The Structure of the Molecular Envelope of the Ring Nebula (NGC 6720)

Joel H. Kastner, David J. Wilner, Diana Ryder, Paula Moraga Baez, Orsola De Marco, Raghvendra Sahai, Al Wootten, Albert Zijlstra · 2025

Read The Structure of the Molecular Envelope of the Ring Nebula (NGC 6720) by Joel H. Kastner, David J. Wilner, Diana Ryder, Paula Moraga Baez, Orsola De Marco, Raghvendra Sahai, Al Wootten, Albert Zijlstra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12223.txt.

Introduction

The Ring Nebula's glowing shell hides a colder jacket of gas, and a 2025 paper by Joel H. Kastner and co-authors gives the first detailed radio map of it. Using a submillimeter telescope array, the team imaged carbon monoxide emission from the famous nebula, NGC 6720.

The gas forms a thin layer around the hot inner shell, closely matching infrared pictures from the JWST telescope. A simple shape model fits the jacket as a squashed, three-way ellipsoid seen nearly pole-on, with a dynamical age near six thousand years. Features that looked like inner filaments in still images turned out to be fast knots flying toward and away from us. The three-dimensional view reshapes how the nebula's structure is read.

Catalog record

CREATORJoel H. Kastner, David J. Wilner, Diana Ryder, Paula Moraga Baez, Orsola De Marco, Raghvendra Sahai, Al Wootten, Albert Zijlstra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12223

