Weakly almost-Fuchsian manifolds are nearly-Fuchsian
Manh-Tien Nguyen, Jean-Marc Schlenker, Andrea Seppi · 2025
Read Weakly almost-Fuchsian manifolds are nearly-Fuchsian by Manh-Tien Nguyen, Jean-Marc Schlenker, Andrea Seppi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12277.txt.
Introduction
Manh-Tien Nguyen, Jean-Marc Schlenker, and Andrea Seppi prove a result about curved three-dimensional spaces. Their 2025 paper deals with hyperbolic manifolds that hold a closed least-area surface whose bending stays within set bounds. Such spaces are called almost-Fuchsian when the bounds hold.
The team shows that near that least-area surface sit other surfaces with still tighter bending bounds. For a large class of complete spaces, that fact forces the whole space to be quasi-Fuchsian. This settles a question left open since a noted 1983 paper. It also kills a later guess, since such spaces can lack the least-area surface the guess required all along, which reshapes the map of these spaces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manh-Tien Nguyen, Jean-Marc Schlenker, Andrea Seppi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12277
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Weakly almost-Fuchsian manifolds are nearly-Fuchsian Manh-Tien Nguyen, Jean-Marc Schlenker, Andrea Seppi Abstract . We show that a hyperbolic three-manifold M M containing a closed minimal surface with principal curvatures in [ − 1 , 1 ] [-1,1] also contains nearby (non-minimal) surfaces with principal curvatures in ( − 1 , 1 ) (-1,1) . When M M is complete and homeomorphic to S × ℝ S\times\mathbb{R} , for S S a closed surface, this implies that M M is quasi-Fuchsian, answering a question left open from Uhlenbeck’s 1983 seminal paper. Additionally, our result implies that there exist (many) quasi-Fuchsian manifolds that contain a closed surface with principal curvatures in ( − 1 , 1 ) (-1,1) , but no closed minimal surface with principal curvatures in ( − 1 , 1 ) (-1,1) , disproving a conjecture from the 2000s. 1. Introduction Embedded surfaces, and in particular minimal surfaces, play an important role in the study of hyperbolic three-manifolds. During the 1980s, the visionary works of Anderson [ And82 , And83 ] and Uhlenbeck [ Uhl83 ] , together with the groundbreaking existence results [ SY79 , SU82 ] , provided a fundamental input on minimal surfaces and quasi-Fuchsian manifolds. Moreover, the work of Uhlenbeck, together with the study of the hyperbolic Gauss map of (not necessarily minimal) surfaces initiated by Epstein [ Eps86 , Eps24 ] , highlighted the central role of surfaces satisfying the condition that the principal curvatures are in (-1,1) — that is, “horospherically convex on both sides”. Since then, many advances have been obtained, particularly from the 2000s and until very recently, see [ Tau04 , Has05 , San17 , HW13 , HW15 , HLT21 , HL21 , Lab21 , CMN23 ] and many others. 1.1. Main result In this paper, we investigate the condition of having principal curvatures in (-1,1) or in [-1,1] , for minimal and non-minimal surfaces. Our main result shows that, if a hyperbolic three-manifold contains a closed minimal surface with principal curvatures in [-1,1] , then one can find nearby (non-minimal) surfaces with principal curvatures in (-1,1) . Theorem 1.1 . Let \Sigma be a closed, orientable, two-sided, embedded minimal surface in a hyperbolic three manifold M , such that the principal curvatures of \Sigma are in [-1,1] . Then any neighbourhood of \Sigma in M contains a closed embedded surface with principal curvatures in (-1,1) . Observe that Theorem 1.1 does not make use of the global structure of M . That is, there is no assumption on the topology or on the completeness of M . When restricting to complete hyperbolic three-manifolds M homeomorphic to S\times{\mathbb{R}} , where S is a closed orientable surface of genus at least two, the following terminology is in place (from [ KS07 , HW13 , HL21 ] ): • M is called nearly-Fuchsian if it contains a closed surface homotopic to S\times\{\star\} with principal curvatures in (-1,1) ; • M is called almost-Fuchsian if it contains a closed minimal surface homotopic to S\times\{\star\} with principal curvatures in (-1,1) ; • M is called weakly almost-Fuchsian if it contains a closed minimal surface homotopic to S\times\{\star\} with principal curvatures in [-1,1] . In this setting, an immediate consequence of Theorem 1.1 is: Corollary 1.2 . Every weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold is nearly-Fuchsian. Let us now discuss the implications of these results. 