Nonreciprocal metasurfaces with epsilon-near-zero materials

Albert Mathew 1 , Rebecca Aschwanden 2 , Aditya Tripathi 1 , Piyush Jangid 1 , Basudeb Sain 2,3 , Thomas Zentgraf ∗2 , Sergey Kruk ∗4 · 2025

Read Nonreciprocal metasurfaces with epsilon-near-zero materials by Albert Mathew 1 , Rebecca Aschwanden 2 , Aditya Tripathi 1 , Piyush Jangid 1 , Basudeb Sain 2,3 , Thomas Zentgraf ∗2 , Sergey Kruk ∗4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11920.txt.

Introduction

Albert Mathew and co-authors demo in a 2025 paper a flat surface that passes light unevenly by direction, at ultrafast speed. One way light flow, like a diode for optics, today needs bulky kit. Nonlinear surfaces promised thin versions, but past demos leaned on slow heat or phase change effects.

Their surface uses indium tin oxide near its epsilon near zero point for speed. It works across 1200 to 1300 nm at high incident power levels in the tests. The one way effect spans both brightness and phase of the passed light. That dual reach opens a path to one way wavefront shaping at tiny scales. Response time is ultrafast, a sharp break from the slow routes before it.

Catalog record

CREATORAlbert Mathew 1 , Rebecca Aschwanden 2 , Aditya Tripathi 1 , Piyush Jangid 1 , Basudeb Sain 2,3 , Thomas Zentgraf ∗2 , Sergey Kruk ∗4
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11920

