Pauli principle forbids Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ} bound states
H. Garcilazo, A. Valcarce · 2025
Read Pauli principle forbids Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ} bound states by H. Garcilazo, A. Valcarce (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-10276.txt.
Introduction
Garcilazo and Valcarce argue that triple systems of a rare heavy baryon cannot bind together, in this 2025 paper. Lattice simulations had found the pair version of this baryon, built from three heavy quarks, attracts its twin strongly. That raised hopes for bound states of three or more as the quark grows heavier.
The authors trace the block to the Pauli principle acting twice over. At the level of whole baryons, it spoils the quietest pairing wave. At the level of the quarks inside, it spoils a second wave. Together the two effects close every door, for strange, charm, and bottom versions alike. The paper tempers expectations for exotic heavy matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | H. Garcilazo, A. Valcarce |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-10276
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Pauli principle forbids Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ} bound states H. Garcilazo, A. Valcarce Abstract Lattice QCD studies have shown the attractive character of the S 0 1 {}^{1}S_{0} Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ} , Q = s , c , b Q=s,c,b , interaction, predicting deeply bound states as the mass of the heavy quark increases. This has led to the question of the possible existence of bound states of more than two Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ} baryons, in particular Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q Ω Q Q Q \Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ}\Omega_{QQQ} bound states. We discuss how these states might not exist in nature in any flavor sector. The reason would be due to the simultaneous action of two consequences of the Pauli principle in the different partial waves: one at the baryon level, affecting the S 0 1 {}^{1}S_{0} partial wave, and the other due to the quark substructure, affecting the S 2 5 {}^{5}S_{2} partial wave. I Introduction. Experimental findings since 2003 with the discovery of the X(3872) [ 1 ] have opened a new era for hadron spectroscopy. As a general conclusion, the idea has emerged that the heavy hadron spectra shows the contribution of states that do not belong to the simplest quark-antiquark (meson) or three-quark (baryon) structures proposed by Gell-Mann [ 2 ] . Experimental evidence of more complex structures is steadily and continuously being found [ 3 ] . One of the most striking predictions of the quark model was the possible existence of bound states in double heavy tetraquark configurations, QQ\bar{q}\bar{q} [ 4 ] . Stability was shown to be a function of the mass ratio M_{Q}/m_{q} . The mechanism that stabilizes QQ\bar{q}\bar{q} at large M_{Q}/m_{q} is the same that makes the hydrogen molecule much more stable than the positronium one in atomic physics [ 5 ] . Such prediction was confirmed by the LHCb Collaboration that announced the discovery of a very sharp peak in the DD\pi spectrum that was dubbed T_{cc} [ 6 , 7 ] . It corresponds to a minimal quark content cc\bar{u}\bar{d}=T_{cc}^{+} . The T_{cc}^{+} misses binding by a very small amount. So, it is almost certain that the heavier partners, T_{bc}=bc\bar{u}\bar{d} and T_{bb}=bb\bar{u}\bar{d} , could be stable with respect to the strong and electromagnetic interactions [ 6 , 8 ] . Another area that has recently attracted a great deal of interest is the case of dibaryons in the heavy flavor sectors. Only one stable state made of two baryons is known, the deuteron. This is a loosely bound state of a proton and a neutron with spin 1. Lattice QCD studies have opened the door to the existence of stable states made of heavy flavor baryons. Thus, the HAL QCD Collaboration [ 9 ] has studied the \Omega\Omega system in the {}^{1}S_{0} channel through (2+1)- flavor lattice QCD simulations with a large volume and nearly physical pion mass m_{\pi}\simeq 146 MeV. Their results indicate that the {}^{1}S_{0} \Omega\Omega state has an overall attraction and is