The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation II: Stellar Mass Models
Francis Duey, James Schombert, Stacy McGaugh, Federico Lelli · 2025
Read The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation II: Stellar Mass Models by Francis Duey, James Schombert, Stacy McGaugh, Federico Lelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10919.txt.
Introduction
Francis Duey, James Schombert, Stacy McGaugh, and Federico Lelli refine how, in a 2025 preprint, astronomers turn galaxy light into stellar mass. The work supports the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation, which links a galaxy's mass to its spin speed. Stellar mass comes from near-infrared light times a mass-to-light ratio. That ratio depends on the galaxy's star-forming past, so it must be modeled with care. The team uses data from the WISE space telescope's main band.
They test many star formation histories and chemical paths to bound the ratio's uncertainty. The largest doubts, about a tenth of a dex, hit blue galaxies with bursty recent star birth. For heavy galaxies, splitting bulge from disk matters most, since the parts need different ratios. Their masses agree closely with estimates from another telescope's infrared band and from optical studies. Near-infrared light, they argue, remains the best mass tracer.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francis Duey, James Schombert, Stacy McGaugh, Federico Lelli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10919
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation II: Stellar Mass Models Francis Duey, James Schombert, Stacy McGaugh, Federico Lelli Abstract We present new color- Υ ∗ \Upsilon_{*} (mass-to-light) models to convert WISE W1 fluxes into stellar masses. We outline a range of possible star formation histories and chemical evolution scenarios to explore the confidence limits of stellar population models on the value of Υ ∗ \Upsilon_{*} . We conclude that the greatest uncertainties (around 0.1 dex in Υ ∗ \Upsilon_{*} ) occur for the bluest galaxies with the strongest variation in recent star formation. For high mass galaxies, the greatest uncertainty arises from the proper treatment of bulge/disk separation in which to apply different Υ ∗ \Upsilon_{*} relations appropriate for those differing underlying stellar populations. We compare our deduced stellar masses with those deduced from Spitzer 3.6 μ \mu m fluxes and stellar mass estimates in the literature using optical photometry and different Υ ∗ \Upsilon_{*} modeling. We find the correspondence to be excellent, arguing that rest-frame near-IR photometry is still more advantageous than other wavelengths. I Introduction The conversion of stellar luminosity into stellar mass is the keystone to understanding the total baryonic mass of a galaxy (Tinsley 1968) and its mass distribution (Ibarra-Medel et al. 2015). In addition, the stellar mass of a galaxy is the primary output of its star formation history, the conversion of neutral gas into stars, and the defining characteristic for the evolution of a galaxy (Speagle et al. 2014). The production, or lack of production, of stars defines a galaxy’s morphology (Cassata et al. 2007), color evolution (Rakos & Schombert 1995) and metallicity evolution (Baker & Maiolino 2023). Whether the growth of stellar mass happens in a monolithic (Eggen, Lynden-Bell & Sandage 1962) or hierarchical fashion (Treu et al. 2005), our understanding of the baryon cycle begins with a galaxy’s current stellar mass. The path to determining stellar mass begins with photometry, as the luminosity of a galaxy is simply a proxy for the number of stars. The photometry of galaxies has a long history (Roth 2023) stretching from uncalibrated photographic imaging through the era of photoelectric photometry that produced catalogs such as the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991) to the present-day digital sky surveys from the ground (e.g., SDSS, Consolandi et al. 2016) and space (e.g., WISE, Wright et al. 2010). However, even for an isolated galaxy with few nearby stellar sources, the determination of an accurate flux (total or by area, i.e. surface photometry) is an observational challenge (Hogg 2022). An additional dilemma arises with any attempt to extract a true bolometric flux from photometric magnitudes without some knowledge of the total energy flux emitted across all wavelengths (Brown et al. 2014). As noted by Taylor et al. (2011), almost all the characteristics of a galaxy, including its morphological appearance, vary sharply during the course of its evolution. Detailed analysis of the color-magnitude diagrams of stellar populations in nearby galaxies (Weisz et al. 2011) shows that the star formation history of a galaxy may change dramatically, often on short timescales, along with its color and mean parameters such as stellar population age and metallicity. The global properties of galaxies, including their kinematics, are well correlated with their total stellar masses, regardless of their suspected paths of galaxy evolution (see Strateva et al. 2001 and Gallazzi et al. 2006). The exploration of these stellar mass scaling relations back to the era of galaxy formation is a primary science goal of the recently launched James Webb Space Telescope (Dressler et al. 2023). The process of converting galaxy fluxes into stellar mass requires interpretation with a stellar population model. These models take a unit amount of gas mass and an initial mass function, plus an assumed star formation history and chemical enrichment scenario, and combine these functions with known stellar isochrones to produce a mean mass-to-light ratio (hereafter \Upsilon_{*} ). The effects of age and metallicity on the \Upsilon_{*} of stellar populations are obvious from even the simplest star formation scenarios. For example, a young stellar population rich in high mass O-stars will have a particularly low \Upsilon_{*} due to the enormous luminosity of O-stars as compared to an old stellar population dominated by lower luminosity red giant branch stars, which will drive \Upsilon_{*} to higher values (Tinsley 1978). At the core of these population models are the simple stellar populations (SSP), stellar groups of single age and metallicity (Bruzual 1993). While the colors and spectral energy distributions (SED) of SSP’s are well matched to the observations of compact systems, such as globular clusters, they fail to adequately match the colors of normal galaxies due to the complex mixing of many populations of different ages and metallicities (Tinsley 1980). A real, present-day galaxy will have a stellar population that evolved over time in two basic ways, 1) a changing star formation rate (the star formation history, SFH) plus 2) a growing mean metallicity as previous generations have enriched the ISM from which the next generation of stars form (chemical evolution). Basic composite stellar populations (CSP), ones which are linear combinations of SSP’s, produce high quality matches to the color and spectroscopic characteristics of normal galaxies (Bell et al. 2003, Gallazzi et al. 2005) and provide a testable pathway to mapping \Upsilon_{*} onto observables such as morphological type or mean color (Walcher et al. 2011, Schombert, McGaugh & Lelli 2022). An additional level of accuracy is obtained when CSP models are matched to the galaxy observables such as a full SED, various spectral indices or widely spaced colors to limit the range of properties of the underlying stars. Each technique has its various strengths and inherent uncertainties. For example, one of the finest analysis comparing synthetic SED’s to multiband photometry is the GAMA project (Driver et al. 2009) outlined in detail in Taylor et al. (2011). Their technique of fitting the flux in nine bandpasses from the UV to the near-IR produces uncertainties in stellar mass of only 0.12 dex (28%). While they conclude that the addition of mid-IR fluxes adds additional uncertainty, probably due to the luminosity changes induced by short-lived asymptotic giant branch stars (AGB), they found acceptable errors when just using SDSS fluxes and a g-i color relation to deduce a \Upsilon_{*} . This is the second paper our series to study of one of the key galaxy scaling relations, the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation. We have dedicated this paper to the construction of an observational technique for the conversion from flux densities (centered on the WISE mission photometric archives) to stellar mass which, when combined with the gas mass, becomes the total baryonic mass of a galaxy. Our first paper in this series (Duey et al. 2024) outlined our procedures and protocols for using WISE and Spitzer imaging to assign a total galaxy luminosity. The goal of this paper is to 1) introduce new mass-to-light models for the WISE filters, 2) compare these models to Spitzer and SDSS stellar masses and 3) map the resulting luminosity TF relation into the stellar mass TF, popular in distance scale studies (Tully et al. 2009). The third paper in this series will be to take the baryon masses deduced in Papers 1 and 2, combined with redshift