Static Born charges and quantum capacitance in metals and doped semiconductors

Asier Zabalo, Cyrus E. Dreyer, Massimiliano Stengel · 2025

Read Static Born charges and quantum capacitance in metals and doped semiconductors by Asier Zabalo, Cyrus E. Dreyer, Massimiliano Stengel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10303.txt.

Introduction

Asier Zabalo, Cyrus Dreyer, and Massimiliano Stengel give theorists a direct way to compute a subtle charge in metals in this 2025 paper. When a crystal's atoms shift, its electrons answer with a polarization captured by Born charges. A static version of these charges was lately proposed to describe slow phonons in dirty metals, where damping rules.

The authors derive the static charges straight at the zone center, applying a classic theorem to the charge response. They also tie the charges, through an exact sum rule, to how the material answers a uniform strain, with its quantum capacitance in a starring role. Tests on aluminum, copper, a polar metal, and a doped oxide check the math. The authors close by questioning what the numbers mean, since the value shifts with the chosen electrical reference and length scale.

Catalog record

CREATORAsier Zabalo, Cyrus E. Dreyer, Massimiliano Stengel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10303

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Static Born charges and quantum capacitance in metals and doped semiconductors Asier Zabalo, Cyrus E. Dreyer, Massimiliano Stengel Abstract Born dynamical charges ( Z dyn \textbf{Z}^{\rm dyn} ) play a key role in the lattice dynamics of most crystals, including both insulators and metals in the nonadiabatic (“clean”) regime. Very recently, the so-called static Born charges, Z stat \textbf{Z}^{\text{stat}} , were introduced [G. Marchese, et al. , Nat. Phys. 20 , 88 (2024)] as a means to modeling the long-wavelength behavior of polar phonons in overdamped (“dirty”) metals. Here we present a method to calculate Z stat \textbf{Z}^{\text{stat}} directly at the zone center, by applying the “ 2 ​ n + 1 2n+1 ” theorem to the long-wavelength expansion of the charge response to a phonon. Furthermore, we relate Z stat \textbf{Z}^{\text{stat}} to the charge response to a uniform strain perturbation via an exact sum rule, where the quantum capacitance of the material plays a crucial role. We showcase our findings via extensive numerical tests on simple metals aluminum and copper, polar metal LiOsO 3 , and doped semiconductor SrTiO 3 . Based on our results, we critically discuss the physical significance of Z stat \textbf{Z}^{\text{stat}} in light of their dependence on the choice of the electrostatic reference, and on the length scale that is assumed in the definition of the macroscopic potentials. I Introduction It has been well known for the better part of a century that long-range electrostatic interactions play a key role in the lattice dynamics of insulating systems [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The fundamental theory thereof, established by Pick, Cohen and Martin in 1970 [ 4 ] , paved the way to modern ab-initio implementations [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] of phonons and electron-phonon interactions in real materials. Recent works have generalized this idea to doped semiconductors and metals [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] , demonstrating that in certain regimes, long-range electrostatic interactions related to phonons can occur in metals due to nonadiabatic effects. Specifically, this occurs for the “clean limit” of a metal or doped semiconductor, i.e., under the assumption that an optical phonon of frequency \omega is much larger that the inverse carrier lifetime, 1/\tau [ 14 , 15 ] . This physics is encapsulated in the “nonadiabatic” Born dynamical charges [ 15 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] , whose sublattice sum relates to the inertia of the free carriers in the material. At the level of the static force constants, of direct relevance to “dirty metals” where \omega\ll 1/\tau [ 16 ] , no such long-range interactions exist, and (assuming a finite electronic temperature) the dynamical matrix is an analytic function of the momentum 1 1 1 At low temperatures, discontinuities in the Fermi occupation function leads to the so-called Kohn anomalies, whose description requires a materials-specific discussion; they are removed at any finite electronic temperature (or smearing), which we assume in this work. . Yet, even in this regime there are good reasons to seek a careful treatment of the long-wavelength limit. For a weakly doped semiconductor, for example, the free carriers have significant impact on the calculated phonon frequencies only in a narrow region of the Brillouin zone surrounding the \Gamma point [ 18 ] . This can result in an abrupt transition between an insulating regime, with a sizable frequency splitting between longitudinal (LO) and transverse (TO) optical branches, to a metallic one over a very short distance in momentum space. Such a sharp feature would be clearly problematic to treat via the established numerical interpolation algorithms. The question then is what definition of the Born effective charge (BEC) should be used in modeling the long-wavelength limit of polar phonons [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] in damped metals. Neither the macroscopic polarization nor its parametric dependence on the atomic positions can be defined or calculated in conductors, ruling out a straightforward approach. To address this issue, a static version of the Born effective charges, {\bf Z}^{\rm stat}_{\kappa\alpha} ( \kappa denotes the sublattice and \alpha the Cartesian direction), was recently proposed [ 16 ] via “macroscopic unscreening” (i.e., with long-range electrostatic effects suppressed) of the charge response to the lattice distortion. The {\bf Z}^{\rm stat}_{\kappa\alpha} were found to be useful tools in the calculation of electronic transport, optical properties of metals, and phonon-mediated superconductivity [ 16 ] . Whether the {\bf Z}^{\rm stat}_{\kappa\alpha} are experimentally measurable quantities on their own, however, still remains to be clarified. Indeed, a direct measurement of the static BECs (e.g., via infrared absorption) appears unfeasible, as the LO/TO splitting vanishes in damped metals. To devise alternative experimental routes, establishing exact formal relations between the {\bf Z}^{\rm stat}_{\kappa\alpha} and other observables is an obvious prerequisite. In these regards, a sum rule for the static BECs in metals was demonstrated in Ref. 16 , but its physical significance was not clarified. This situation contrasts that of the Born dynamical charges, where an exact sum rule links their sublattice sum to a defining geometric property of the electronic ground state, the Drude weight tensor [ 12 ] . From the methodological perspective there is considerable room for progress too. All the calculations of the static charges that were reported so far were based on numerical differentiation of momentum-dependent response functions (either the charge response to a phonon [ 16 ] or the atomic force response to a modulated scalar potential [ 19 ] ). The finite-difference approach to the long-wavelength expansion, while efficient and straightforward to implement, introduces additional parameters in the calculation, which must be carefully checked for convergence. For many applications, it would be desirable to have a more straightforward code implementation, allowing for the calculation of the static charges directly at the \Gamma point of the Brillouin zone. The recent generalization of long-wavelength perturbation theory to metals [ 20 ] appears ideally suited to this task. In this work, we study the static BECs in three-dimensional (3D) metals with the aim of addressing these questions. First, we use the formalism of Ref. [ 20 ] to establish a closed formula for the static BECs, only requiring the calculation of response functions at the \Gamma ( q=0 ) point in the Brillouin zone. Next, we establish an exact sum rule for the static BECs, by relating them to the first-order charge response to a uniform strain. The latter, in turn, can be written as a deformation potential times the quantum capacitance C_{Q} of the 3D crystal, describing the number of electrons that are stored in the unit cell upon a shift of the Fermi level. Similarly, we find that the quantum capacitance relates the static BECs with the octupolar moment of the screened charge response to an atomic displacement. We demonstrate these formal results with ab-initio density-functional perturbation theory (DFPT) calculations performed on aluminum, copper, LiOsO 3 , and doped SrTiO 3 . Finally, we discuss the dependence of both {\bf Z}^{\rm stat}_{\kappa\alpha} and C_{Q} on the choice of the electrostatic reference, on the pseudopotential approximation, and on the specifics of how the electrostatic kernel is partitioned between an analytic and a nonanalytic part. The

Read the complete text