A Realistic Projection for Constraining Neutron Star Equation of State with the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Detector Network in the A+ Era
Alexis Boudon, Hong Qi, Jean-Francois Coupechoux, Philippe Landry, Viola Sordini · 2025
Read A Realistic Projection for Constraining Neutron Star Equation of State with the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Detector Network in the A+ Era by Alexis Boudon, Hong Qi, Jean-Francois Coupechoux, Philippe Landry, Viola Sordini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11585.txt.
Introduction
Alexis Boudon and co-authors forecast neutron star measurements for upgraded detectors in 2025. Merging neutron stars ring gravitational wave detectors, and their squishiness reveals the star matter equation of state. The coming detector upgrade era promises more and sharper merger signals. The team simulated three thousand merger signals under three candidate equations.
Full parameter recovery used fast reduced order methods. Squishiness tended to read high for heavy stars and low for light ones. The study names those biases and the corrections they need. Honest forecasts keep the field from overclaiming when real upgraded data arrive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexis Boudon, Hong Qi, Jean-Francois Coupechoux, Philippe Landry, Viola Sordini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11585
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Realistic Projection for Constraining Neutron Star Equation of State with the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Detector Network in the A+ Era Alexis Boudon, Hong Qi, Jean-Francois Coupechoux, Philippe Landry, Viola Sordini Abstract The LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA network in the upcoming A+ era with upgrades of both Advanced LIGO (aLIGO+) and Advanced Virgo (AdV+) will enable more frequent and precise observations of binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, improving the constraints on neutron star equation of state (EOS). In this study, we applied reduced order quadrature techniques for full parameter estimation of 3,000 simulated gravitational wave signals from BNS mergers at A+ sensitivity following three EOS models— hqc18 , sly230a , and mpa1 . We found that tidal deformability tend to be overestimated at higher mass and underestimated at lower mass. We postprocessed the parameter estimation results to present our EOS recovery accuracies, identify biases within EOS constraints and their causes, and quantify the needed corrections. I Introduction Seven years on from the first observation of a binary neutron star (BNS) merger with gravitational waves (GWs), GW170817 [ 4 , 5 , 8 ] remains the only GW transient that is appreciably informative about the uncertain structure and makeup of neutron star (NS) matter. The measurement of the BNS tidal deformability parameter \tilde{\Lambda} [ 34 , 68 ] from the tidal phasing of the inspiral gravitational waveform has been translated into constraints on the NS radius and equation of state (EOS) [ 28 , 6 , 10 ] . These constraints have since been refined [ 26 , 47 , 38 , 40 ] by combining information from radio [ 21 , 35 ] and X-ray [ 50 , 51 , 59 , 62 ] observations of pulsars, data from nuclear experiments [ 46 , 61 , 17 ] , and predictions from nuclear theory [ 48 , 30 ] , while recent works have explored the impact of dynamical tidal effects and advanced Bayesian methods for EOS constraints in future GW observations [ 57 , 36 ] . Nonetheless, significant uncertainties exist in our understanding of NS matter and its equation of state. The current dearth of revelatory GW observations of NSs is attributable to two facts. First, the astrophysical rate of BNS mergers is much lower [ 14 ] than estimated in the immediate aftermath of GW170817 [ 4 ] : despite 11 months of subsequent observing time by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) network [ 1 , 16 , 20 ] with improved detector sensitivity during the O3 observing run, only one additional BNS merger, GW190425 [ 11 ] , has been observed to date. Second, GW190425’s source was so distant, and so unusually massive, that no useful tidal information was extractable from the signal [ 11 ] . Similarly, the LVK’s existing NS–black-hole discoveries [ 12 , 2 ] —while more numerous than the BNS detections—have very little to say about NS matter, as they are unlikely to have undergone tidal disruption prior to merger owing to their asymmetric mass ratios and small primary spins [ 24 , 63 , 2 ] . After its ongoing O4 observing run concludes, the LVK network will undergo further upgrades to bring its LIGO detectors to A+ sensitivity [ 7 ] and its overall BNS range [ 27 ] to 240-345 Mpc [ 66 ] . Constraints on the neutron star EOS at Advanced LIGO/Virgo design sensitivity have been studied, such as [ 19 ] with 200 BNSs and two parameter power series for the tidal deformability versus mass relation, [ 37 ] with 40 BNSs and piecewise polytrope and spectral EOSs, and [ 42 ] with 5 BNSs and nonparametric EOSs; however, these studies used outdated estimation of A+ sensitivity, simulations at smaller scales, or not end-to-end simulations. Here we make projections for neutron star EOS constraints that can be expected from an O5 observing campaign with the LVK network in the A+ configuration, using the best current estimates of the BNS merger rate, population and EOS. We simulate a realistic population of BNS coalescences detectable in three years of continuous three-detector operation [ 66 ] , considering three possibilities for the assumed NS EOS, supporting relatively compact, typical and diffuse NSs, respectively. We calculate the source parameter uncertainties for each detected BNS signal in our simulated population using reduced-order-quadrature– (ROQ–) accelerated GW parameter estimation (PE) [ 25 , 64 , 58 ] , as implemented in Bilby [ 22 ] . We then perform Bayesian inference of the EOS [ 43 ] using LWP [ 31 ] , interpolating the PE samples for GW observation with a kernel density estimate and modeling the EOS phenomenologically as a Gaussian process [ 41 , 32 ] . Three years of LVK observation at A+ sensitivity typically results in 25 (within the range 0.9 to 450 estimated in Section II.1 ) BNS detections with a network signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) greater than 11.2. For a signal to qualify as a detection, we require not only a network SNR exceeding 11.2 but also that the SNR in each detector surpasses 5. This criterion ensures sufficient contributions from all detectors while maintaining high confidence in the detection significance. The network threshold itself is empirically calibrated, considering detector sensitivities, noise characteristics, and false alarm rates, as discussed in recent analyses [ 53 ] . Analyzing these observations jointly in the LWP , a hierarchical Bayesian inference framework, we find that the three equations of state can be marginally distinguished with necessary corrections. Despite the projected O5-era BNS observations thus promising incremental gains in our EOS knowledge, we conclude that precision constraints on the EOS from gravitational waves must wait until the proposed A# [ 7 ] or Voyager [ 18 ] upgrade to the LVK network, or until planned next-generation ground-based GW detectors like Einstein Telescope [ 49 ] and Cosmic Explorer [ 33 ] come online. Our study is organized as follows: Sec. II describes our methodology; Sec. III presents the PE results for the simulated BNS population; and Sec. IV presents the results of the EOS inference. We draw our conclusions and discuss them in Sec. V . II Methods II.1 Simulated BNS Population Following Landry & Read [45] , Abbott et al. [14] , we simulate a population of BNS coalescences by assuming a uniform NS mass distribution between 1,M_{\odot} and the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) maximum mass, pairing them randomly into binaries. The NS spins are oriented isotropically and sampled uniformly in dimensionless magnitude up to 0.05 , consistent with the spins of known Galactic double NSs [ 56 , 39 ] that will merge within a Hubble time. We distribute the sources uniformly over the sky and in comoving volume out to a distance of 460 Mpc, which is well beyond the BNS range of the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) network at O5 sensitivity [ 7 ] . The chosen population model is summarized in Table 1 . The simulated signals are injected using Bilby into Gaussian noise representative of A+ sensitivity [ 65 ] . The used noise curves are APlusDesign.txt for LIGO Hanford and Livingstone, avirgo_O5high_NEW.txt for Virgo, and kagra \_ 80MPc.txt for KAGRA. Later in Sec. IV , we adopt an astrophysical BNS merger rate of 10 to