Computational Discovery of Chiasmus in Ancient Religious Text

Hope McGovern Hale Sirin Tom Lippincott · 2025

Read Computational Discovery of Chiasmus in Ancient Religious Text by Hope McGovern Hale Sirin Tom Lippincott (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10739.txt.

Introduction

Ancient scripture sometimes folds a passage back on itself in mirror order, a device called chiasmus whose reality scholars still debate. Hope McGovern, Hale Sirin, and Tom Lippincott hunt it by computer in this 2025 paper. Their method is the first systematic computational approach to the problem. Neural embeddings score the echoes between phrases.

The search runs at two scales, whole verses and half-verses. Expert annotators reviewed a sample of the finds. Agreement among experts ran high, and the system's top hits proved precise — about four in five at verse level. Patterns of where chiasmi cluster were also charted. Computation cannot settle the literary debate, but it gives it evidence at scale.

Catalog record

CREATORHope McGovern Hale Sirin Tom Lippincott
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10739

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Computational Discovery of Chiasmus in Ancient Religious Text Hope McGovern Hale Sirin Tom Lippincott Abstract Chiasmus, a debated literary device in Biblical texts, has captivated mystics while sparking ongoing scholarly discussion. In this paper, we introduce the first computational approach to systematically detect chiasmus within Biblical passages. Our method leverages neural embeddings to capture lexical and semantic patterns associated with chiasmus, applied at multiple levels of textual granularity (half-verses, verses). We also involve expert annotators to review a subset of the detected patterns. Despite its computational efficiency, our method achieves robust results, with high inter-annotator agreement and system precision@ k k of 0.80 at the verse level and 0.60 at the half-verse level. We further provide a qualitative analysis of the distribution of detected chiasmi, along with selected examples that highlight the effectiveness of our approach. 1 1 1 All code and data available at https://github.com/comp-int-hum/literary-translation 1 Introduction Chiasmus is a topic which fascinates Bible scholars. Most simply and broadly understood, chiasmus , or chiasm, denotes a sequence of textual units that intentionally exhibit a semantic or poetic symmetry. A clear chiastic example in English is JFK’s adage (with corresponding textual units in the same color): Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country. The name derives from the Greek letter \chi , ‘chi’, which looks like an English ‘X’ and is used to illustrate the structure of a chiasmus: e.g. ABB’A’, as shown in Table 1 . Chiasmi may be even or odd (i.e. having an unpaired distinct center), and may have an arbitrary number of lines. While chiasmus in English is associated with high oratory skill Bothwell et al. 2023 , it is exceedingly rare as a rhetorical device in modern language: English experts trawling through a corpus of Winston Churchill’s works found only seven chiasmi out of a total of \sim 200 speeches Dubremetz and Nivre 2015 . However, chiasmus is extremely common in ancient literature and oratory Welch 1981 . It has been known to be a common rhetorical feature of Ancient Hebrew poetry since the 1740s Lowth 1839 . A […] Let them be turned back and disappointed who devise evil against me! B Let them be like chaff before the wind, with the angel of the LORD driving them away! B’ Let their way be dark and slippery, with the angel of the LORD pursuing them! A’ For without cause they hid their net for me; without cause they dug a pit for my life. Table 1: The ‘X’ pattern of chiasm in Psalm 35:4-7 (ESV). Pairs (A, A’) and (B, B’) exhibit repeated phrases and conceptual links. While most scholars agree that chiasmus is a facet of Ancient Near Eastern writings, there is much debate about its prevalence, purpose, and location. Biblical scholars have proposed its use to underscore characterization in narrative passages Assis 2002 , as a poetic device in the Psalms Martin 2018 , and to capture ritualistic language in legal documents McCoy 2003 . However, a lack of quantitative methods for Biblical chiasmus renders the task of detection a laborious and subjective one. We provide a straightforward method to computationally formalize and detect chiasmi. Unlike previous work which utilized handcrafted features and a log-linear model to detect fine-grained instances of chiasmus in English prose Dubremetz and Nivre 2017 , we use a statistical method based on cosine distance from line-level embedded representations of text. The use of embeddings instead of only lemmata allows us to include semantic information between lines that form a chiastic structure, enabling a more nuanced definition of chiasmus in line with rhetorical intention. This approach is supported by recent work in rhetorical device detection Schneider et al. 2021 , and includes the repetition of words, phrases, grammatical structures, or (identical or antithetical) concepts as part of the chiastic parallels. In contrast with Schneider et al. 2021 , our method is extensible to various sizes of chiasmus; that is, those of just four lines long or of 100 lines long, and is language-agnostic, whereas previous work has focused only on fine-grained, intra-line chiasmus in English or German. In this study, we analyze both half-verses and verses as units so that a chiasmus within the same verse can also be captured (i.e. “The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath”). We formalize the notion of Biblical chiasmus thoroughly in section 2.2 . Our main contributions are as follows: 1. We show that multilingual embedding spaces may be effectively used to detect rhetorical phenomena such as chiasmus in ancient manuscripts. 2. We provide, for the first time, a mathematical formalism of Biblical chiasmus and provide a computational algorithm for its detection. 3. Our method is computationally efficient and achieves robust results, with high inter-annotator agreement and system precision@ k of 0.80 at the verse level and 0.60 at the half-verse level. 4. We contribute to Classics and Biblical Studies by providing a qualitative analysis of the distribution of detected chiasmi, along with selected examples that highlight the effectiveness of our approach. 2 Method 2.1 Data We use as our primary source the Translator’s Amalgamated Hebrew Old Testament (TAHOT) 2 2 2 www.STEPBible.org , which is based on the Leningrad Codex – the oldest complete extant version of the Hebrew Old Testament. Note that modern English translations follow a versification system that is at times slightly different to the Hebrew text due to a difference in textual traditions. We use the Hebrew versification system to better uncover chiasmi as they may be in the original text. N.B. We carry out all detection experiments using the Hebrew text, but for clarity and accessibility, report English translations 3 3 3 We release a formatted version of STEP Bible’s data, including translations, on the Huggingface Hub. DOI: 10.57967/hf/4174 . in tables and figures. We segment the text into two levels: verses and half-verses. In the Hebrew text, half-verses are naturally marked by the cantillation symbol, atnach , which typically separates the two halves of a verse. We consider up to and including the word with the atnach to be the first half, while the remainder is the second half. We then remove all vocalizations and cantillation symbols before embedding. 2.2 Formalizing Chiasmus The first step in our method involves constructing a cosine similarity matrix, denoted as S , based on feature vectors extracted from the text via E5, a multilingual embedding model Wang et al. 2024 4 4 4 We use the ‘small’ variant of this model, with 118M parameters. . Our method is similar to that of Burns et al. 2021 , which uses pairwise cosine similarity of embedded representations to identify intertextual phrases in Latin. Each element S_{ij} represents the cosine similarity between the feature vectors of textual units i and j . Next, we identify potential chiastic structures by focusing on matching groups of text pairs, such as A and A^{\prime} , B and B^{\prime} , and so forth. For each potential chiastic structure, we compute the chiasmus score \mu_{\text{chiasmus}} , which is the average cosine similarity of these matching pairs: \mu_{\text{chiasmus}}=\frac{1}{k}\sum_{i=1}^{k}S_{\text{pair}(i)} (1) where \text{pair}(i) refers to the indices of the matching pairs (e.g., A and A^{\prime} ,

Read the complete text