Thermalization in Quantum Fluids of Light: A Convection-Diffusion Equation

Vladislav Yu. Shishkov, Ivan V. Panyukov, Evgeny S. Andrianov, Anton V. Zasedatelev · 2025

Read Thermalization in Quantum Fluids of Light: A Convection-Diffusion Equation by Vladislav Yu. Shishkov, Ivan V. Panyukov, Evgeny S. Andrianov, Anton V. Zasedatelev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10537.txt.

Introduction

Vladislav Shishkov and co-authors build a microscopic theory of how quantum fluids of light settle toward thermal balance. Their math lands on a convection-diffusion equation in momentum space, a form borrowed from fluid flow. For flat systems with a parabolic energy curve, it shrinks to the Bateman-Burgers equation.

The fluid analogy joins shock wave formation and turbulence with the condensation of photons and polaritons in optical cavities. A Reynolds number is defined for the light fluid. The condensation threshold lands exactly at a Reynolds number of one. Past that point, a shock like front forms in momentum space, with the high momentum states taking the classic Bose-Einstein spread.

Catalog record

CREATORVladislav Yu. Shishkov, Ivan V. Panyukov, Evgeny S. Andrianov, Anton V. Zasedatelev
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10537

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Thermalization in Quantum Fluids of Light: A Convection-Diffusion Equation Preprint: APS/123-QED Vladislav Yu. Shishkov, Ivan V. Panyukov, Evgeny S. Andrianov, Anton V. Zasedatelev Abstract We develop a microscopic theory for the dynamics of quantum fluids of light, deriving an effective kinetic equation in momentum space that takes the form of the convection-diffusion equation. In the particular case of two-dimensional systems with parabolic dispersion, it reduces to the Bateman–Burgers equation. The hydrodynamic analogy unifies nonlinear wave phenomena, such as shock wave formation and turbulence, with non-equilibrium Bose–Einstein condensation of photons and polaritons in optical cavities. We introduce the Reynolds number ( Re ) (\textit{Re}) and demonstrate that the condensation threshold corresponds exactly to a critical Reynolds number of unity ( Re = 1 ) (\textit{Re}=1) , beyond which ( Re > 1 ) (\textit{Re}>1) a shock-like front emerges in the momentum space, characterized by the Bose–Einstein distribution for the particle density in states with high momentum. I Introduction Quantum fluids of light exhibit remarkable collective behaviors driven by nonlinear interactions between photons or polaritons, giving rise to a diverse array of hydrodynamical phenomena Carusotto and Ciuti 2013 . Thermalization of the particles is a crucial process in the formation of light-matter Bose–Einstein condensates (BECs) Kirton and Keeling 2013 ; Kirton and Keeling 2015 ; Schmitt et al. 2015 . In optical cavities, this process depends on the absorption and emission of photons by dye molecules within the cavity. In this case, the rate of energy exchange between the cavity photons and the molecules, as well as their vibrational properties, significantly impacts the efficiency of thermalization. In this study, we develop an effective equation that describes the kinetics of particles over momentum space, resembling the Bateman–Burgers equation Whitham 2011 ; Orlandi 2000 known from fluid dynamics. We introduce the concept of the Reynolds number (\textit{Re}) for the two-dimensional Bose gas and show that the critical value of this