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nonreciprocal metasurfaces with epsilon-near-zero materials Preprint: APS/123-QED Albert Mathew 1 , Rebecca Aschwanden 2 , Aditya Tripathi 1 , Piyush Jangid 1 , Basudeb Sain 2,3 , Thomas Zentgraf ∗2 , Sergey Kruk ∗4 Abstract Nonreciprocal optics enables asymmetric transmission of light when its sources and detectors are exchanged. A canonical example – optical isolator – enables light propagation in only one direction, similar to how electrical diodes enable unidirectional flow of electric current. Nonreciprocal optics today, unlike nonreciprocal electronics, remains bulky. Recently, nonlinear metasurfaces opened up a pathway to strong optical nonreciprocity at the nanoscale. However, demonstrations to date were based on optically slow nonlinearities involving thermal effects or phase transition materials. In this work, we demonstrate a nonreciprocal metasurface with an ultra-fast optical response based on indium tin oxide in its epsilon-near-zero regime. It operates in the spectral range of 1200-1300 nm with incident power densities of 40-70 GW/cm 2 . Furthermore, the nonreciprocity of the metasurface extends to both amplitude and phase of the forward/backward transmission opening a pathway to nonreciprocal wavefront control at the nanoscale. Contemporary optics is undergoing revolutionary transformations driven by nanotechnology. Today we can nanofabricate functional optical components hundreds of times thinner than a human hair that outperform conventional bulky optics Kruk and Kivshar 2017 ; Kamali et al. 2018 ; Chen et al. 2020 . A vital but largely unaddressed problem of contemporary nanoscale optics and nanophotonics is how to break reciprocity Peng et al. 2014 ; Caloz et al. 2018 in light propagation. Nonreciprocity is instrumental for the traffic control of signals in high-end laser systems, optical communications and machine vision with LiDAR technology Yang et al. 2020 . However, optical nonreciprocity is difficult to achieve and there exist only three known conceptual pathways Peng et al. 2014 ; Caloz et al. 2018 : (i) materials with asymmetric permittivity/permeability tensors such as ferrites, (ii) time-varying systems, and (iii) nonlinear light-matter interactions. Today virtually all commercial optical isolators are based on the first pathway of materials with asymmetric material property tensors that show a magneto-optic Faraday effect under a static magnetic field. Such optical isolators require strong magnets, which hinder their miniaturization. Typical optical isolators today measure centimetres in size. Materials with high remanent magnetization (magnetism that remains in a material after an external magnetic field is removed) may represent a pathway toward miniaturization of nonreciprocal optics. Remanent magnetisation was used in nonreciprocal metasurfaces in the microwave spectral range (at around 15GHz frequency or 2 cm wavelength) Yang et al. 2023 . This is, however, challenging to apply at optical frequencies due to constrains of material properties. As of now, miniaturization of nonreciprocal optical components based on materials with asymmetric permittivity/permeability tensor faces a roadblock. This prevents fabrication and integration of large quantities of nonreciprocal photonic components into intricate layouts similar to how nonreciprocal electronic components – diodes and transistors – are integrated into chips. The second approach based on time varying systems Yu and Fan 2009 ; Kang et al. 2011 ; Estep et al. 2014 includes a broad range of phenomena covering acousto-optics Kittlaus et al. 2020 ; Tian et al. 2021 , opto-mechanics Wanjura et al. 2023 , and electro-optics Yu et al. 2023 . The advancements in time-varying systems led to a significant miniaturization of nonreciprocal optics down to the micrometre-scale. Recent demonstrations include systems based on lithium niobate Sohn et al. 2021 and silicon nitride on-chip waveguiding platforms Ji et al. 2022 . However, further miniaturisation of such systems from the micro-scale to the nanoscale has not been achieved. At present, the most feasible pathway towards nonreciprocity at the nanoscale is via nonlinear light-matter interactions. Nonlinearity-induced nonreciprocity at the sub-micrometer scale has been studied in unstructured thin films Tocci et al. 1995 ; Anand et al. 2013 ; Tang et al. 2020 ; Wan et al. 2018 . However, such observations were accompanied by low levels of transmission and high insertion losses, which hindered their development beyond initial proof-of-concept experiments. Nonlinearity-induced nonreciprocity began rapidly evolving at its confluence with the physics of nanoresonators and metasurfaces. Optical metasurfaces can be realised as arrays of subwavelength elements judiciously designed to resonate with the incident light thus enhancing light-matter interactions by orders of magnitude Koshelev et al. 2020 ; Zubyuk et al. 2021 . Theoretical studies of nonlinear nanoresonators and metasurfaces revealed asymmetric and nonreciprocal responses of light Poutrina and Urbas 2016 ; Kim 2021 ; Lawrence et al. 2018 ; Jin and Argyropoulos 2020 ; Cheng et al. 2021 ; Antonellis et al. 2019 ; Karakurt et al. 2010 . Experimental demonstrations of nonlinear effects that are asymmetric with respect to forward vs backward propagation of light were performed for the generation of optical harmonics of third Shitrit et al. 2018 ; Kruk et al. 2022 ; Kruk et al. 2019 and second Boroviks et al. 2023 order. Nonlinear self-action leading to nonreciprocity was recently demonstrated in metasurfaces hybridised with a phase-change material (vanadium dioxide) in both near-infrared spectral regions (fibre communications band) Tripathi et al. 2024 and in mid-infrared King et al. 2024 , as well as in silicon grating metasurfaces leveraging a combination of thermal and Kerr-type effects Cotrufo et al. 2024 . Such nonlinear metasurfaces, being fundamentally self-biased systems (that is, the nonreciprocal response being triggered by the propagating light itself without any external stimuli), have a finite switching time between different responses in ”forward” and ”backward” directions. In ref. Cotrufo et al. 2024 switching times on the order of microseconds were reported. The switching time in the vanadium dioxide metasurfaces was theoretically estimated Tripathi et al. 2024 to be in the range of microseconds for the continuous wave operation going down for pulsed operation to sub-nanoseconds (transmission fall time) and hundreds of nanoseconds (transmission rise time). To date, nanoscale nonreciprocity was not demonstrated in a platform enabling ultra-fast optical switching times. Here, we demonstrate an optical metasurface that incorporates an epsilon-near-zero (ENZ) material Alam et al. 2016 . Such ENZ regimes of optical responses were demonstrated in multiple material platforms including indium tin oxide (ITO) Alam et al. 2016 and aluminium zinc oxide Caspani et al. 2016 . ENZ materials incorporated into metasurfaces were shown to enhance light confinement and to boost nonlinear effects Shi et al. 2021 ; Deng et al. 2020 ; Xie et al. 2024 ; Minerbi et al. 2022 ; Alam et al. 2018 ; Ma et al. 2023 ; Schulz et al. 2020 , enabling optical modulation Vatani et al. 2022 , broadband optical absorption Wang et al. 2019 , optical switching Xie et al. 2020 , photon acceleration Liu et al. 2021 , and electrochemical control Kaissner et al. 2021a ; Karst et al. 2021a . We note that the nonlinear response of epsilon-near-zero materials can be on the femtosecond scale. In our work, the nonlinear refractive index modulation of the ENZ material leads to ultra-fast nonlinear nonreciprocity. We choose ITO as the material platform and fabricate silicon (Si) nanodisks on top of it such that the combined system of the Si-nanodisks and the ITO-film forms a nano-resonator (Figs. 1a-c). The measured relative permittivity of the ITO film shows the transition from positive to negative values at a wavelength

Read the complete text