEV has become more of a pressing issue again as it might be prohibitive for some of the proposed designs (For a more in-depth overview, we’ve created a diagram of recently proposed mechanism designs and also Mike Neuder lately gave a comprehensive overview ). 2 Methodology In order to get a better understanding of the historical prevalence of multi-block MEV, we decided to look at all slots from the Merge in September ‘22 until May ‘24 (totalling roughly 4.3 million slots) and analyze the corresponding data on validators and builders and on MEV-boost payments (if applicable). The scope was to identify patterns of unusual consecutive slot sequences and accompanying MEV values. The data has been kindly provided by Toni Wahrstätter and contains information per slot on relay, builder pubkey, proposer pubkey and MEV-Boost value as well as a builder pubkey and validator pubkey mapping. In the labeling of validators for our purposes staking pool providers such as Lido or Rocket Pool are treated as one entity. MEV-Boost payments are used as a proxy for the MEV per block. We acknowledge that this is only a non-perfect approximation. The ascending MEV-Boost first-price auction by its nature of being public essentially functions like a second price +1 wei auction. Hence, we strictly speaking only get an estimate of the intrinsic value of the second highest bidder. However, as [ 4 ] have observed more than 88% of MEV-Boost auctions were competitive and [ 5 ] concluded that the average profit margin per top three builder is between 1% and 5.4%, further indicating a competitive market between the top builders. Based on this, despite the limitations we deem it feasible to use the MEV-Boost payments as an approximation for the generated MEV per block. To establish a baseline of expected multi-slot sequences, a Monte Carlo simulation was conducted. In this simulation, builders were randomly assigned to each slot within the specified time period, based on their observed daily market share during that period. The frequency of consecutive slots, ranging in length from 1 to 25 (the longest observed sequence in the empirical data), was recorded. This procedure was repeated 100 times, and the average was taken. We decided to use daily market shares for the main analysis as in the investigated time period market shares have strongly shifted [ 4 ] . For comparison we also ran the analysis on monthly and overall market shares. Further, base fee volatility data has been included to cross-check effects of low and high-volatility periods. Previous research (e.g. [ 6 ] & [ 7 ] ) has focused on token price volatility effects based on CEX-prices. As we are interested in low- and high-MEV environments, we deem base fee volatility for our use case more fitting, as it is driven by empty or full blocks which are at least partially a result of the prevalence of MEV opportunities. 3 Empirical Findings Finding 1: Fewer multi-slot sequences exist than assumed by random distribution Figure 1: Comparison of statistically expected vs. observed multi-slot sequences (note that slots > 25 have been summarized in slot 25 for brevity) Firstly, the prevalence of multi-slot sequences with the same builder proposing the block was investigated to determine if they are more common than would be expected by chance. Comparing the results of the Monte Carlo simulation as a baseline in expected distribution (blue) with the observed distribution (orange), it can be seen that significantly fewer multi-slot sequences occur than expected ( Figure 1 ). The longest observed sequence was 25 slots and the longest sequence with the same validator (Lido) and builder (BeaverBuild) was 11 consecutive slots on March 4th, 2024 (more details with descriptive statistics in the notebook ). Running the same simulation on monthly or total market shares in the time period, the observation shifts to having more longer sequences than expected, however we attribute this to the statistical effect of changing market shares. A detailed analysis can be run in the notebook or be provided upon request. In the next step, to understand this in a more-fine-grained manner, the values are compared for each of the top 10 builders based on market shares. Therefore, for each builder, the difference between expected and observed occurrences of multi-slot sequences are plotted with the size of the bubble indicating the delta in Figure 2 . The expected occurrences are based on the results of the Monte Carlo simulation. Red bubbles indicate a positive deviation (more observed slots than expected), while blue indicates a negative deviation. Green dots indicate values in line with the expectation. In Figure 2 it is shown in absolute numbers, in the notebook it can also be seen on a relative scale. Figure 2: Deviations between expected (Monte Carlo simulation) and observed multi-slot frequencies per builder It can be observed in the relative as well as in the absolute deviation that for the top builders there are more single slot sequences than expected with the exception of ETH-Builder, f1b and Blocknative. For multi-slot sequences with two or more slots, almost all top 10 builders have less than expected. This shows that the trend is not limited to singular entities but derives more from the general market structure. Finding 2: Payments for multi-slot sequences are higher on average than for single slots To understand if multi-slot

Read the complete text