The doubly librating Plutinos

Renu Malhotra, Takashi Ito · 2025

Read The doubly librating Plutinos by Renu Malhotra, Takashi Ito (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12345.txt.

Introduction

Renu Malhotra and Takashi Ito study the Plutinos, a swarm of icy bodies past Neptune, in work from 2025. Their orbits lock to Neptune's in a three-to-two rhythm, like Pluto's own path. The pair asks how many also swing in a second rhythm, tied to the tilt point of the orbit, as Pluto's path does.

About sixteen percent of known Plutinos show that second swing. Those that do cluster along an arc when plotted by orbit stretch and tilt. The arc traces back to a family of paths found by Poincaré long ago. The find may help test tales of how the giant planets drifted early on.

Catalog record

CREATORRenu Malhotra, Takashi Ito
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12345

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The doubly librating Plutinos Renu Malhotra, Takashi Ito Abstract Named for orbital kinship with Pluto, the Plutinos are a prominent group of Kuiper Belt objects whose orbital periods are in libration about the 3/2 ratio with Neptune’s. We investigate the long term orbital dynamics of known Plutinos, with attention to the additional libration (or lack thereof) of their argument of perihelion, g g , a well-known characteristic of Pluto’s orbit. We show that the g g librators amongst the Plutinos cluster around an arc in the eccentricity–inclination parameter plane. This previously unreported dynamical structure is owed to a family of periodic orbits of the third kind in the restricted problem of three bodies, identified by Poincaré at the end of the 19th century. Approximately sixteen percent of the currently known Plutinos exhibit g g librations, a far greater fraction than the ratios of the associated libration frequencies. These results may offer new constraints for theoretical models of the dynamical history of the Plutinos and of the orbital migration history of the giant planets. I Introduction The Plutinos are a dynamical group of Kuiper Belt objects whose orbital period is in 3/2 resonant ratio with Neptune’s. Their existence and high abundance is amongst the strongest lines of evidence for the orbital migration of the giant planets during the late stages of planet formation in the ancient Solar system ( Nesvorný 2018 ; Malhotra 2019 ; Gladman & Volk 2021 , see, e.g., reviews by) . The defining characteristic of the Plutinos is the libration of a critical resonant angle, \sigma , defined as \sigma=3\lambda-2\lambda^{\prime}-\varpi, (1) where \lambda denotes mean longitude, \varpi denotes longitude of perihelion, and the primed quantities denote the parameters of Neptune. The critical resonant angle of every Plutino librates around a center at \sigma=180^{\circ} , with libration periods of {\cal O}(10^{4}) years. Like Pluto itself, some Plutinos exhibit the additional property that their argument of perihelion, g , librates around one of two centers, either g=+90^{\circ} or g=-90^{\circ} , with libration periods on the order of {\cal O}(10^{6}) years; we call these the doubly librating Plutinos. (We denote the argument of perihelion with g , following the traditional notation of the canonical Delaunay elements of the Keplerian osculating ellipse, although \omega is also commonly used in the literature for this element ( Brouwer & Clemence 1961 , e.g.) .) The libration of g is also known as the von Zeipel–Lidov–Kozai [vZLK] oscillation, a phenomenon that has historically been studied in the context of the secular (orbit-averaged) three body problem (e.g., Ito & Ohtsuka 2019 ; Tremaine 2023 , note that the terms “Kozai resonance” or “Lidov–Kozai resonance” are also used in the literature) . This classical model neglects the effects of mean motion resonances. For the case of g librations in the presence of a mean motion resonance and in the presence of additional planetary perturbers, the mathematical analysis of the vZLK phenomenon requires special care in the orbit-averaging procedure (e.g., Saillenfest 2020 ; Lei et al. 2022 ; Ito & Malhotra 2023 , and references therein) . In the present work, we examine the dynamics of the Plutinos, with attention to the doubly librating subset. Section II describes the observational data of the Plutinos and our methodology for identifying the doubly librating subset. In Section III , we describe how the doubly librating Plutinos cluster around a specific structure in the eccentricity–inclination parameter space, and how this structure is related to a family of periodic orbits in the three body problem identified long ago by Poincaré 1892 , specifically the “periodic orbits of the third kind”. Section IV summarizes and concludes with remarks on the relative abundance of the doubly librating Plutinos and possible implications for their origins and the nature of giant planet migration. II Numerical simulations We retrieved the list of Plutinos identified and published in Volk & Van Laerhoven 2024 . Then, we obtained the current orbital data of these objects from JPL Horizons System ( https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/horizons/app.html#/ ). We also obtained from the Horizons System at the same time the data for solar system parameters (masses of the Sun and the eight major planets and the orbital parameters of the planets). We used these data as the inputs for numerical orbit propagation for a time span of 100 myr, with the SWIFT_RMVS3 code ( Levison & Duncan 1994 ) . SWIFT_RMVS3 is a regularized mixed variable symplectic integrator optimized for fast and accurate propagation of planetary orbits. The Plutinos were treated as test particles in this numerical simulation. The initial propagation step size was chosen as 30 days, and we recorded the orbital evolution of planets and test particles every 500 years. From the time series of the orbit propagation results, we identified 441 long term stable Plutinos, using the criterion that the range of the critical resonant angle, \sigma modulo 360 ∘ , over the 100 myr time span remained limited: \mathrm{max}\{\sigma\}-\mathrm{min}\{\sigma\}<358^{\circ} . These identifications were verified by visual inspections of plots of \sigma(t) . The reduction in the number of surviving Plutinos from the initial sample size of 453 to 441 is due to our longer integration time span (100 myr) compared to the 10 myr time span used in Volk & Van Laerhoven 2024 . Even so, this sample size is significantly larger than in previous studies of the orbital characteristics of known Plutinos. For comparison, Lawler & Gladman 2013 and Volk et al. 2016 studied Plutino samples of less than 25, Balaji et al. 2023 worked with a Plutino sample of 85. Within this sample of 441 long term stable Plutinos we found 69 cases of g librators, that is a \sim 16\% fraction. A few words are in order regarding how we identified the g librators. Recall that g is defined as the angular measure from the longitude of ascending node to the direction of pericenter of the orbit. The longitude of ascending node depends upon the choice of reference plane. JPL Horizons adopts the J2000 ecliptic as the reference plane, a practical choice for observational solar system astronomy. However, on secular timescales, the orbital planes of the planets precess around the plane normal to the total angular momentum vector of the solar system, the so-called invariable plane ( Murray & Dermott 1999 ; Souami & Souchay 2012 ) . Considering that the giant planets are the major perturbers defining the long term dynamics of the Plutinos, we adopted this plane as the reference plane for all angular orbital elements. We computed all orbital elements relative to the solar system barycenter. We looked for cases in which the time series of a Plutino’s g showed persistent librations about a possible mean value. Guidance from the classical (non-resonant) vZLK theory of the circular restricted three body problem ( Ito & Ohtsuka 2019 , e.g.) indicates that there are four possible centers of g libration: 0, 90^{\circ} , 180^{\circ} and 270^{\circ} . In the 3:2 exterior mean motion resonance, the g libration is expected to be centered at these same four values, but in other resonances the g librations can be centered at other values ( Kozai 1985 ; Saillenfest et al. 2016 ; Saillenfest 2020 ) . We looked for

Read the complete text