located near to the unitary regime with a binding energy B^{\rm QCD}_{\Omega\Omega}=1.6(6)\left({}^{+0.7}_{-0.6}\right) MeV. The Coulomb repulsion reduces the binding energy by a factor of two, B^{\rm QCD+Coulomb}_{\Omega\Omega}=0.75(5)(5) MeV, the system being still bound. A few years later, the \Omega_{ccc}\Omega_{ccc} system was studied on the basis of the HAL QCD method [ 10 ] . Without the Coulomb interaction, a (2+1)- flavor lattice QCD study of the {}^{1}S_{0} channel with nearly physical light-quark masses and the relativistic heavy-quark action with the physical charm quark mass, shows a weak repulsion at short distances surrounded by a relatively strong attractive well, which leads to a bound state with a binding energy B^{\rm QCD}_{\Omega_{ccc}\Omega_{ccc}}=5.68(0.77)\left({}^{+0.46}_{-1.02}\right) MeV. Taking into account the Coulomb repulsion between the \Omega^{++}_{ccc} ’s, with their charge form factor obtained from lattice QCD, a scattering length of a^{C}_{0}=-19(7)\left({}^{+7}_{-6}\right) fm was obtained. The ratio r^{C}_{\rm eff}/a^{C}_{0}=-0.024 is considerably smaller than that of the dineutron ( -0.149 ), which indicates that \Omega_{ccc}\Omega_{ccc} is located in the unitary regime. More recently, the first lattice QCD investigation of heavy dibaryons \Omega_{bbb}\Omega_{bbb} in the {}^{1}S_{0} channel has been carried out [ 11 ] . It was reported a binding energy B^{\rm QCD}_{\Omega_{bbb}\Omega_{bbb}}=81\left({}^{+16}_{-14}\right) MeV. With such a deep binding, Coulomb repulsion serves only as a perturbation on the ground state wave function of the parametrized strong potential and may shift the strong binding only by a few percent. In particular, the associated maximum change in binding energy is found to be between 5 and 10 MeV. On the other hand, it is also well known from nuclear physics that when a two-baryon interaction is attractive, if such a system is merged with additional nuclear matter and there are no severe Pauli principle constraints, the attraction can be strengthened. Simple examples can be given of the effect of a third or a fourth baryon in two-baryon systems with attractive character interactions. The deuteron, (I)J^{P}=(0)1^{+} , is bound by 2.225 MeV, while the triton, (I)J^{P}=(1/2)1/2^{+} , is bound by 8.480 MeV, and the \alpha particle, (I)J^{P}=(0)0^{+} , is bound by 28.295 MeV. The binding per nucleon B/A increases as 1:3:7 . A similar argument is found in systems with strangeness -1 . The hypertriton {}^{3}_{\Lambda} H, (I)J^{P}=(0)1/2^{+} , is bound with a separation energy of 130\pm 50 keV [ 12 ] 1 1 1 Note that the above canonical value of the hypertriton binding energy has been challenged recently by the STAR Collaboration [ 13 ] , claiming a much more tightly bound hypertriton with B=0.41\pm 0.12\,{\rm(stat)}\pm 0.11\,{\rm(syst)} MeV, which does not affect our reasoning. , and the {}^{4}_{\Lambda} H, (I)J^{P}=(0)0^{+} , is bound with a separation energy of 2.12\pm 0.01\,{\rm(stat)}\,\pm 0.09\,{\rm(syst)} MeV [ 14 ] . The template that has been observed for tetraquarks, that the binding energy increases for heavy quarks [ 4 , 8 ] , it therefore appears to be reproduced in the case of other multiquark hadrons involving more than one bottom quark [ 11 ] . Considering all the above together, a common interesting pattern might be emerging that the presence of more than one bottom quark enhances the binding in multihadron systems [ 15 , 16 ] . Given the bound-state nature of two– \Omega systems in the different heavy flavor sectors predicted by lattice QCD calculations [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] , the question immediately arises whether systems containing more than two such \Omega -like baryons might also be bound in nature [ 17 , 18 ] . This issue is particularly relevant in the bottom sector given the very large binding energy predicted for the two-body system by lattice QCD calculations [ 11 ] . This is the question we analyze in this work making use of the quark substructure of the \Omega^{i} baryons 2 2 2 Since our arguments will be valid for any of the flavor sectors considered, henceforth we will denote by \Omega^{i} the \Omega for i=s , the \Omega_{ccc} for i=c and the \Omega_{bbb} for i=b . , similar