Linear ADRC is equivalent to PID with set-point weighting and measurement filter

Fredrik Bagge Carlson, JuliaHub Inc · 2025

Read Linear ADRC is equivalent to PID with set-point weighting and measurement filter by Fredrik Bagge Carlson, JuliaHub Inc (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-11374.txt.

Introduction

Fredrik Bagge Carlson shows in 2025 that two ways of steering machines are, in the linear case, the same method in different dress. One is a newer method that watches for and cancels pushes on a system. The other is the classic PID controller found in plants and labs worldwide.

Carlson proves the match when the newer method is tuned by its standard band rule, with two tweaks on the classic side. One tweak weights the target value, and the other smooths the measured signal. He then gives plain formulas to run the newer method as a standard PID for simple first and second order systems. The result lets engineers use gear and code they already trust, rather than learning a new stack to get the same response.

Catalog record

CREATORFredrik Bagge Carlson, JuliaHub Inc
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-11374

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Linear ADRC is equivalent to PID with set-point weighting and measurement filter Fredrik Bagge Carlson, JuliaHub Inc Abstract We show that linear Active Disturbance-Rejection Control (ADRC) tuned using the ”bandwidth method” is equivalent to PI(D) control with set-point weighting and a lowpass filter on the measurement signal. We also provide simple expressions that make it possible to implement linear ADRC for first and second-order systems using commonplace two degree-of-freedom PID implementations. The expressions are equivalent to ADRC in the response from measurements, and a slight approximation in the response from references. I Introduction Active Disturbance-Rejection Control (ADRC) is often touted as a promising improvement over the PID controller as the goto tool for practitioners. In [ 1 ] , the author point out that ADRC, in particular linear ADRC, is a new name for the well-established method of using state feedback with state estimates provided by an observer augmented with a disturbance model. Linear ADRC makes the particular choice of an integrating disturbance model acting on the plant input. The author of [ 1 ] compares linear ADRC, tuned using the ”bandwidth method” [ 2 ] , to PI and PID controllers tuned to a particular response to a reference step. The conclusion that is drawn is that ADRC is generally more robust and performs overall better than the PI and PID controllers. In this paper, we show that linear ADRC tuned with the bandwidth method is in fact equivalent to a commonplace implementation of a PID controller. For first-order systems , the controller response to measurements is equivalent to a PI controller with a first-order filter on the measurement signal, and the response to references is a filtered PID controller. With very minor approximation error, the complete two degree-of-freedom 1 1 1 Two inputs r and y with different response to each input. controller can be represented as a single PI controller with set-point weighting and a first-order lowpass filter on the measurement, a very convenient conclusion considering how commonplace this particular implementation of a PI controller is. For second-order systems , with a similar minor approximation (in reference response only, no approximation is made in the response from measurements), the linear ADRC controller is equivalent to a PID controller with set-point weighting and a second-order lowpass filter on measurements. Once again, a very convenient conclusion considering the ubiquity of this particular implementation. Linear ADRC can thus be ”implemented” by simply tuning a PI(D) controller with gains derived from the ADRC tuning parameters, and we can view linear ADRC as new PID ”tuning rule”. II Technical Details We will follow the notation used in [ 1 ] for first-order systems, that considers an ADRC controller on the following form \displaystyle\begin{bmatrix}\dot{\hat{x}}_{1}\\ \dot{\hat{x}}_{2}\end{bmatrix} \displaystyle=\begin{bmatrix}-l_{1}&1\\ -l_{2}&0\end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix}\hat{x}_{1}\\ \hat{x}_{2}\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}b_{0}\\ 0\end{bmatrix}u+\begin{bmatrix}l_{1}\\ l_{2}\end{bmatrix}y (1) \displaystyle u \displaystyle=\dfrac{-K_{P}(r-y)-\hat{f}}{b_{0}}=\dfrac{-K_{P}(r-\hat{x}_{1})-\hat{x}_{2}}{b_{0}} (2) where the state-space system represents the disturbance observer, r is the reference signal, y is the measurement signal, u is the control signal, and \hat{f} is the estimated disturbance input. The tuning parameters are the observer parameters l_{1} , l_{2} , and K_{P} , and these are set using rules that require the user to pick a desired settling time T_{s} and the characteristic gain of the plant, b_{0} . The plant is assumed to be on the form P(s)=\dfrac{K}{Ts+1} which gives b_{0}=K/T . The parameters as dictated by the bandwidth tuning rule are selected as \displaystyle