Inverse cascade from helical and nonhelical decaying columnar magnetic fields
Axel Brandenburg \aff 1,2,3,4 \corresp, Longqing Yi \aff 5,6 \corresp, Xianshu Wu \aff 5 · 2025
Read Inverse cascade from helical and nonhelical decaying columnar magnetic fields by Axel Brandenburg \aff 1,2,3,4 \corresp, Longqing Yi \aff 5,6 \corresp, Xianshu Wu \aff 5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-12200.txt.
Introduction
Brandenburg, Yi, and Wu model how tangled magnetic fields decay in a swirling fluid in twenty twenty-five. Strong lasers may one day make such fields in a lab, so their decay can be studied up close. Lab fields would start stretched in one direction, unlike past models. The team asked if that changes how the field breaks down.
Their models show the field soon spreads out to look the same in all directions. Decay then follows the same rules as in even, swirling flow. Fields that start with no twist still grow twist in patches. A stored value that tracks that patchy twist steers the decay. The work links lab tests to field decay on cosmic scales.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Axel Brandenburg \aff 1,2,3,4 \corresp, Longqing Yi \aff 5,6 \corresp, Xianshu Wu \aff 5 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-12200
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Inverse cascade from helical and nonhelical decaying columnar magnetic fields Axel Brandenburg \aff 1,2,3,4 \corresp, Longqing Yi \aff 5,6 \corresp, Xianshu Wu \aff 5 Abstract Powerful lasers may in future produce magnetic fields that would allow us to study turbulent magnetohydrodynamic inverse cascade behavior. This has so far only been seen in numerical simulations. In the laboratory, however, the produced fields may be highly anisotropic. Here, we present corresponding simulations to show that, during the turbulent decay, such a magnetic field undergoes spontaneous isotropization. As a consequence, we find the decay dynamics to be similar to that in isotropic turbulence. We also find that an initially pointwise nonhelical magnetic field is unstable and develops magnetic helicity fluctuations that can be quantified by the Hosking integral. It is a conserved quantity that characterizes magnetic helicity fluctuations and governs the turbulent decay when the mean magnetic helicity vanishes. As in earlier work, the ratio of the magnetic decay time to the Alfvén time is found to be around 50 50 in the helical and nonhelical cases. At intermediate times, the ratio can even reach a hundred. This ratio determines the endpoints of cosmological magnetic field evolution. 1 Introduction In the absence of any initial velocity field and without any type of forcing, an initially random magnetic field can only decay. This decay can be sped up by turbulent gas motions driven through the Lorentz force that is being exerted by the magnetic field itself. The decay of such a random field obeys powerlaw behavior where the magnetic energy density {\cal E}_{\rm M} decays with time t like {\cal E}_{\rm M}(t)\propto t^{-p} , and the magnetic correlation length \xi_{\rm M} increases like \xi_{\rm M}\propto t^{q} . For a helical magnetic field, we have p=q=2/3 ( Hatori, 1984 ; Biskamp & Müller, 1999 ) , while for a nonhelical magnetic field, we have p=10/9 and q=4/9 ( Hosking & Schekochihin, 2021 ; Zhou et al., 2022 ) . Such a decay has been seen in many hydromagnetic numerical simulations ( Brandenburg et al., 2015 ; Hosking & Schekochihin, 2021 ; Armua et al., 2023 ; Brandenburg et al., 2023 ) , but not yet in plasma experiments. With the advance of high-powered lasers it is already possible to produce magnetic fields in the laboratory ( Tzeferacos et al., 2018 ) , and similar advances may also allow us to achieve sufficient scale separation to perform meaningful inverse cascade experiments. However, such magnetic fields may be strongly anisotropic, so the question arises to what extent this affects the otherwise familiar decay dynamics. Our goal here is to study the decay of an array of magnetic flux tubes with an electric current that is aligned with the magnetic field ( Jiang et al., 2021 ) . Such a field is indeed highly anisotropic such that the correlation length in the direction along the tubes is much larger than that perpendicular to it. A simple numerical realization of such a magnetic field is what is called the Roberts field I, which is more commonly also known as Roberts flow I. It is one of four flow fields studied by Roberts (1972) in the context of dynamo theory. The field is fully helical, but with a slight modification, it can become a pointwise nonhelical field, which is then called the Roberts field II. Both fields are here of interest. They are defined in section 2 , along with a proper measure of anisotropy, the relevant evolution equations, and relevant input and output parameters. In section 3 , we present numerical results for both flows using different magnetic diffusivities and scale separation ratios. Inverse cascading during the turbulent decay of helical and nonhelical magnetic fields has applications to primordial magnetic fields in the radiation dominated era of the Universe, which are discussed in section 4 . We conclude in section 5 . 