Experiences Applying Lean R&D in Industry-Academia Collaboration Projects

Marcos Kalinowski, Lucas Romao, Ariane Rodrigues, Clarissa Barbosa, Hugo Villamizar, Simone D. J. Barbosa, Hélio Lopes · 2025

Read Experiences Applying Lean R&D in Industry-Academia Collaboration Projects by Marcos Kalinowski, Lucas Romao, Ariane Rodrigues, Clarissa Barbosa, Hugo Villamizar, Simone D. J. Barbosa, Hélio Lopes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11774.txt.

Introduction

Marcos Kalinowski and co-authors report on lean research work with industry in 2025. Lean research and development aims to turn ideas into business value fast. A university team in Rio de Janeiro has used it to pair academia with firms. Partners in this report span oil and gas work and a large retail chain.

Dozens of people took part, from team members to sponsors and managers. They rated the staged lean process as a good fit for innovation projects. The authors note that many factors shape joint success beyond any one method. Still, they present the approach as a promising frame for fast, high impact joint projects.

Catalog record

CREATORMarcos Kalinowski, Lucas Romao, Ariane Rodrigues, Clarissa Barbosa, Hugo Villamizar, Simone D. J. Barbosa, Hélio Lopes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11774

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experiences Applying Lean R&D in Industry-Academia Collaboration Projects Marcos Kalinowski, Lucas Romao, Ariane Rodrigues, Clarissa Barbosa, Hugo Villamizar, Simone D. J. Barbosa, Hélio Lopes Abstract Lean R&D has been used at PUC-Rio to foster industry-academia collaboration in innovation projects across multiple sectors. This industrial experience paper describes recent experiences and evaluation results from applying Lean R&D in partnership with Petrobras in the oil and gas sector and Americanas in retail. The findings highlight Lean R&D’s effectiveness in transforming ideas into meaningful business outcomes. Based on responses from 57 participants—including team members, managers, and sponsors—the assessment indicates that stakeholders find the structured phases of Lean R&D well-suited to innovation projects and endorse the approach. Although acknowledging that successful collaboration relies on various factors, this industrial experience positions Lean R&D as a promising framework for industry-academia projects focused on achieving rapid, impactful results for industry partners. 1 Introduction Industry-Academia Collaboration (IAC) projects have been a main focus at PUC-Rio, Latin America’s leading university in industry income according to the Times Higher Education ranking [ 13 ] . Several of these IAC projects are carried out within the oil and gas industry, mainly motivated by the needs of Petrobras, a state-owned Brazilian multinational corporation headquartered in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Research, Development, and Innovation (RDI) initiatives in the oil and gas industry commonly involve cooperation terms with research institutes and universities. These terms were usually designed in a plan-driven manner, with deliveries that, given research uncertainties, typically spanned several years. In September 2019, representatives of Petrobras came up with a challenge: to structure an RDI collaboration that would enable agile deliveries of Minimal Viable Products (MVPs) to test business hypotheses, allowing to take ideas from their conception to impact. To address this challenge, we designed an RDI approach to allow fast-paced MVP deliveries. The resulting approach, inspired by continuous software engineering principles [ 2 ] and concepts from Lean [ 9 ] and Lean Startup [ 10 ] , was called Lean R&D [ 5 , 6 ] . In January 2020, Petrobras started four IAC projects with PUC-Rio applying Lean R&D. The ExACTa ( exacta.inf.puc-rio.br ) laboratory was created at PUC-Rio to handle such agile RDI projects, aiming at fast-paced deliveries of R&D projects, aligning research on artificial intelligence, human-computer interaction, and software engineering with the digital transformation needs of industrial partners. The first case studies on using Lean R&D provided initial indications into the feasibility of using the approach within RDI projects [ 6 , 12 ] . Since then, ExACTa has been using Lean R&D to deliver innovative solutions to several industry partners. This industrial experience paper provides new results assessing the use of Lean R&D in more recent RDI IAC projects with Petrobras and Americanas, a player active in the retail business in Brazil, which owns more than 1,000 physical stores spread throughout the country. We report on the experiences and their results, assess the perception of the