1.2. A question of Uhlenbeck An open question since the work of Uhlenbeck (see [ Uhl83 , Theorem 3.3] ) is whether a weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold M is necessarily quasi-Fuchsian. This is well-known when M is almost-Fuchsian, but remained open when the principal curvatures achieve the maximum value 1. Since a nearly-Fuchsian manifold is quasi-Fuchsian (see [ Uhl83 , Appendix] , or [ EES22 , Proposition 4.18] in arbitrary dimensions), we prove that the answer is affirmative. Corollary 1.3 . Every weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold is quasi-Fuchsian. Let us present a few previous results around Corollaries 1.2 and 1.3 . Recently, [ HL21 , Corollary 1.4] proved that if a weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold does not contain any accidental parabolic, then it is quasi-Fuchsian. Compared to their result, we provide an independent, unified proof, removing the assumption on the accidental parabolics. In fact, as a consequence of Corollary 1.3 , every weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold does not contain any accidental parabolic. Forgetting for a moment the minimality condition on \Sigma , in [ Rub05 , Section 4] Rubinstein constructed examples of closed embedded surfaces with principal curvatures in [-1,1] in a hyperbolic three-manifold that has accidental parabolics. That is, a “weakly nearly-Fuchsian” manifold might not be quasi-Fuchsian. In particular, the conclusion of Theorem 1.1 fails if \Sigma is only a closed embedded, non-minimal, surface. The recent work of Davalo (see [ Dav24 , Theorem 1.1, Theorem 1.2] ) constructed quasi-Fuchsian manifolds that are not nearly-Fuchsian. Finally, we also remark that the class of nearly-Fuchsian manifolds is easily seen to be open inside the deformation space of complete hyperbolic structures on S\times{\mathbb{R}} , because a perturbation of the ambient hyperbolic structure will maintain the condition that the principal curvatures are in (-1,1) for small times. Therefore, the conclusion of Corollaries 1.2 and 1.3 (and Corollary 1.4 below) still holds true for M in a neighbourhood of the space of weakly almost-Fuchsian manifolds. 1.3. Nearly-Fuchsian that are not almost-Fuchsian It has been conjectured since the early 2000s (see the historical discussion below) that every nearly-Fuchsian manifold is almost-Fuchsian. Equivalently, the conjecture was that if a quasi-Fuchsian manifold M contains a closed surface with principal curvatures in (-1,1) , then it contains a closed minimal surface with principal curvatures in (-1,1) . As a consequence of our main result, we disprove this conjecture. It is known from [ Uhl83 , Theorem 4.4, Corollary 4.5] that, for every complex structure X on S and every holomorphic quadratic differential \mathfrak{q} on (S,X) , there is a unique weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold, but not almost-Fuchsian, such that the (unique) closed minimal surface in M has first fundamental form conformal to X , and second fundamental form equal to the real part of t\mathfrak{q} , for a (unique) value of t>0 . So, there is abundance of non-almost-Fuchsian, weakly almost-Fuchsian manifolds. Corollary 1.4 . Let M be a weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold that is not almost-Fuchsian. Then M contains a closed surface with principal curvatures in (-1,1) , but no closed minimal surface with principal curvatures in (-1,1) . Indeed, from [ Uhl83 ] again, it is well-known that a closed minimal surface in a weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold is unique (see also [ HLS24 , Theorem 1.3] for a more general statement), and therefore a weakly almost-Fuchsian manifold cannot contain any other closed minimal surfaces with principal curvatures in (-1,1) . The history of this problem is the following. In [ And02 ] , Andrews discussed applications of geometric flows that evolve by suitably chosen symmetric functions of the principal curvatures, mostly for the study of minimal surfaces in \mathbb{S}^{3} , and proposed a similar approach for {\mathbb{H}}^{3} . Citing [ And02 , Section 6] , “The surfaces of interest are those for which all of the principal curvatures are less than 1 in magnitude. We can find a flow which deforms any such surface