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Structure of the Molecular Envelope of the Ring Nebula (NGC 6720) Joel H. Kastner, David J. Wilner, Diana Ryder, Paula Moraga Baez, Orsola De Marco, Raghvendra Sahai, Al Wootten, Albert Zijlstra Abstract We present the first interferometric imaging of molecular line emission from the Ring Nebula, NGC 6720, in the form of Submillimeter Array (SMA) observations of CO J = 2 → 1 J=2\rightarrow 1 emission. The SMA 12 CO(2–1) mapping data, with ∼ \sim 3 ′′ spatial resolution and 2 km s -1 velocity resolution, provide an unprecedentedly detailed, 3D view of the Ring’s clumpy molecular envelope. The morphology of the velocity-integrated SMA 12 CO(2–1) image closely resembles those of near-IR H 2 and PAH emission in JWST/NIRCam imaging of NGC 6720, with the molecular gas forming a geometrically thin layer surrounding the ionized gas imaged by HST and JWST. A simple, geometrical model of the 12 CO(2–1) data shows that the intrinsic structure of NGC 6720’s molecular envelope closely resembles a truncated, triaxial ellipsoid that is viewed close to pole-on, and that the dynamical age of the molecular envelope is ∼ \sim 6000 yr. The SMA 12 CO(2–1) data furthermore reveal that filamentary features seen projected in the Ring’s interior in JWST imaging are in fact fast-moving polar knots or bullets with radial velocities of ± \pm 45–50 km s -1 relative to systemic, and that the hot progenitor star remnant is positioned at the precise geometric center of the clumpy, ellipsoidal molecular shell. We assert that the Ring’s molecular envelope was formed via a relatively sudden, AGB-terminating mass ejection event ∼ \sim 6000 yr ago, and that this ellipsoidal envelope was then punctured by fast, collimated polar outflows resulting from interactions between the progenitor and one or more companion stars. Such an evolutionary scenario may describe most molecule-rich, “Ring-like” planetary nebulae. I Introduction The Ring Nebula (NGC 6720) is the nearby [ 5 , D=782^{+29}_{-32} pc;] archetype of the class of molecule-rich, “Ring-like” planetary nebulae (PNe). The intrinsic (three-dimensional) structure of the Ring has been debated for over a century [ 15 , e.g.,] . Some investigations of the Ring support a geometry consisting of an ellipsoidal main ring with surrounding quasi-spherical halo [ 17 , 16 , e.g.,] , while others provide evidence for a bipolar structure, wherein the main ring is the nebula’s dense waist and the halos are extended bipolar lobes viewed in projection [ 11 , 7 , e.g.,] . Given that molecule-rich PNe like NGC 6720 are the products of axisymmetric mass loss from relatively massive ( \stackrel{{\scriptstyle>}}{{\sim}} 2 M_{\odot} ) asymptotic giant branch (AGB) progenitors [ 13 ] , this debate concerning the Ring Nebula’s three-dimensional geometrical structure has profound implications for the mechanisms and timescales governing mass loss from AGB and post-AGB stars. Projected against the sky, the Ring displays a clear nested structure. Its inner, ionized cavity appears nearly circular in shape, with a radius of \sim 25 ′′ ( \sim 0.1 pc), and is bright in forbidden lines of high-ionization species (e.g., [O iii ]). This photoionized cavity is surrounded by a denser, elliptical ( \sim 70 {}^{\prime\prime}\times 55^{\prime\prime} ) ring structure seen in lower-excitation atomic species (e.g., [N ii ]). The main elliptical ring, in turn, is encircled by two main, very extended (150 ′′ and 230 ′′ diameter) halo structures, the larger of the two being nearly perfectly circular. The central ring and external halo system have bright near-IR H 2 emission counterparts [ 11 ] . Recently published JWST imaging of PN NGC 6720 provides an extinction-penetrating infrared view of the nebula, elucidating the detailed projected structures of its ionized and H 2 emission regions [ 22 ] . The JWST images resolve the nebula’s main molecular ring into \sim 20000 individual H 2 -emitting knots and reveal concentric arc structures in the nebula’s immense ( \sim 1 pc radius), surrounding H 2 halo. Wesson et al. [22] argue that the system of arcs within the halo revealed by the JWST H 2 images was most likely sculpted by an unseen companion to the hot, luminous ( T_{\star}\sim 130 kK, L_{\star}\sim 310 L_{\odot} ) present-day central star. An interacting binary scenario is further supported by the significant molecular gas component associated with the nebula’s main, bright elliptical ring; such molecule-rich toroidal structures in PNe are likely comprised of the remnants of AGB envelope ejecta that were focused along the orbital plane of the nebular progenitor star and a close binary companion during a stage of rapid, possibly binary-assisted AGB mass loss [e.g., 12 , 14 , and references therein] . The average angular distance between the H 2 arc structures in the molecular halo of NGC 6720 implies an orbital period of 280 years for such a putative binary consisting of AGB primary and mass-loss-shaping companion [ 22 ] . Wesson et al. [22] also find that the central star is offset from the geometric center of the nebula by \sim 1500 au, and speculate that this offset may serve as additional evidence of stellar multiplicity. However, such a large displacement of the mass-losing star from the nebular center cannot be ascribed to the influence of the same companion that generated the arcs. To explain various features observed in the JWST imaging – especially the Ring’s overall elliptical morphology and the presence of a dark lane within its central, highly ionized region — Wesson et al. [22] present a schematic structural model invoking a twin-cone bipolar geometry. In this model, which is motivated by inferences from optical spectroscopy of the Ring Nebula’s halo and core structures by Bryce et al. [7] and Guerrero et al. [10] , respectively, the axis of symmetry of the conically shaped polar lobes is viewed at an incliation \sim 30 ∘ away from pole-on. However, this basic intrinsic geometry appears at odds with that deduced from comprehensive long-slit optical spectroscopic and HST imaging observations by O’Dell et al. [17] , O’Dell et al. [16] . Those studies present evidence that the Ring’s intrinsic structure is that of a triaxial, prolate ellipsoid viewed nearly pole-on, and that the Ring’s extended halo structures are AGB wind remnants. In many respects, the JWST imaging of the Ring presented and analyzed in Wesson et al. [22] closely parallels that of ERO JWST imaging of the Southern Ring planetary nebula (NGC 3132) analyzed in De Marco et al. [9] . In both cases, the H 2 emission imaged by JWST reveals knot and arc structures in exquisite detail; however, the JWST near-IR H 2 imaging yields no nebular kinematic information and, furthermore, the near-IR H 2 emission only traces the hot ( \sim 1000 K), UV-illuminated and/or shock-excited molecular gas that constitutes the “tip of the iceberg” in terms of the total molecular gas masses of the nebulae. To ascertain the mass distribution and energetics of the molecular envelope of NGC 6720 on size scales approaching those probed by JWST, we require interferometric mm-wave maps of molecular line (i.e., CO) emission. As we demonstrated in the case of NGC 3132 [ 14 ] , such interferometric molecular line mapping data provide the means to elucidate the 3D structure and shaping history of molecule-rich PNe,

Read the complete text