Mapping network structures and dynamics of decentralised cryptocurrencies: The evolution of Bitcoin (2009-2023)
Marco Venturini, Daniel García-Costa, Elena Álvarez-García, Francisco Grimaldo, Flaminio Squazzoni · 2025
Read Mapping network structures and dynamics of decentralised cryptocurrencies: The evolution of Bitcoin (2009-2023) by Marco Venturini, Daniel García-Costa, Elena Álvarez-García, Francisco Grimaldo, Flaminio Squazzoni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11416.txt.
Introduction
Marco Venturini and co-authors reconstruct how Bitcoin's transaction network changed from its 2009 launch through 2023, in a 2025 paper. Public debate treats the currency as a new, flat economic infrastructure. The team mapped its network structure and dynamics across fifteen years to test that picture against the data.
They find centralization and wealth concentration rising from the earliest years through a richer-get-richer dynamic, driven from inside the system rather than by later outside forces. Three eras emerge: exploration, adaptation, and maturity, each with coherent network patterns. The authors warn that the crystallized power structure cuts against the system's decentralized promise.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marco Venturini, Daniel García-Costa, Elena Álvarez-García, Francisco Grimaldo, Flaminio Squazzoni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11416
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mapping network structures and dynamics of decentralised cryptocurrencies: The evolution of Bitcoin (2009-2023) Marco Venturini, Daniel García-Costa, Elena Álvarez-García, Francisco Grimaldo, Flaminio Squazzoni Abstract Cryptocurrencies have recently been in the spotlight of public debate due to their embrace by the new US President, with crypto fans expecting a ’bull run’. The global cryptocurrency market capitalisation is more than $3.50 trillion, with 1 Bitcoin exchanging for more than $97,000 at the end of November 2024. Monitoring the evolution of these systems is key to understanding whether the popular perception of cryptocurrencies as a new, sustainable economic infrastructure is well-founded. In this paper, we have reconstructed the network structures and dynamics of Bitcoin from its launch in January 2009 to December 2023 and identified its key evolutionary phases. Our results show that network centralisation and wealth concentration increased from the very early years, following a richer-get-richer mechanism. This trend was endogenous to the system, beyond any subsequent institutional or exogenous influence. The evolution of Bitcoin is characterised by three periods, Exploration , Adaptation and Maturity , with substantial coherent network patterns. Our findings suggest that Bitcoin is a highly centralised structure, with high levels of wealth inequality and internally crystallised power dynamics, which may have negative implications for its long-term sustainability. I Introduction Introduced by Satoshi Nakamoto in 2008 [ 1 ] , Bitcoin is now worth $1.5 trillion with a daily exchange volume of $67 billion [ 2 ] , excluding derivatives. In total, the entire cryptocurrency world has a market capitalisation of around $3.50 trillion. The world’s largest asset management firm, BlackRock, launched a spot Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) replicating Bitcoin in January 2024, soon followed by other institutional players. By 6 November 2024, this ETF had a daily exchange volume of $97 billion [ 3 ] . The number of crypto users worldwide is estimated to be around 620 million in 2024, rising to 800 million in 2025 [ 4 ] , Bitcoin transactions per day are at their highest level ever, and 1 Bitcoin is exchanged for more than $97,000 by the end of November 2024. While Bitcoin is increasingly present in the portfolios of retail investors, it has also recently been at the centre of the electoral campaign for the 2024 US presidential election, with the newly elected president promising to make the United States the “crypto capital of the world”. On the day of Trump’s victory, the price of Bitcoin jumped from $69,500 to around $76,000, thus marking an all-time high price. This shows that Bitcoin is no longer a niche product of a group of idealistic “hippies”, but is part of a wider political agenda and is being included in financial institutions’ derivative products and in portfolio investing strategies. However, Bitcoin is a multi-faceted, complex system where different entities and instances coexist, from exchanges and financial institutions to retail and fraudulent users. For instance, Bitcoin has been instrumental in the creation of SilkRoad, a dark market founded in 2011 and shut down by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) in October 2013, but also of regulated exchanges such as Coinbase, a secure online platform for buying, selling, transferring and storing cryptocurrencies, now listed on the NASDAQ with a market capitalisation of $77 billion. Beyond these bright and dark sides, the secret of Bitcoin’s success is that it allows anonymous peer-to-peer transactions without any intermediary, relying solely on its decentralised consensus protocol [ 5 ] . The Bitcoin transaction network consists of several elements: addresses, transactions and blocks. The recipient of a transaction is an address identified by its public key, a univoque alphanumeric sequence. An address can only send what it has previously received: this is known as the UTXO, Unspent Transaction Output, which characterises Bitcoin. Transactions, in turn, are defined as the transfer of tokens from one address to another ( peer-to-peer ); once confirmed, they are broadcast to the network [ 6 ] and collected into new blocks by miners who compete to solve a cryptographic puzzle [ 7 ] to add the candidate block to the blockchain. This process, known as “proof-of-work,“ selects miners based on their computational effort [ 8 ] . Understanding the complexity of this new type of economic exchange infrastructure requires a detailed study of a complex transaction network, made up of different components that interact in non-trivial way. This challenge has attracted many computational scientists, with studies of the transaction network of Bitcoin since its early years [ 9 , 10 ] . Unfortunately, the research has been hampered by a limited timescale of observation. For instance, [ 8 ] analysed the evolution of the Bitcoin transaction network and tested the rich-get-richer mechanism using data until December 2015. Similarly, in [ 11 ] , the authors built a longitudinal dataset of the Bitcoin network to study its structural changes over time, but relied on data only up to September 2014. A notable exception is [ 12 ] , in which the authors used data up to May 2020 to provide a comprehensive analysis of Bitcoin network dynamics from January 2009 to the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic. Furthermore, these studies have tended to focus on specific Bitcoin aspects to capture its network properties, such as looking at degree distributions, power laws or preferential attachment, rather than attempting a comprehensive analysis of its network formation, dynamics and evolution. Finally, while previous research has considered a longitudinal perspective to capture network dynamics, it has ignored the impact of certain important exogenous factors, such as law enforcement and public interest, with the exception of [ 13 ] , which linked the prevalence of business entities in the network to the Bitcoin external evolution and perception of Bitcoin, from a prototype to a “sin” phase towards legitimate business. Our study aims to contribute to the computational literature on Bitcoin, and cryptocurrencies in general, by extending the dataset timeframe, using multiple measures, and investigating the network dynamics by identifying different evolutionary stages. First, we used a dataset updated to the latest available year (2023) and adopted a systemic approach, i.e. a large number of measures, to fully characterise the Bitcoin transaction network. We then mapped Bitcoin’s network properties over 14 years, focusing in particular on centralisation and concentration trends, significantly extending all previous research time windows. We took a longitudinal approach with annual snapshots of the network and examined the system dynamics. We also tested for the rich-get-richer phenomenon, allowing us to assess whether the centralisation and concentration trends are due to the increasing presence of institutional investors or to the endogenous growth dynamics of Bitcoin since its early stages. Furthermore, we confirmed previous findings on disassortative and clustering tendencies, while also investigating the network connected components and their composition. Finally, we identified three periods in the evolution of Bitcoin: the Exploration , Adaptation and Maturity phases. Our study had three objectives. First, we analysed the entire transaction network of Bitcoin. Second, we studied the dynamics of centralisation and concentration by considering the multiple tensions between the presence of institutional actors and the endogenous force of wealth accumulation typical of financial markets. Third, by combining our data with Bitcoin-related events, we reconstructed the evolution of the system by identifying its different