K_{P}=\dfrac{4}{T_{s}}\quad l_{1}=-2gK_{P}\quad l_{2}=g^{2}K_{P}^{2} (3) where g is a multiplier that determines how much faster the observer poles are compared to the closed-loop poles associated with the plant. In the experiment section for first-order systems in [ 1 ] , T_{s}=1 , g=10,K=T=1 are used. For deeper technical details and the formulation for second-order systems, we refer the reader to [ 1 ] . II-A First-order linear ADRC and PID II-A 1 Transfer functions When represented as a transfer function, the ADRC controller detailed above can be written as 2 2 2 We omit the parameter b_{0} here for brevity. It scales the controller gain proportionally and is thus straightforward to incorporate by scaling the resulting controller by 1/b_{0} . The when the equivalent PI(D) parameters are stated, we include b_{0} for completeness. \displaystyle C_{ADRC}(s)=\begin{bmatrix}C_{r}(s)&-C_{y}(s)\end{bmatrix} (4) \displaystyle C_{r}(s)=\dfrac{4T_{s}^{2}s^{2}+32T_{s}gs+64g^{2}}{s(T_{s}^{3}s+T_{s}^{2}(8g+4))} (5) \displaystyle C_{y}(s)=\dfrac{32T_{s}gs+(16T_{s}+64)g^{2}}{s(T_{s}^{3}s+T_{s}^{2}(8g+4))} (6) Compare C_{y}(s) to the transfer function of a PI controller with lowpass filter (PI+F) C_{PIF}=\big(k_{p}+k_{i}/s\big)\dfrac{1}{T_{f}s+1}=\dfrac{k_{p}s+k_{i}}{s(T_{f}s+1)} it becomes clear that we can pick k_{p},k_{i},T_{f} so that the PI controller becomes identical to the feedback part of the ADRC controller, C_{y} (including the above omitted parameter b_{0} ): \displaystyle k_{p} \displaystyle=\dfrac{4g^{2}+8g}{b_{0}T_{s}(2g+1)} (7) \displaystyle k_{i} \displaystyle=\dfrac{16g^{2}}{b_{0}T_{s}^{2}(2g+1)} (8) \displaystyle T_{f} \displaystyle=\dfrac{T_{s}}{8g+4} (9) The feedforward part, C_{r} , can similarly be shown to be equivalent to a first-order filtered PID controller, but more interestingly, we can approximate C_{r} as -C_{y} with set-point weighting on the proportional term, but without the lowpass filter. To do this, we introduce the 2DOF PI controller K_{ry} with set-point weight b , defined by the transfer function between r,y and u in the expression K_{ry}(s):u=k_{p}(br-y)+k_{i}(r-y)\frac{1}{s} with the set-point weight b=K_{P}/(b_{0}k_{p}) where K_{P} is the proportional gain in the ADRC controller. k_{p} is the proportional gain in the equivalent PID controller obtained by matching C_{y} to C_{PIF} . With this choice of b , the feedforward part of the 2DOF PI controller will have the following low and high-frequency asymptotes: \displaystyle|s| \displaystyle\to 0: \displaystyle\quad sC_{r}(s) \displaystyle\to\dfrac{16g^{2}}{T_{s}^{2}(2g+1)}=k_{i} (10) \displaystyle|s| \displaystyle\to 0: \displaystyle\quad sK_{ry}(s) \displaystyle\to k_{i} (11) where we can identify that K_{ry}\to C_{r} as |s|\to 0 . In the other direction, we have \displaystyle|s| \displaystyle\to\infty: \displaystyle\quad C_{r}(s) \displaystyle\to\dfrac{4}{T_{s}}=K_{P} (12) \displaystyle|s| \displaystyle\to\infty: \displaystyle\quad K_{ry}(s) \displaystyle\to bk_{p}=\frac{K_{P}}{k_{p}}=K_{P} (13) We thus have the same gain from r to u through K_{ry} as we have through the ADRC controller C_{r} as |s|\to 0 and as |s|\to\infty , with a small discrepancy around the crossover frequency. 3 3 3 Due to the difference in the proportional term in the Bode curves demonstrating this will be shown for the example provided in [ 1 ] in section III . II-A 2 State-space realization of equivalent PIF controller For convenience, we also include a statespace realization of the proposed equivalent 2DOF PIF controller (with the approximation of C_{r} ): \displaystyle\dot{x} \displaystyle=\left[\begin{matrix}0&-\frac{k_{i}}{T_{f}}\\ 0&-\frac{1}{T_{f}}\end{matrix}\right]x+\left[\begin{matrix}k_{i}&0\\ 0&1\end{matrix}\right]\begin{bmatrix}r\\ y\end{bmatrix} \displaystyle u \displaystyle=\left[\begin{matrix}1&-\frac{k_{p}}{T_{f}}\end{matrix}\right]x+\left[\begin{matrix}bk_{p}&0\end{matrix}\right]\begin{bmatrix}r\\ y\end{bmatrix} with inputs [r,y] and output u . II-B Second-Order Linear ADRC In a similar fashion we can establish equivalence between the second-order linear ADRC controller and a PID controller with set-point weighting and a second-order lowpass filter on the measurement signal, given by the transfer function between r,y and u in the expression: \displaystyle K_{PIDF}(s) \displaystyle:u=k_{p}(br-y_{f})+(r-y_{f})\frac{k_{i}}{s}-y_{f}k_{d}s (14) \displaystyle y_{f} \displaystyle=\dfrac{1}{T_{f}^{2}s^{2}+2T_{f}ds+1}y (15) where d is a relative damping parameter of the filter and T_{f} is the time constant of the filter. Note that the reference r does not appear in the derivative part, the set-point weight in the derivative term is zero, while b generally is not. The expressions for k_{p},k_{i},k_{d},T_{f},d are more complicated than for the first-order case, but can be derived by matching the transfer function of the ADRC controller to the transfer function of the PID controller in a similar fashion. The expressions are provided in the appendix, and the source code used to symbolically solve for them is provided in [ 3 ] . III Numerical Comparisons This

Read the complete text