Large discrepancies in error estimates for reverberation times derived from light curves of active galactic nuclei
C. Martin Gaskell · 2025
Read Large discrepancies in error estimates for reverberation times derived from light curves of active galactic nuclei by C. Martin Gaskell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12757.txt.
Introduction
C Martin Gaskell warns that the error bars on timing measurements of active galactic nuclei are often badly wrong, in a 2025 paper. Astronomers time how long light takes to cross the region around a feeding black hole by watching its flicker echo between bands. Those light curves are sampled unevenly, which makes honest error estimates hard.
Gaskell shows that a widely used resampling method greatly overstates errors for the classic correlation method, above all for sparse data. He also argues that a rival method's claims of much sharper timing are spurious; its accuracy is no better than the classic one. A slightly updated formula from early work gives easy, sound errors for good data. He further shows how the flicker's width scales with brightness, which helps plan observing runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. Martin Gaskell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Large discrepancies in error estimates for reverberation times derived from light curves of active galactic nuclei Thanks: Paper dedicated to the memory of Nikolai Gennadievich Bochkarev (19 May 1947 – 24 December 2022) in appreciation of his encouragement and support of reverberation mapping and his tireless work in the promotion of international collaboration in astronomy. Nikolai Gennadievich was among the first to recognize the signicance of reverberation mapping and his papers on the topic cover four and a half decades. C. Martin Gaskell Abstract Light-travel-time delays provide one of the most powerful ways of learning about the structure and kinematics of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Estimating delays from observations of AGN variability presents statistical challenges because the time series are almost invariably irregularly sampled. Correct assessment of errors in lag estimates is important for evaluating results. The most widely used method of determining phase lags has been the interpolated cross-correlation function method introduced by Gaskell and Sparke (1986). It is shown here that the widely used modified smooth bootstrap method of Peterson et al. (1998) significantly overestimates the error in lags derived using the Gaskell & Sparke (GS) method, especially for poorly sampled light curves. The remarkably high accuracy claimed for lags obtained by the JAVELIN method of Zu et al. (2011) (more than an order of magnitude improvement for 25% of cases) is spurious and the accuracy no better than the GS method. A related method proposed by Li et al. (2013) suffers from similar but less serious problems. A slightly modified version of the analytic formula of Gaskell and Peterson (1987) gives an easy and accurate way of estimating lag errors for well-sampled, high-quality data. The width of the continuum autocorrelation function is shown to be proportional to the square root of the luminosity. This is useful in planning observing campaigns. The discrete correlation function method is less powerful than the GS method and for many typical situations gives errors in the lag twice as large as those of the GS method. Key words : galaxies: active – quasars: emission lines – galaxies: Seyfert – quasars: general – methods: statistical – accretion, accretion discs. Received 8 November, 2023 November 8 ; accepted accepted 22 April, 2024 1 Introduction The discovery of variability of the broad-line emission in an active galactic nucleus (AGN) by Dibai & Esipov 1965 and Burbidge & Burbidge 1966 (see also Wampler 1967 ), prompted Shklovskii 1966 to recommend the undertaking of prolonged, systematic observations of broad-line variability as a means of learning about AGNs. Following this suggestion, Lyutyi & Cherepashchuk 1972 and Cherepashchuk & Lyutyi 1973 showed that the size of broad-line regions (BLRs) in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) could be estimated from the phase lag between continuum variability and line variability because the emission of reprocessed radiation is delayed by the extra time it takes the direct, unreprocessed, driving radiation to reach the reprocessing regions. The first study of the energetics of the broad-line variability was by Bochkarev & Pudenko 1975 who showed that the necessary extreme ultraviolet (EUV) to soft X-ray energies needed for photoionizing and heating the gas were consistent with observations of the high-energy spectrum. In an idealised case, the light curve of the reprocessed radiation is the light curve of the driving radiation convolved with an impulse response function, \Psi(\tau) , where \tau is the time delay (see Blandford & McKee 1982 for details). The impulse response function (IRF) is the response of a system to a \delta -function 1 1 1 Following Blandford & McKee 1982 , \Psi(\tau) has been commonly called the “transfer function” in AGN literature, but, as Uttley et al. 2014 point out (see their footnote 1), in signal processing the term ”transfer function” is used for the Fourier transform of the IRF. . Gaining information about AGNs from analysis of the lags in light curves is now referred to as “reverberation mapping”. The easiest quantity to estimate, and one of the most important, is the phase lag, the first moment of \Psi(\tau) . Even determining this is not straight forward, however, since AGNs time series are rarely uniformly sampled. The most widely used method of estimating the lag from AGN light curves has been the partial-interpolation cross-correlation function technique introduced by Gaskell & Sparke 1986 . This method deals with the problem of irregular sampling by cross correlating the observed points in one time series with observed or linearly interpolated points in the other time series (see Fig. 1 of Gaskell & Peterson 1987 ). The lag is taken to be either the peak of the cross-correlation function (CCF) or the centroid of the peak above some threshold (usually taken to be 80% of the peak of the CCF). Gaskell & Sparke (GS) showed that by using this technique BLR sizes could be obtained in a single observing season for a typical Seyfert galaxy. The GS method has therefore been used extensively for measuring the sizes of BLRs. The method has also been used to show that the BLR is gravitationally bound. Bochkarev & Antokhin 1982 and Antokhin & Bochkarev 1983 pointed out that broad-line profile changes on a timescale of days should be observable and observations of them would distinguish between different kinematic models for the BLR. In 1983 Bochkarev initiated what was to become a very successful long-term AGN monitoring campaign with the 6-m telescope of the Special Astrophysical Observatory to study broad-line profile changes. This has has produced over 40 journal papers published to date. The monitoring quickly showed that there were indeed rapid changes in broad-line profiles Bochkarev 1984 . Gaskell 1988 introduced velocity-resolved reverberation mapping to determine the direction of gas motion by comparing the variability of red and blue wings of lines (see also Koratkar & Gaskell 1989 ; Koratkar & Gaskell 1991 ). This gave the important result that the BLR gas is virialized and thus opened up the estimation of black hole masses from reverberation mapping (see Marziani & Sulentic 2012 for a review of mass estimation from the BLR and Kormendy & Ho 2013 for a general review of supermassive black hole masses). There have been many other applications of the GS technique. It is used to measure the radius of the hot inner edge of the dusty torus ( Clavel et al. 1989 ) and of a scattering region producing polarized flux ( Gaskell et al. 2012 ) . Lags have also been determined for the extreme UV and X-ray regions (e.g., Chiang et al. 2000 ; Zoghbi et al. 2011 ; Zoghbi et al. 2012 ). Much of our knowledge of AGNs and the masses of supermassive black holes thus rests on the results of reverberation mapping. Furthermore, Oknyanskij 2002 has suggested that the reverberation mapping could be used to estimate cosmological parameters by giving the distances to AGNs. A result of Gaskell & Sparke 1986 that was surprising at the time was to confirm that the BLR was smaller than had been expected from pre-1986 photoionization models. This naturally led to questions being asked about the errors in the determination of the lags. In particular Edelson & Krolik 1988 argued that the approach of Gaskell & Sparke 1986 did not give a