The Impact of Bar-induced Non-Circular Motions on the Measurement of Galactic Rotation Curves
Jie Liu, Zhi Li, Juntai Shen · 2025
Read The Impact of Bar-induced Non-Circular Motions on the Measurement of Galactic Rotation Curves by Jie Liu, Zhi Li, Juntai Shen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12760.txt.
Introduction
Jie Liu, Zhi Li, and Juntai Shen show, in a 2025 astronomy paper, how a galaxy's central bar can quietly corrupt the standard measure of its spin. Rotation curves chart how fast gas orbits at each radius, and the common tilted-ring method assumes gas moves in circles.
A bar stirs gas into non-circular flows, and the bias depends on the angle between bar and disk. At small angles the derived curve grows a dip: too fast near the center ring, too slow along the bar. The team found such dips are common in a major survey of barred galaxies, and simulations plus a simple model explain the pattern.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jie Liu, Zhi Li, Juntai Shen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12760
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Impact of Bar-induced Non-Circular Motions on the Measurement of Galactic Rotation Curves Jie Liu, Zhi Li, Juntai Shen Abstract We study the impact of bar-induced non-circular motions on the derivation of galactic rotation curves (RCs) using hydrodynamic simulations and observational data from the PHANGS-ALMA survey. We confirm that non-circular motions induced by a bar can significantly bias RCs derived from the conventional tilted-ring method, consistent with previous findings. The shape of the derived RC depends on the position angle difference ( Δ ϕ \Delta\phi ) between the major axes of the bar and the disk in the face-on plane. For | Δ ϕ | ≲ 40 ∘ \left|\Delta\phi\right|\lesssim 40^{\circ} , non-circular motions produce a bar-induced “dip” feature (rise-drop-rise pattern) in the derived RC, which shows higher velocities near the nuclear ring and lower velocities in the bar region compared to the true RC ( RC true \mathrm{RC_{true}} ). We demonstrate convincingly that such dip features are very common in the PHANGS-ALMA barred galaxies sample. Hydrodynamical simulations reveal that the “dip” feature is caused by the perpendicular orientation of the gas flows in the nuclear ring and the bar; at low | Δ ϕ | \left|\Delta\phi\right| streamlines in the nuclear ring tend to enhance V los V_{\mathrm{los}} , while those in the bar tend to suppress V los V_{\mathrm{los}} . We use a simple “misaligned ellipses” model to qualitatively explain the general trend of RCs from the tilted-ring method ( RC tilted \mathrm{RC_{tilted}} ) and the discrepancy between RC tilted \mathrm{RC_{tilted}} and RC true \mathrm{RC_{true}} . Furthermore, we propose a straightforward method to implement a first-order correction to the RC derived from the tilted-ring method. Our study is the first to systematically discuss the bar-induced “dip” feature in the RCs of barred galaxies combining both simulations and observations. Athena++ [ 40 ] , Scipy [ 46 ] , Numpy [ 10 ] , Jupyter notebook [ 14 ] , IRAF [ 43 , 44 ] I Introduction Galactic circular rotation curves (RCs) are crucial for understanding galactic properties. They provide the first clear direct evidence for the existence of dark matter by suggesting that galaxies contain more mass than visible matter alone ( Bosma 4 ). Various methods have been developed to derive accurate RCs from galactic kinematics, such as the centroid-velocity method ( Rubin et al. 30 ), the peak-intensity-velocity method ( Merrifield 20 ), the terminal-velocity and envelope-tracing method ( Sofue 37 ), the iteration method ( Takamiya & Sofue 42 ), and the tilted-ring method ( Rogstad et al. 29 , van der Hulst et al. 45 ). These methods are commonly applied to derive RCs from the kinematics of gas disks, which are assumed to have lower velocity dispersion and more circular orbits than the stellar component. However, when a galaxy has a rotating stellar bar, non-circular motions become significant around the bar region. This is commonly seen in both hydrodynamic simulations ( Sanders & Tubbs 32 , Athanassoula 1 , Schoenmakers et al. 33 , Maciejewski 18 , Maciejewski 19 , Kim et al. 12 , Kim et al. 13 , Li et