On the hierarchy of plate models for a singularly perturbed multi-well nonlinear elastic energy
Edoardo Giovanni Tolotti · 2025
Read On the hierarchy of plate models for a singularly perturbed multi-well nonlinear elastic energy by Edoardo Giovanni Tolotti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11443.txt.
Introduction
Edoardo Giovanni Tolotti rebuilds a ladder of plate models for a trickier elastic material in a solo 2025 paper. A classic result sorts thin plate behavior into tiers by how energy scales as thickness shrinks. That proof leans on a stiffness bound that snaps when the material has several rest shapes, as in metals that switch phases.
Following a known patch, Tolotti adds a term that fines jumps between rest shapes, which keeps wild bends in check. In that frame the full tier ladder returns, with each rest shape's mark on the tiers made plain. He then shows energy minimizers settle as they should under outside forces with free edges. A fresh take on best fit rotations carries the proof for that step.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Edoardo Giovanni Tolotti |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11443
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the hierarchy of plate models for a singularly perturbed multi-well nonlinear elastic energy Edoardo Giovanni Tolotti Abstract † † footnotetext: This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Journal of Nonlinear Science. The final authenticated version is available in Open Access at https://doi.org/10.1007/s00332-025-10174-3 Abstract In the celebrated work of Friesecke, James and Müller ’06 the authors derive a hierarchy of models for plates by carefully analyzing the \Gamma -convergence of the rescaled nonlinear elastic energy. The key ingredient of their proofs is the rigidity estimate proved in an earlier work of theirs. Here we consider the case in which the elastic energy has a multi-well structure: this type of functional arises, for example, in the study of solid-solid phase transitions. Since the rigidity estimate fails in the case of compatible wells, we follow Alicandro, Dal Maso, Lazzaroni and Palombaro ’18 and add a regularization term to the energy that penalizes jumps from one well to another, leading to good compactness properties. In this setting we recover the full hierarchy of plate models with an explicit dependence on the wells. Finally, we study the convergence of energy minimizers with suitable external forces and full Neumann boundary conditions. To do so, we adapt the definition of optimal rotations introduced by Maor, Mora ’21. Keywords : Dimension reduction \cdot Thin plates \cdot Nonlinear elasticity \cdot \Gamma -convergence AMS Classification : 74K20 \cdot 74B20 \cdot 74G65 \cdot 49J45 Introduction A large variety of elastic models for thin plates, i.e., slender bodies whose reference configuration has no intrinsic curvature, have been proposed in the mechanical literature (see for example [ 9 , 2 , 20 , 25 ] ). The objective of this work is to rigorously derive some of these models as \Gamma -limits of three-dimensional nonlinear elasticity. We focus on elastic energy densities that are minimized on a finite number of copies of \SO(3) . This setting is relevant, for example, in the modeling of solid-solid phase transitions (see [ 4 ] ). To be more precise, we consider a thin cylinder \Omega_{h}=S\times(-\frac{h}{2},\frac{h}{2}) , where the mid-plane S is a subset of \mathbb{R}^{2} and h is the small thickness of the plate. Its elastic energy takes the form E_{h}(w_{h})=\int_{\Omega_{h}}W(\nabla w_{h})\,dx\,, (2) where w_{h}:\Omega_{h}\to\mathbb{R}^{3} is a deformation of \Omega_{h} and W is the elastic energy density. We suppose that W is minimized on the set K=\cup_{i=1}^{l}\SO(3)U_{i} , where U_{1},\dots,U_{l} are symmetric and positive-definite matrices. In this work, we study the \Gamma -limit of \frac{1}{h^{\alpha+1}}E_{h} , as h\to 0 , for \alpha\geq 2 . Roughly speaking, this corresponds to the analysis of deformations whose energy per unit volume V_{h}=h^{-1}E_{h} scales like h^{\alpha} . This problem has been extensively studied in the mathematical literature. The regime \alpha=0 , i.e., V_{h}\sim 1 , leads to the so-called membrane theory, rigorously