Encapsulation-Induced Alignment in Endofullerenes
Jonathan Smucker, Jesus Pérez-Ríos · 2025
Read Encapsulation-Induced Alignment in Endofullerenes by Jonathan Smucker, Jesus Pérez-Ríos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12534.txt.
Introduction
Jonathan Smucker and Jesus Perez-Rios study molecules trapped inside carbon cage balls in a 2025 paper. Each cage, called a fullerene, holds one small molecule in a smooth trap. The trap leaves most traits of the guest much as they were in free space. It does give the guest a favoured axis, though, so the guest tends to line up with the cage in a set way.
The team worked out how two guests, aluminium fluoride and nitrogen gas, sit inside the most common cage. Both guests lined up strongly with the cage axis in their math. Yet the tone marks that labs use to read these guests barely moved from free-space values. That split is good news: alignment can be strong while spectra stay clean for study. New cage types now in labs widen the test bed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonathan Smucker, Jesus Pérez-Ríos |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12534
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Encapsulation-Induced Alignment in Endofullerenes Preprint: APS/123-QED Jonathan Smucker, Jesus Pérez-Ríos Abstract Methods for creating endofullerenes have been steadily improving since their discovery, allowing for new types of endofullerenes to be created in larger numbers. When a molecule is trapped in a fullerene, the fullerene creates a harmonic trapping potential that leaves most of the fundamental properties of the internal molecule intact. The fullerene cage does create a preferred axis for the internal molecule, which we refer to as the encapsulation-induced alignment of the molecule. We explore the alignment of AlF and N 2 inside of C 60 by first computing the interaction between the internal molecule and the fullerene cage using ab initio electronic structure methods. Our results show that the internal molecules are found to be strongly aligned despite finding that all the calculated spectroscopic constants are relatively unaffected by the fullerene cage. I Introduction When first discovered, Buckminster fullerene (C 60 ) was thought to be of niche interest to astrophysics. Methods for producing C 60 in a laboratory were rapidly developed and fullerenes were discovered to have many applications in physics, chemistry, astronomy and material science Kroto 1992 . Rapidly expanding studies of fullerenes quickly discovered that atoms and molecules could be trapped inside the hollow carbon cage Lu et al. 2012 ; Popov et al. 2013 ; Chai et al. 1991 , these complexes were named endohedral fullerenes or just endofullerenes. When the internal atom or molecule is light enough, the rotation and vibration of the internal molecule becomes quantized and cannot be treated classically Levitt 2013 . When the internal atom or molecule of an endofullerene is sufficiently heavy, it maintains many of its individual properties Lu et al. 2012 , similar to a molecule or atom inside a carbon nanotube. The internal molecule or atom is therefore protected from outside collisions while effectively remaining unperturbed. These properties have drawn attention from researchers due to possible applications in medical science, photovoltaics, quantum computing, and electronics Lu et al. 2012 ; Popov et al. 2013 ; Harneit 2017 . Thanks to experimental developments over the last 40 years, a wide range of molecules have been trapped inside fullerene cages Popov et al. 2013 ; Levitt 2013 . Of particular interest is the development of molecular surgery, a process in which a fullerene cage is chemically pried open allowing an atom or small molecule to be placed inside before the fullerene is sealed again Bloodworth and Whitby 2022 . Modern experimental methods allow much greater control over what type of molecular or atom is trapped inside the fullerene and allow more diverse sets of endofullerenes to be produced. With molecular endofullerenes more available than ever, more and more studies are focusing on the properties of these endofullerenes rather than their production. Specifically, many of these studies focused on the translational and rotational energy of the trapped atom or molecule Williams et al. 1993 ; Jafari et al. 2022 ; Ye et al. 2010 ; Xu et al. 