number (\textit{Re}=1) not only marks the onset of significant nonlinear dynamics, but also coincides with the threshold for Bose–Einstein condensation. II Kinetics of the Bose gas The dynamics of the average number of particles, n_{\bf k}(t) , with momentum \bf k is governed by three processes: thermalization, dissipation with the rate \gamma_{\bf k} , and incoherent pumping with the rate \varkappa_{\bf k}(t) which may depend on time. Generally, the kinetics of the Bose gas can be described by the Maxwell–Boltzmann equation Deng et al. 2010 . \frac{\partial n_{\bf k}(t)}{\partial t}=-\gamma_{\bf k}n_{\bf k}(t)+\sum_{\bf k^{\prime}}\left[\gamma_{\rm therm}^{\bf kk^{\prime}}\left(n_{\bf k}(t)+1\right)n_{\bf k^{\prime}}(t)-\right.\\ \left.\gamma_{\rm therm}^{\bf k^{\prime}k}\left(n_{\bf k^{\prime}}(t)+1\right)n_{\bf k}(t)\right]+\varkappa_{\bf k}(t), (1) An important property of the particles affecting their kinetics is their dispersion, \omega_{\bf k} , that establishes the connection between the momentum of the particle, \hbar{\bf k} , and its energy, \hbar\omega_{\bf k} . We assume that (1) the system is isotropic, that is, the energy of the particles and the dissipation rate depend only on the absolute value of the momentum, k , i.e. \hbar\omega_{\bf k}=\hbar\omega_{k} and \gamma_{\bf k}=\gamma_{k} ; (2) \omega_{k} increases monotonically with k . These assumptions are relevant for most experiments on Bose–Einstein condensation. Thermalization part of the equation causes the redistribution of the particles in the momentum space and preserves the total number of particles \sum_{\bf k}n_{\bf k}(t) . Indeed, from ( 1 ) it follows \frac{d}{dt}\sum_{\bf k}n_{\bf k}(t)=-\sum_{\bf k}\gamma_{\bf k}n_{\bf k}(t)+\sum_{\bf k}\varkappa_{\bf k}(t). (2) Regarding the thermalization process, we assume that (1) the thermalization rate is zero between the states separated by the energies over \hbar\omega_{M} , i.e. \gamma_{\rm therm}^{{\bf k}_{1}{\bf k}_{2}}=0 for |\omega_{k_{1}}-\omega_{k_{2}}|>\omega_{M} ; (2) the thermalization rate depends only on the difference between the energies of the states such that \gamma_{\rm therm}^{{\bf k}_{1}{\bf k}_{2}}=\gamma_{\rm therm}^{{k}_{1}{k}_{2}}=\Gamma\left(1+n_{\rm th}(\omega_{k_{2}}-\omega_{k_{1}})\right)\\ \text{for}\;\;|\omega_{k_{1}}-\omega_{k_{2}}|<\omega_{M}\;\text{and}\;\omega_{k_{1}}<\omega_{k_{2}}, (3) and \gamma_{\rm therm}^{{\bf k}_{1}{\bf k}_{2}}=\gamma_{\rm therm}^{{k}_{1}{k}_{2}}=\Gamma n_{\rm th}(\omega_{k_{1}}-\omega_{k_{2}})\\ \text{for}\;\;|\omega_{k_{1}}-\omega_{k_{2}}|<\omega_{M}\;\text{and}\;\omega_{k_{2}}<\omega_{k_{1}}, (4) where \Gamma is a constant rate, n_{\rm th}(\Delta\omega)=(e^{\hbar\Delta\omega/k_{B}T}-1)^{-1} , T is the temperature of the environment, and k_{B} is the Boltzmann constant. These assumptions are consistent with the Kubo–Martin–Schwinger relation Kubo 1957 , \gamma_{\rm therm}^{{\bf k}_{1}{\bf k}_{2}}=\gamma_{\rm therm}^{{\bf k}_{2}{\bf k}_{1}}e^{-(\hbar\omega_{{\bf k}_{1}}-\hbar\omega_{{\bf k}_{2}})/k_{B}T} . The momentum \bf k in Eq. ( 1 ) are discrete, and their manifold is determined by the size of the system. We make a transition from the discrete manifold to the continuous distribution of the momentum introducing the linear density of the particles f(k,t)=\sum_{\bf K}n_{\bf K}(t)\delta(|{\bf K}|-k), (5) where the sum is taken over all the states with the same absolute momentum k . The introduction of the linear density ( 5 ) allows us not only