2 Our model 2.1 Roberts fields To fix our geometry, we assume magnetic flux tubes to extend in the z direction and being perpendicular to the xy plane. Such a field can be realized by the so-called Roberts field I, i.e., the magnetic field \bm{B} is given by \bm{B}=\bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}}\equiv{\bm{\nabla}}\times\phi\hat{\mbox{\boldmath$z$}}{}+\sqrt{2}k_{0}\phi\hat{\mbox{\boldmath$z$}}{},\quad\mbox{where}\quad\phi=k_{0}^{-1}B_{0}\sin k_{0}x\sin k_{0}y. (1) is an xy periodic field. Such a magnetic field has a component in the z direction, but no variation along that direction, so it is highly anisotropic. This may change with time as the magnetic field undergoes a turbulent decay. The Roberts field I is maximally helical with \bm{A}\cdot\bm{B}=\sqrt{2}k_{0}^{-1}B_{0}^{2}(\sin^{2}k_{0}x+\sin^{2}k_{0}y) , so \langle\bm{A}\cdot\bm{B}\rangle=\sqrt{2}k_{0}^{-1}B_{0}^{2} . Here, \bm{A} is the magnetic vector potential and \bm{B}={\bm{\nabla}}\times\bm{A} . The Roberts field II, by contrast, is given by \bm{B}=\bm{B}_{\mathrm{II}}\equiv{\bm{\nabla}}\times\phi\hat{\mbox{\boldmath$z$}}{}+k_{\rm f}\tilde{\phi}\hat{\mbox{\boldmath$z$}}{},\quad\mbox{where}\quad\tilde{\phi}=k_{0}^{-1}B_{0}\cos k_{0}x\cos k_{0}y, (2) where \tilde{\phi} is 90\hbox{${}^{\circ}$} phase shifted in the x and y directions relative to \phi(x,y) and k_{\rm f}=\sqrt{2}k_{0} is the eigenvalue of the curl operator for field I, i.e., {\bm{\nabla}}\times\bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}}=k_{\rm f}\bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}} , so \bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}}\cdot{\bm{\nabla}}\times\bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}}=k_{\rm f}\bm{B}_{\mathrm{I}}^{2} , while \bm{B}_{\mathrm{II}}\cdot{\bm{\nabla}}\times\bm{B}_{\mathrm{II}}=0 pointwise. Both for fields I and II, we have \langle\bm{B}^{2}\rangle=2B_{0}^{2} . 2.2 Quantifying the emerging anisotropy To quantify the degree of anisotropy, we must separate the derivatives of the magnetic field along the z direction ( {\bm{\nabla}}_{\|} ) from those perpendicular to it ( {\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp} ), so {\bm{\nabla}}={\bm{\nabla}}_{\|}+{\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp} . We also decompose the magnetic field analogously, i.e., \bm{B}=\bm{B}_{\|}+\bm{B}_{\perp} . The mean current density can be decomposed similarly, i,e., \bm{J}=\bm{J}_{\|}+\bm{J}_{\perp} , but this decomposition mixes the underlying derivatives. We see this by computing \bm{J}\equiv{\bm{\nabla}}\times\bm{B} (where the permeability has been set to unity). Using this decomposition, we find \bm{J}={\bm{\nabla}}_{\|}\times\bm{B}_{\perp}+{\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp}\times\bm{B}_{\|}+{\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp}\times\bm{B}_{\perp}, (3) noting that {\bm{\nabla}}_{\|}\times\bm{B}_{\|}=0 . The term of interest for characterizing the emergent isotropization is the first one, {\bm{\nabla}}_{\|}\times\bm{B}_{\perp} , because it involves only parallel derivatives ( z derivatives), which vanish initially. We monitor the ratio of its mean squared value to \langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle . The last term in equation ( 3 ) is just \bm{J}_{\|}={\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp}\times\bm{B}_{\perp} , but the first and second terms cannot simply be expressed in terms of \bm{J}_{\perp} , although {\bm{\nabla}}_{\|}\times\bm{B}_{\perp} would be \bm{J}_{\perp} if the magnetic field only had a component in the plane, and {\bm{\nabla}}_{\perp}\times\bm{B}_{\|} would be \bm{J}_{\perp} if the magnetic field only had a component out of the plane. We therefore denote those two contributions in the following by \bm{J}_{\perp\perp} and \bm{J}_{\perp\|} , respectively, so that \bm{J}_{\perp\perp}+\bm{J}_{\perp\|}=\bm{J}_{\perp} . Thus, as motivated above, to monitor the emergent isotropization, we determine \langle\bm{J}_{\perp\perp}^{2}\rangle/\langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle . For isotropic turbulence, we find that this ratio is about 4/15\approx 0.27 , and this is also true for \langle\bm{J}_{\perp\|}^{2}\rangle/\langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle ; see Appendix A for an empirical demonstration. In the expression for \langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle , there is also a mixed term, \bm{J}_{\perp\textrm{m}}^{2}=-2\langle B_{x,z}B_{z,x}+B_{y,z}B_{z,y}\rangle , which turns out to be positive in practice. Here, commas denote partial differentiation. Thus, we have \langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle=\langle\bm{J}_{\perp\perp}^{2}\rangle+\langle\bm{J}_{\perp\|}^{2}\rangle+\langle\bm{J}_{\perp\textrm{m}}^{2}\rangle+\langle\bm{J}_{\|}^{2}\rangle. (4) In the isotropic case, we find \langle\bm{J}_{\|}^{2}\rangle/\langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle=1/3 , and for the mixed term we then have \langle\bm{J}_{\perp\textrm{m}}^{2}\rangle/\langle\bm{J}^{2}\rangle=2/15\approx 0.13 . 2.3 Evolution equations To study the decay of the magnetic field, we solve the evolution equations of magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) for an isotropic compressible gas with constant sound speed c_{\rm s} , so the gas density \rho is proportional to the pressure p=\rho c_{\rm s}^{2} . In that case, \ln\rho and the velocity \bm{u} obey \frac{{\rm D}{}\ln\rho}{{\rm D}{}t}=-{\bm{\nabla}}\cdot\bm{u}, (5) \frac{{\rm D}{}\bm{u}}{{\rm D}{}t}=-c_{\rm s}^{2}{\bm{\nabla}}\ln\rho+\frac{1}{\rho}\left[\bm{J}\times\bm{B}+{\bm{\nabla}}\cdot(2\rho\nu\mbox{\boldmath${\sf S}$}{})\right], (6) where {\rm D}{}/{\rm D}{}t=\partial/\partial t+\bm{u}\cdot{\bm{\nabla}} is the advective derivative, \nu is the kinematic