2009 ; Felker and Bačić 2016 . Some of these studies use the sum of pairwise Lennard-Jones type interactions to predict the interaction between the internal molecule with the outer fullerene wall. We instead employ a grid of single point energy calculations to obtain our potential energy surfaces. Studies of vibration are limited. This study focuses on the alignment of molecules inside of C 60 , which we refer to as the encapsulation-induced alignment. The fullerene creates a preferred axis for the internal molecule, similar to the preferred axis created by an external electric field in alignment studies of free molecules. Our study focuses on two endofullerenes: N 2 @C 60 and AlF@C 60 . We demonstrate how the fullerene cage shifts the spectroscopic constants of these internal molecules. We also briefly study the effects of the fullerene on the dipole moment of AlF. N 2 represents a molecule with a highly covalent bond and a short equilibrium distance. AlF has a much higher ionic character and a much longer equilibrium distance. The contrast between these two internal molecules helps to provide insight on how a wider variety of molecules might behave while trapped inside a fullerene cage. II Computational Methods The optimized geometries and the energies of various configurations were calculated using density functional theory (DFT) as implemented in Gaussian 16 Frisch et al. 2016 . First, we performed a comparative study for the encapsulation energy of N 2 @C 60 using different functionals and basis sets, and the results are shown in Table 1 . In terms of the geometry of the endofullerene, we notice that the outer C 60 cage is largely unchanged from method to method and largely unchanged through the introduction of the internal N 2 molecule. The only major difference between the optimized geometries produced by the different methods is the bond length of the internal molecule, which results in distinct encapsulation energies. We note that the B3LYP Becke 1993 and PBEH1PBE Ernzerhof and Perdew 1998 functionals, which are well suited to describe covalent interactions, predict positive binding energies. However, functionals that are better suited for unbonded interactions, such as MN15 Yu et al. 2016 , PW6B95 Zhao and Truhlar 2005 , APFD Austin et al. 2012 , and wB97XD Chai and Head-Gordon 2008 show negative binding energies. These findings agree with previously published results on the same system Slanina et al. 2006 , although these results used fixed geometries for C 60 . Moreover, functionals including dispersion corrections or empirical dispersion corrections predict negative encapsulation energies with the exception of CAM-B3LYP Yanai et al. 2004 , although the encapsulation energy for CAM-B3LYP is very small. Based on the nature of the two systems under consideration: AlF@C 60 and N 2 @C 60 , we conclude that it is appropriate to use a functional with dispersion correction to accommodate weak interactions beyond the covalent interactions common in C 60 . This conclusion agrees with other studies that emphasize the requirement of functionals that include dispersion corrections to accurately describe observed spectra in endofullerenes Bacanu et al. 2021 . Table 1: Comparison of the encapsulation energy of N 2 @C 60 calculated using various different methods. None of these calculations accounted for basis superposition error (BSSE). Method Def2TZV Basis (kcal/mol) 6-31G** Basis (kcal/mol) B3LYP-D3 -15.87 -14.63 B3LYP 6.70 8.07 CAM-B3LYP 0.29 1.76 MN15 -23.68 -19.36 PW6B95 -11.85 -12.12 PW6B95D3 -20.63 -20.85 PBEh1PBE 0.42 1.24 wB97XD -12.12 -12.04 APFD -18.79 -18.04 From studies comparing experimental spectroscopic data on He@C 60 Bacanu et al. 2021 , it has been shown that the wB97XV functional leads to the most accurate results, followed by B3LYP-D3. Fueled by the results displayed in Table 1 and following that recommendation, we tested the computational cost of the of the wB97XV Chai and Head-Gordon 2008 functional, the B3LYP functional with GD3BJ empirical dispersion (B3LYP-D3) and the APFD functional. These results are displayed in Fig. 1 . The computational cost of the wB97XV method is comparable to the cost of the B3LYP-D3 method when using the Def2TZV basis set. When using the Def2QZV basis set, the cost of the wB97XV functional surpassed the cost of the B3LYP-D3 method significantly. For this reason, we used