suitability of Lean R&D, and discuss the overall acceptance from the point of view of members of the R&D teams, business and technical managers, and sponsors. With Petrobras, we focus on the use of Lean R&D in two Artificial Intelligence (AI) projects. Both were subject to patent applications [ 7 , 8 ] and received a Petrobras inventor award at the end of 2022. One of these projects, called Smart Tocha ( Smart Torch ), comprises an AI solution that continuously processes oil refinery torch burn images to automatically act over refinery controls to increase the energy efficiency of the gas burning. The other one, called Inspetor Digital ( Digital Inspector ), involves using AI to help refinery equipment inspectors complete reports more quickly and efficiently. This paper focuses on the process used at ExACTa, not on the particular projects; more details on the projects can be found within the patent applications. Americanas started their IAC with ExACTa in July 2022 and set up four teams to simultaneously handle RDI projects using Lean R&D. These projects concerned innovating the management of physical stores, improving logistic operations, and applying machine learning for product classification and e-commerce recommendations. While ExACTa R&D employees working on the projects for Petrobras were experienced professionals, Americanas wanted to involve undergrad, master, and Ph.D. students in the teams. The contract involved applying two complete Lean R&D cycles throughout one year (six months for each MVP delivery per team). Each team had ten members: eight undergraduate students, one master’s student, and one PhD student. The team was supported by a general coordination involving representatives of ExACTa and Americanas and a dedicated mentor with a Ph.D. in computer science. The students also received training and mentorship from researchers of PUC-Rio. We called these teams ExACTa FIT, where FIT is a Portuguese acronym standing for education in technological innovation. The ExACTa FIT teams conducted all Lean R&D phases, including ideating innovative solutions. We report on the outcomes of these projects and perceptions on Lean R&D gathered through questionnaires applied to the different stakeholders at Petrobras and Americanas. We received 57 responses, mainly indicating the suitability of the Lean R&D’s phases and its overall acceptance, but also providing attention points related to the ease of learning and applying the approach and improvement opportunities. 2 Overview of Lean R&D When designing the Lean R&D approach, the main requirements were to allow maximizing business value while minimizing waste, allowing to fail fast to enable handling opportunities, and enabling to address complex RDI problems with fast-paced deliveries. Based on these requirements, the approach was designed starting with a Lean Inception [ 1 ] ideation workshop, parallel (early) technical feasibility assessment and conception phases, scrum-based development, and continuous experimentation. An overview of Lean R&D is shown in Figure 1 . Figure 1: Overview of the Lean R&D approach. The timeline is illustrative and reflects typical timeframes used within the ExACTa PUC-Rio laboratory. It is possible to observe four checkpoints, a set of activities, and the support of a dedicated research team for technical solution-related activities. More details on these elements and the involved roles can be found in our previous paper describing Lean R&D [ 6 ] . Hereafter, we summarise the activities to provide an overview understanding. The approach starts with a Lean Inception to allow stakeholders to jointly outline the vision of an MVP that can be used to test business hypotheses associated with industrial impact. This phase emphasizes co-creation between academic and industry teams, ensuring alignment on the MVP’s objectives and expected outcomes. At the first checkpoint, a steering committee (including the sponsor customer) must approve the MVP outline and its intended business value. Otherwise, if the idea of the MVP or its expected results are not promising enough, it fails fast, and a new Lean Inception is conducted, potentially focusing on a different business problem. This checkpoint thus ensures that only high-potential projects move forward, optimizing resource allocation and focus. In the Technical Feasibility phase, the development team, assisted by the research team, starts investigating the technical feasibility of implementing the features identified during the Lean Inception. In parallel, the Conception involves a Product Owner (PO) detailing the MVP features identified during the Lean Inception by applying product backlog-building co-creation dynamics and

Read the complete text