A Unified View of Vacuum Decay Channels
J.R. Espinosa · 2025
Read A Unified View of Vacuum Decay Channels by J.R. Espinosa (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09714.txt.
Introduction
Espinosa gives a talk-based paper, from 2025, on how a false vacuum can decay. A newer method, based on a tunneling potential, frames all decay routes in one view. The classic bounce path is one member of a wider family of paths. That family also holds other known forms, from smooth instantons to bubbles of nothing. The talk shows how one frame can hold them all.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J.R. Espinosa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09714
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Unified View of Vacuum Decay Channels J.R. Espinosa Abstract The tunneling potential formalism, an alternative to the standard Coleman Euclidean approach, offers in a natural way a unified view of vacuum decays. In particular, I show in this talk how Coleman’s bounce is just a member of a continuous family of solutions that can also feature Hawking-Moss instantons, pseudo-bounces and bubble-of-nothing solutions. 1 The Tunneling Potential Formalism The tunneling potential formalism [ 1 , 2 ] calculates the tunneling action for vacuum decay [of the false vacuum at \phi_{+} of some scalar potential V(\phi) ] by minimizing the simple functional S[V_{t}]=\frac{6\pi^{2}}{\kappa^{2}}\int_{\phi_{+}}^{\phi_{0}}\frac{(D+V_{t}^{\prime})^{2}}{V_{t}^{2}D}d\phi\ . (1) The function V_{t}(\phi) is the tunneling potential that connects \phi_{+} to some field value \phi_{0} ( >\phi_{+} by convention) beyond the potential barrier that would stabilize classically \phi_{+} . The formula above includes gravitational corrections to the decay: \kappa=1/m_{P}^{2} , with m_{P} the (reduced) Planck mass, and D=\sqrt{V_{t}^{\prime}{}^{2}+6\kappa(V-V_{t})V_{t}} . This formalism reproduces the standard results obtained using the Euclidean methods by Coleman and de Luccia [ 3 , 4 ] (CdL). The minimization procedure returns a specific solution V_{t} that is a solution of the Euler-Lagrange equation \delta S/\delta V_{t}=0 associated to ( 1 ) that reads (4V_{t}^{\prime}-3V^{\prime})V_{t}^{\prime}+6(V-V_{t})[V_{t}^{\prime\prime}+\kappa(3V-2V_{t})]=0\ . (2) The solution extends from \phi_{+} to some \phi_{0} that coincides with the central value of the CdL bounce. For Minkowski or AdS false vacua, V_{t} is monotonically decreasing (as it goes away from \phi_{+} ) while for dS vacua, V_{t}=V for some field interval from \phi_{+} to some intermediate \phi_{i} and, from \phi_{i} to \phi_{0} , V_{t} is concave down (this second field range coincides with that of the CdL bounce). For large enough V(\phi_{+})>0 , the CdL bounce does not exist and vacuum decay proceeds via the Hawking-Moss instanton [ 5 ] (with the field jumping to the top of the barrier homogeneously inside the dS horizon) with a specific rate ( S_{HM}=24\pi^{2}[1/V(\phi_{+})-1/V(\phi_{T})]/\kappa^{2} ) that is reproduced by ( 1 ) for V_{t}=V from \phi_{+} to the top of the barrier at \phi_{T} . 2 A Family of V_{t} Solutions The V_{t} corresponding to the CdL solution turns out to be one (special) member of a larger family of solutions of the differential equation ( 2 ) which also have physical meaning, as shown below. Let us consider the case of a dS false vacuum to show this and let us look for solutions of ( 2 ) which, like the CdL one, have some interval with V_{t}=V (the trivial HM regime) and some interval with V_{t}\leq V (the non-trivial regime). Calling as before \phi_{i} the field value that separates both regimes, the family of solutions is labeled by the \phi_{i} value (which runs from the false vacuum \phi_{+} to \phi_{T} , the field value at the top of the potential barrier). The boundary conditions at \phi_{i} are as for the