to pass from discrete momenta to a continuous momentum k in Eq. ( 1 ), but also exclude thermalization dynamics along the states with perpendicular momenta, as shown in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Energy-momentum relation of the particles. For the illustrative purposes we show a two-dimensional system with the particles having a parabolic dispersion. For the illustrative purposes, we also specify the momentum range from -7 \mu m -1 to 7 \mu m -1 which is relevant for the recent experiments Sannikov et al. 2024 ; Plumhof et al. 2014 ; Zasedatelev et al. 2019 ; Zasedatelev et al. 2021 . Red arrows on the dispersion surface show perpendicular \Delta{\bf k}_{\perp} and parallel \Delta{\bf k}_{||} components of the wave-vector, exchanged within the process of particle thermalization. One can see that the thermalization rate given by ( 3 )-( 4 ) does not depend on \Delta{\bf k}_{\perp} (see Fig. 1 ). Thus, using the definition of the linear density ( 5 ), we can transform the discrete Maxwell–Boltzmann equation ( 1 ) into the continuous form \frac{\partial f(k,t)}{\partial t}=-\gamma_{k}f(k,t)+F(k,t)\\ +\int\limits_{0}^{+\infty}(\gamma^{kk^{\prime}}_{\rm therm}-\gamma^{k^{\prime}k}_{\rm therm})f(k,t)f(k^{\prime},t)dk^{\prime}\\ +\int\limits_{0}^{+\infty}\left[\gamma^{kk^{\prime}}_{\rm therm}g(k)f(k^{\prime},t)-\gamma^{k^{\prime}k}_{\rm therm}g(k^{\prime})f(k,t)\right]dk^{\prime}. (6) where F(k,t)=\sum_{\bf K}\varkappa_{\bf K}(t)\delta(|{\bf K}|-k) is an incoherent pumping and g(k)=\sum_{\bf K}\delta(|{\bf K}|-k) is the density of states determined by the dimensionality of the system. For a one-dimensional system g(k)=L/2\pi , where L is the length of the system; for a two-dimensional system g(k)=Sk/2\pi , where S is the area of the system; for a two-dimensional system g(k)=Vk^{2}/2\pi^{2} , where V is the volume of the system. So far, Eq. ( 6 ) is equivalent to Eq. ( 1 ) which is the Maxwell–Boltzmann equation. To transform the integral equation ( 6 ) into the equation of a differential type, we integrate over the momentum space preserving only the terms up to \omega_{M}^{2} (see Appendix A for details). As a result, we obtain the convection-diffusion equation describing the kinetics of Bose gas \frac{\partial f(k,t)}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial J(k,t)}{\partial k}=-\gamma_{k}f(k,t)+F(k,t) (7) with the flux in momentum space defined by J(k,t)=-\frac{\Gamma\omega_{M}^{2}}{2}\frac{g(k)f(k,t)}{v_{\rm gr}^{2}(k)}\\ -\frac{k_{B}T}{\hbar}\frac{\Gamma\omega_{M}^{2}}{2}\frac{g^{2}(k)}{v_{\rm gr}^{3}(k)}\frac{\partial}{\partial k}\left(\frac{f(k,t)}{g(k)}\right)-\frac{\Gamma\omega_{M}^{2}}{2}\frac{f^{2}(k,t)}{v_{\rm gr}^{2}(k)}. (8) The left-hand side of Eq. ( 7 ) corresponds to the conservative dynamics with the particle redistribution over momentum space caused by thermalization, while the right-hand side of this equation is the non-conservative part, which describes the loss of particles, -\gamma_{k}f(k,t) , and the supply of particles to the system from some external source, F(k,t) . Since k=|{\bf k}| , the particles cannot pass through k=0 implying the boundary condition for Eq. ( 7 ) {\lim_{k\to+0}}J(k,t)=0. (9) The convection–diffusion equation in momentum space ( 7 ) with boundary condition ( 9 ) and the expression for the flow of the particles in momentum space ( 8 ) are the main result of the paper. In what follows, we study the properties of the obtained

Read the complete text