al. 17 ) and observations (e.g., H I in Walter et al. 47 , and CO in Leroy et al. 16 ). In this case, the circular rotation curve is hard to define and may not exactly reflect the real mass distribution as the potential is non-axisymmetric. In addition, large non-circular motions in the gas disk may violate the underlying assumption of the aforementioned methods, leaving uncertainties in the derived RC. It is important to note that the galactic properties directly inferred from RCs may be subject to these uncertainties; for example, the orbital time, t_{orb} , in the Molecular Elmegreen–Silk Relation [ 7 , 36 , 41 ] , and the dark matter core size in dwarf galaxies [ 22 ] . Properly addressing these deviations is crucial to obtaining a more accurate rotation curve as well as other galactic parameters. On the other hand, studies aimed at quantitatively correcting the effects of non-circular motions on RCs are incomplete. Rhee et al. [28] conducted N -body simulations for barred galaxies and derived RCs using the tilted-ring method. They found that the method could cause an \sim 20\% underestimation of the rotation curve in the central region. Chemin et al. [5] studied the RC of the Milky Way and found that the deviation of the RC is related to the “viewing angle” of the bar, aligning with the previous results by Binney et al. [3] and Schoenmakers et al. [33] . They proposed a straightforward method to correct the RC with a radially dependent factor \left(\frac{v(R)}{v_{\mathrm{true}}}\right)_{\mathrm{sim}} derived from simulations. Sellwood & Spekkens [34] developed DiskFit to extract non-circular motions with an m=2 (i.e., bisymmetric) component. Randriamampandry et al. [26] , Randriamampandry et al. [27] tested this tool with simulations and concluded that DiskFit could roughly recover the true RC when the bar is not aligned or perpendicular to the disk major axis, although their simulation cannot fully resolve the gas substructures generated by the bar 1 1 1 We conducted tests using DiskFit and further discuss the limitations of Randriamampandry et al. [26] , Randriamampandry et al. [27] in Appendix E . . Nevertheless, a more comprehensive study of the RCs in barred galaxies, along with the necessary corrections, is still needed. This paper aims to deepen the understanding of the systematic deviation of derived RCs of barred galaxies based on both hydrodynamical simulations and observations. We define the RC of a barred galaxy as the circular velocity in centrifugal balance with the azimuthally averaged gravitational potential [ 39 , see the discussions in] . We further propose a straightforward correction method for RCs derived from the tilted-ring method in barred galaxies. The paper is organized as follows: § II presents an analysis of the non-circular motion effects based on simulations. § III demonstrates the bar-induced “dip” features in the observed RCs of real galaxies. § IV introduces two simple models to illustrate the physical origin of the RC features and proposes a straightforward correction method. The summary is in § V . II The effect of Non-circular motions in Simulations Figure 1: Clockwise-rotating quadrupole models. Columns 1 and 4 display the projected surface density, with bar directions indicated by red dashed lines. \Delta\phi from 0^{\circ} to \pm\;90^{\circ} is indicated in the top corner of each plot. Columns 2 and 5 display the constructed V_{\mathrm{los}} map generated directly from the components V_{x} and V_{y} with an inclination ( i ) of 45^{\circ} . The zero-velocity lines are represented by black dashed lines. Columns 3 and 6 present a comparison between \mathrm{RC_{true}} and \mathrm{RC_{tilted}} (derived from V_{\mathrm{los}} using the tilted-ring method). \mathrm{RC_{tilted}} derived from simulation is represented by the blue solid line, while the other version (the green dashed line) is derived from the “misaligned ellipses” model (see § IV.2 ). The inner and outer vertical black dashed lines denote the nuclear ring size and the bar length, respectively. We first illustrate the effects of bar-induced non-circular motions on rotation curves using simple hydrodynamical simulations. We test two classical barred galactic potentials: the quadrupole model and the Ferrers model. The