Quantitative Theory for Critical Conditions of Like-Charge Attraction Between Polarizable Spheres

Yanyu Duan, Zecheng Gan · 2025

Read Quantitative Theory for Critical Conditions of Like-Charge Attraction Between Polarizable Spheres by Yanyu Duan, Zecheng Gan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10516.txt.

Introduction

Yanyu Duan and Zecheng Gan give in 2025 a compact theory for a curious effect: two spheres with the same charge can attract when each is polarizable. A neat predictive rule for when the attraction switches on had been missing. Their route starts from a new three-point image formula that ties a classical mirror-charge idea to a known special function.

From that formula fall simple threshold conditions that match simulations to within one percent across many settings. The thresholds may inform self-assembly, crystal growth, and phase separation at many scales. The formula also speeds up force-field calculations that involve polarizable spheres.

Catalog record

CREATORYanyu Duan, Zecheng Gan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10516

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantitative Theory for Critical Conditions of Like-Charge Attraction Between Polarizable Spheres Yanyu Duan, Zecheng Gan Abstract Despite extensive experimental and theoretical efforts, a concise quantitative theory to predict the occurrence of like-charge attraction (LCA) between polarizable spheres remains elusive. In this work, we first derive a novel three-point image formula, based on a key observation that connects the classical Neumann’s image principle with the incomplete beta function. This approach naturally yields simple yet precise critical conditions for LCA, with a relative discrepancy of less than 1 % 1\% compared to numerical simulations, validated across diverse parameter settings. The obtained critical conditions may provide physical insights into various processes potentially involving LCA, such as self-assembly, crystallization, and phase separation across different length scales. Additionally, the new image formula is directly applicable to enhance the efficiency of polarizable force field calculations involving polarizable spheres. keywords American Chemical Society, L a T e X † † affiliation: Thrust of Advanced Materials, and Guangzhou Municipal Key Laboratory of Materials Informatics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Guangzhou), Guangzhou 511453, China. † † email: [email protected]; [email protected] † † affiliation: Thrust of Advanced Materials, and Guangzhou Municipal Key Laboratory of Materials Informatics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Guangzhou), Guangzhou 511453, China. † † affiliation: Department of Mathematics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong SAR, China † † abbreviations: IR,NMR,UV Introduction. Electrostatic effect plays a significant role in nature across various length scales Levin (2002) ; Grosberg et al. (2002) ; Messina (2009) ; Ohshima (2024) .Examples include interactions between biomolecules He et al. (2023) ; Kornyshev et al. (2007) , dust charging and transport Wang et al. (2016) ; Baptiste et al. (2021) , aerosol growth in Titan’s atmosphere Lindgren et al. (2017) , and the self-assembly of charged colloidal particles Leunissen et al. (2005) ; Barros and Luijten (2014) . One of the fundamental principles that describes the electrostatic interaction between electrically charged particles is Coulomb’s law Coulomb (1785) ; Jackson (2021) . According to this classical law, like-charged particles repel, oppositely-charged particles attract. However, for charged particles at short distances, Coulomb’s law may not accurately describe the interaction because polarization effects between the particles can become significant. One counterintuitive phenomenon resulting from polarization effects at short distances is like-charge attraction (LCA) Besley (2023) ; Lee et al. (2023) . In recent years, LCA has been reported in the electrostatic interactions between charged conducting spheres Lekner (2012) , polarizable spheres Xu (2013) ; Qin et al. (2016) , rough dielectric particles Gorman et al. (2024) , and particles in a uniform external field Li et al. (2024) . Conversely, LCA can also occur for like-charged particles in electrolyte solutions Larsen and Grier (1997) ; Allahyarov et al. (1998) ; Levin et al. (1999) ; Linse and Lobaskin (1999) ; Moreira and Netz (2001) ; Baumgartl et al. (2006) ; Nagornyak et al. (2009) ; Zhao et al. (2016) ; Jiang and Gillespie (2021) ; Budkov and Kolesnikov (2022) ; Wills et al. (2024) ; Budkov et al. (2024) ; Wang et al. (2024) , where both polarization and electrostatic correlations among mobile ions become crucial Zhang and