Summary of Fiducial Parameters

Daniel J. D’Orazio, Christopher Tiede, Lorenz Zwick, Kimitake Hayasaki, Lucio Mayer · 2025

Read Summary of Fiducial Parameters by Daniel J. D’Orazio, Christopher Tiede, Lorenz Zwick, Kimitake Hayasaki, Lucio Mayer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10509.txt.

Introduction

Daniel D'Orazio and co-authors explored a violent fate for stars caught near two merging supermassive black holes in 2025. If gas disks drive the binary, nearby stars should be delivered into the disk plane, migrate inward, and become trapped at the edge of the cavity the binary clears. Locked to its slow decay. A trapped star then spirals down with the binary until tidal forces strip it in a runaway process.

For Sun-like stars around binaries in the mass range the space-based sensor LISA will hear. The stripping should produce repeated X-ray flares near the maximum steady brightness, flashing every few hours to days and continuing for decades. Those traits match the recently discovered quasi-periodic eruptions remarkably well. One problem remains: the forecast and seen rates clash, unless mergers of lower-mass binaries are more common than expected.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel J. D’Orazio, Christopher Tiede, Lorenz Zwick, Kimitake Hayasaki, Lucio Mayer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE130 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10509

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Summary of Fiducial Parameters Daniel J. D’Orazio, Christopher Tiede, Lorenz Zwick, Kimitake Hayasaki, Lucio Mayer Abstract If supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) are driven together by gas disks in galactic nuclei, then a surrounding nuclear star cluster or in-situ star-formation should deliver stars to the disk plane. Migration through the circumbinary disk will quickly bring stars to the edge of a low-density cavity cleared by the binary, where the stellar orbit becomes trapped and locked with the binary decay. Here we explore the scenario where the trapped stellar orbit decays with the binary until the binary tidally strips the star in a runaway process. For Sun-like stars, this occurs preferentially for 10 4 − 10 6 ​ M ⊙ 10^{4}-10^{6}{M_{\odot}} SMBHBs, as the SMBHB enters the LISA band. We estimate that the runaway stripping process will generate Eddington-level X-ray flares repeating on hours-to-days timescales and lasting for decades. The flaring timescales and energetics of these circumbinary-disk tidal-disruption events (CBD-TDEs) match well with the recently discovered Quasi-Periodic Eruptions. However, the inferred rates of the two phenomena are in tension, unless low-mass SMBHB mergers are more common than expected. For less-dense stars, stripping begins earlier in the SMBHB inspiral, has longer repetition times, lasts longer, is dimmer, and can occur for more massive SMBHBs. Whether CBD-TDEs are a known or a yet-undiscovered class of repeating nuclear transients, they could provide a new probe of the elusive SMBH mergers in low mass / dwarf galaxies, which lie in the sweet-spot of the LISA sensitivity. I Introduction When galaxies harboring supermassive black holes (SMBHs) collide, the SMBHs can form a binary at the center of the nascent galaxy [ 14 ] . If the SMBH binary (SMBHB) can efficiently interact with its environment, to remove orbital angular momentum and energy, it can reach separations where gravitational radiation efficiently drives the binary towards merger [ 79 ] . The late inspiral and merger would be detectable with low and mid-frequency gravitational wave detectors such as the Pulsar Timing Arrays [ 43 , 1 , 37 , PTAs, e.g. ,] , TianQin [ 78 ] and LISA [ 3 , 21 ] . Environmental interactions include those with gas surrounding the binary in a circumbinary disk [ 9 , CBD, e.g. , ] and with stars from a surrounding nuclear star cluster [ 85 , e.g. ,] . Both types of interactions can lead to observational identifiers of a SMBHB. Gas interactions with the binary can lead to periodically variable photometric and spectroscopic signatures due to accretion rate variability and relativistic effects [ 30 , 29 , e.g. ,] . Stellar interactions can lead to tidal disruption events (TDEs). A TDE is a luminous transient event that typically occurs around a SMBH at the center of an inactive galaxy, and