derived for the first time by Le Dret and Raoult in [ 19 ] (see also [ 14 , 3 ] ). Here the hypotheses on W are compatible with a multi-well structure. The scaling 0<\alpha<2 is largely unexplored and only partial results are available (see [ 10 ] ). In the single-well setting (that is, l=1 and U_{1}=\Id ), the cases V_{h}\sim h^{\alpha} , where \alpha\geq 2 , have been studied by Friesecke, James, and Müller in [ 16 , 15 ] . When \alpha=2 , they retrieve the so-called Kirchhoff-Love theory, first proposed by Kirchhoff in [ 18 ] . When \alpha=4 , they obtain the Von Kármán model introduced in [ 25 ] , whereas in the case 2<\alpha<4 and \alpha>4 they derive the so-called constrained and linearized Von Kármán model, respectively. The key ingredient of all the latter results is the celebrated rigidity estimate proved by the same authors in [ 15 ] . Indeed, a quantitative understanding of the closeness of deformations gradients to the set of rotations is needed in order to rigorously linearize the energy density near the identity. Various extensions of the rigidity estimate are available in the multi-well case. For two strongly incompatible wells, the rigidity estimate has been proved by Chaudhuri and Müller in [ 6 ] (and later with a different proof by De Lellis and Székelyhidi in [ 12 ] ). In this setting the same authors also investigated the scaling \alpha=1 in [ 7 ] . A further generalization is given by Chermisi and Conti in [ 8 ] , for a finite number of well-separated wells. However, it is well-known that the rigidity estimate fails without separation assumptions on the wells. Indeed, if two of the wells are rank-one connected, it is easy to construct continuous deformations with zero elastic energy, whose gradient oscillates between the two wells. In the absence of a rigidity estimate, energy bounds fail to provide the necessary compactness for deformations. One possible way to overcome this issue is to singularly perturb the elastic energy by adding a higher order term of the form h^{-1}\eta^{p}(h)\int_{\Omega_{h}}|\nabla^{2}w_{h}|^{p}\,dx\,, (3) where \eta(h)\to 0 as h\to 0 and p>1 is a suitable exponent. This is a classical way of selecting preferred configurations in the Van der Waals–Cahn–Hilliard theory. Indeed, this additional term introduces a competition in the minimization problem: the free energy favors deformations with gradient in K , while the perturbation penalizes transitions between the wells. Various analyses have been carried out in this setting. In the membrane scaling \alpha=0 , a full description of the \Gamma -limit of the perturbed energy with p=2 is obtained in [ 13 , 11 ] . As in the non-perturbed case, the hypotheses on the energy density allow for W to have a multi-well structure. The expression of the \Gamma -limit depends on the behavior of \eta(h)/h . We also recall the work by Shu [ 23 ] , where an additional homogenization parameter is taken into account. In our work we focus on the regimes \alpha\geq 2 , and we do not assume any hypotheses of well-separation or connectedness of the wells. We follow ideas from Alicandro, Dal Maso, Lazzaroni, and Palombaro in [ 1 ] , where the linearization of a multi-well elastic energy is studied. We show that the perturbation coefficient \eta(h) can be chosen in such a way that, at the limit, deformation gradients are forced to fall into a single well and at the same time the (rescaled) perturbation term becomes negligible. Under these scaling assumptions on \eta(h) , in Section 3 we show that the L^{2} -norm of the distance of the deformation gradient from a specific well can be bounded by a suitable power of the perturbed elastic energy. In particular, once such a well has been identified, the usual rigidity estimate can be applied to deduce compactness. The hierarchy of plate models that we derive is similar to the one found in [ 16 , 15 ] for the single-well case. A key difference with respect to these works is the dependence of the limit models on the well around which we have to linearize. For \alpha=2 , we retrieve the Kirchhoff model (see Theorem 1.1 ). Sequences of deformations with V_{h}\sim h^{2} converge to isometric embeddings of the mid-plane into \mathbb{R}^{3} , for a flat metric depending on the well. The resulting model