Shklovskii (2005) . Studies indicate that LCA significantly influences various physical chemistry processes, including cation mobility in ionic liquids Khudozhitkov et al. (2023) , polyelectrolyte self-assembly Zaki et al. (2016) , protein adsorption at the silica–aqueous interface McUmber et al. (2015) , and ion-pairing in water Vazdar et al. (2012) . Considerable effort has been devoted to explaining this counterintuitive phenomenon driven by polarization effects, utilizing various numerical methods and theoretical models Besley (2023) . Developed numerical methods include the finite element method Feng (2000) , boundary element method Ruan et al. (2022) ; Gorman et al. (2024) ; Hassan et al. (2022) , multilevel method Saunders et al. (2021) , method of moments Bichoutskaia et al. (2010) ; Derbenev et al. (2016) ; Siryk and Rocchia (2022) , image charge method Wang and Wang (2013) ; Xu (2013) ; Li et al. (2024) , and hybrid methods Gan et al. (2016) ; Gan et al. (2019) . Additionally, several theoretical models have been proposed, including the bi-spherical coordinate transformation approach Khachatourian et al. (2014) ; Lian and Qin (2018) , polarizable ions model Chan (2020) , and multiple-scattering formalism Freed (2014) ; Qin et al. (2016) ; Qin et al. (2016) ; Qin (2019) . Despite the extensive numerical and theoretical investigations mentioned above, a concise and quantitative theory to predict the occurrence of LCA remains elusive. In this Letter, we propose such a theoretical model for systems consisting of two like-charged polarizable spheres. We address the challenge of close interaction between two polarizable spheres by deriving a new three-point image formula, based on which a simple yet accurate theory for the critical conditions of LCA is obtained. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. First, the classic Neumann’s image principle for the polarizable sphere model is revisited. Then we derive the new three-point image formula and present a general theory for the critical conditions of LCA. Finally, we discuss the critical conditions of LCA for both equal-sized and unequal-sized spheres, considering asymmetries in permittivity and carrying charges within each sphere. The polarizable sphere model and Neumann’s image principle. Consider two polarizable spheres immersed in a homogeneous dielectric medium with permittivity \epsilon_{\mathrm{out}} , each sphere having a radius a_{i} , relative dielectric constant \epsilon_{i} ( \epsilon_{i}>\epsilon_{\mathrm{out}} ), and central charge Q_{i} ( i\in\{1,2\} ), separated by a center-to-center distance R , as illustrated in Fig. 1 . Such polarizable sphere model has been extensively studied in the modeling and simulation of various systems across different length scales, including polarizable ions Levin (2009) , charged colloids Barros and Luijten (2014) , and biomolecules Lotan and Head-Gordon (2006) . Figure 1: Schematics of the system setup: (a). the reflected Neumann’s image charges; and (b). the three-point image formula (developed in this work), for two polarizable spheres immersed in a medium. In both panels, colored tiny hollow circles denote image charges, while arrows indicate dipole moments. A classical approach for evaluating the polarization potential and field is the image charge method. Let us start by considering a single, charge-neutral polarizable sphere with radius a and relative dielectric constant \epsilon_{\mathrm{in}} , suspended in a medium characterized by relative permittivity \epsilon_{\text{out}} . The so-called Neumann’s image principle Neumann (1883) ; Lindell (1993) has been derived to account for the polarization potential induced by an external point charge Q . Suppose the point charge Q is located at a distance R from the center of the sphere ( R>a ), then the polarization potential outside the sphere can be expressed as the sum of the Coulombic potential generated by a Kelvin image charge Q_{\text{K}}=-\frac{Qka}{R} , positioned at the Kelvin inversion point r_{\text{K}}=\frac{a^{2}}{R} inside the sphere, and a Neumann line image density q_{\text{line}}(r)=\frac{Qkg}{a}\left(\frac{r_{\text{K}}}{r}\right)^{1-g} distributed from the sphere center to the Kelvin point (i.e., r\in[0,r_{\text{K}}] ), where we define k=\frac{\epsilon_{\text{in}}-\epsilon_{\text{out}}}{\epsilon_{\text{in}}+\epsilon_{\text{out}}} and g=\frac{\epsilon_{\text{out}}}{\epsilon_{\text{in}}+\epsilon_{\text{out}}} . It can be verified that Q_{\text{K}}+\int_{0}^{r_{\text{K}}}q_{\text{line}}(r)dr=0 , thereby ensuring that the total charge neutrality condition within the polarizable sphere is maintained. Consequently, the polarization energy E_{\mathrm{pol}} for the single-sphere system can

Read the complete text