is characterized by flares lasting for several months to years [see 47 , for a review] . The standard theoretical picture is that stars approach the SMBH on nearly parabolic orbits, are torn apart by its tidal forces [ 58 ] , and release a fraction of their gravitational energy as the stellar debris accretes onto the SMBH, producing bright flares [ 88 ] . Over the past fifteen years, the number of TDEs or TDE candidates has increased significantly, but is still only a hundred or more. However, with the upcoming operation of the Vera C. Rubin Observatory [ 4 , VRO;] , the number of observed TDEs is expected to increase by an order of magnitude or more within the next decade. One of the scientific motivations for studying TDEs is that they provide opportunities to find fingerprints of intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs), SMBHBs, and isolated, recoiling SMBHs [ 64 ] . For SMBHBs, TDEs present unique phenomena that provide insights into both black hole dynamics and accretion processes. When a star is disrupted in such a system, its debris interacts not only with the tidal field of a SMBH, but also with the gravitational potential of the binary, leading to complex accretion dynamics [ 90 , e.g. ,] . Liu et al. [69] , Liu et al. [70] demonstrated that TDEs in SMBHBs could produce periodic but intermittent flares due to debris streams interacting with the secondary SMBH, offering a potential observational signature of binary systems. Hayasaki & Loeb [54] , Coughlin et al. [22] investigated the hydrodynamics of such events around close SMBHBs, and showed that a chaotic motion of the debris stream significantly modifies the accretion behavior, leading to unique electromagnetic signals. In particular, for merging SMBHs, an accretion disk formed around the secondary SMBH generates a periodic lightcurve due to special relativistic boosting, potentially providing a method to diagnose gravitational wave emission from the merging SMBHs [ 54 ] . These studies highlight the potential of TDEs to serve as a unique diagnostic tool for detecting SMBHBs or merging SMBHs and understanding the interplay between stellar disruption, accretion physics, and binary evolution. In reality, both gas disks accreting onto the black holes and surrounding stars (in a nuclear star cluster or formed in the disk) should exist in tandem, providing opportunities for disk and TDE-induced binary signatures, as well as possible combinations, which we investigate here. The interaction between AGN disks and surrounding stars has been studied with recently renewed interest in the context of the pairing and merging of stellar-mass BHs through the “AGN-channel” [ 77 , 98 , 12 ] . One outcome of this interaction is the eventual grind-down of stellar orbits into the plane of the disk [ 12 , 40 , 73 , e.g. , ] , and their rapid migration towards the central accretor [ 93 , e.g. , ] . Here we argue that the same process of grind-down and migration occurs for disks around SMBHBs, that is until the migrating star approaches the inner part of the CBD, where the binary clears a low density cavity [ 10 , 31 , e.g. ] . At this cavity a natural and robust migration trap [ 76 , 100 , 63 ] locks the stellar orbit to that of the decaying SMBHB until either the trap breaks, the SMBHB decouples from the disk, or the star begins to be tidally stripped by the binary. We explore the latter case here, arguing that the stellar stripping events can runaway and fully disrupt the star, significantly altering the feeding of the binary by the CBD and resulting in Eddington-level X-ray events repeating on hours to days timescales and lasting for a few to tens of years. Furthermore, for Solar-like stars, these events, which we call circumbinary disk tidal disruption events (CBD-TDEs), would accompany inspiraling LISA SMBHBs or their progenitors. There are also intriguing similarities to the recently discovered Quasi-Periodic Eruptions [QPEs, e.g. , 82 , and references therein] . Our study proceeds as follows. In § II we motivate the trapping of stars at the edge of circumbinary cavities around SMBHBs and the consequences for disruption of these stars while the SMBHB is approaching, or in, the LISA band. In § III we build a model for partial to full disruption of such a star by the SMBHB. In § IV we investigate the consequences of

Read the complete text