CdL solution: V_{t}(\phi_{i})=V(\phi_{i})\ ,\quad V_{t}^{\prime}(\phi_{i})=3V^{\prime}(\phi_{i})/4\ . (3) To find the family of solutions, ones solves ( 2 ) starting from \phi_{i} with these boundary conditions until the solution hits V (at some end-point \phi_{e} ) or diverges to -\infty . Figure 1: Left: Family of V_{t} solutions for a dS false vacuum decay. Center: zoom of previous. The family includes the Hawking-Moss solution (violet), pseudo-bounces (green), the CdL solution (red) and bubbles-of-nothing (orange). Right: Tunneling action corresponding to the different V_{t} solutions as a function of \phi_{i} . The left and central plots of figure 1 show the family of solutions obtained. For \phi_{i}=\phi_{T} (the top of the barrier, \phi_{T}\simeq 0.25 in the example) one gets the trivial HM solution (violet line). For smaller \phi_{i} one gets solutions (green lines) that correspond to the so-called pseudo-bounces [ 6 ] , to be discussed in section 3 . For some special value of \phi_{i} this family of pseudo-bounces ends, at the CdL solution (in red). Below the CdL line, the V_{t} solutions (orange lines) diverge to -\infty without hitting V . These correspond to bubble-of-nothing (BoN) decays [ 7 ] (provided \phi is a geometrical modulus describing the size of an extra dimension), see section 4 . The right plot of figure 1 gives the tunneling action of all these V_{t} solutions (following the same color coding), which is finite even for the singular BoN ones. For the solutions relevant for standard (non-moduli) scalar fields (HM, pseudo-bounces and CdL) the HM and CdL ones are stationary points of the action, with CdL being the minimum, as expected. 3 Pseudo-bounces Pseudo-bounces are vacuum decay channels that are not stationary points of the action (as seen in the example above, figure 1 , right plot) but they would minimize the action S[V_{t}] if the end point \phi_{e} were to be held fixed. Therefore, these solutions are in principle of subleading importance for decay compared to the CdL/HM ones. However, they can become relevant [ 6 ] in at least two cases: a) if the slope of the action is small, the action for pseudo-bounces is not much larger than that of the CdL solution and one should integrate over them in order to get a good estimate of the vacuum decay rate; b) if the potential is such that the CdL solution is only reached at \phi_{e}\to\infty (so that the CdL solution does not properly exist) then vacuum decay necessarily proceeds via pseudo-bounce configurations. One can think of the pseudo-bounce solutions as lying along the bottom of a valley of the tunneling action in configuration space. Indeed, an slice of such valley at fixed \phi_{e} (the central value of the field configuration) is minimized by the pseudo-bounce that ends at \phi_{e} . The Euclidean field profile of pseudo-bounces is readily found [ 6 ] . They are configurations with a fixed field-value in their core, which extends out to some finite radius, after which the solution relaxes to the false vacuum (solving in that region the Euclidean bounce equation), see figure 2 , left plot. In the V_{t} formulation, the difference between the CdL solution and pseudo-bounces is that at \phi_{e} one has V_{t}^{\prime}(\phi_{e})=3V^{\prime}(\phi_{e}) for the CdL case and V_{t}^{\prime}(\phi_{e})=0 for pseudo-bounces. This difference comes about naturally when solving ( 2 ) starting from \phi_{i} , as illustrated by figure 2 , which shows in its right plot how V_{t}^{\prime} behave as V_{t} approaches V for the different types of solutions: for pseudo-bounces, V_{t}^{\prime} flows to 0; for CdL, V_{t}^{\prime} flows to the finite value 3V^{\prime}(\phi_{e})/4 , and, for BoNs, V_{t}^{\prime} diverges to -\infty . Figure 2: Left: Euclidean pseudo-bounce field profile. Right: Flow of V_{t}^{\prime} near the end point \phi_{e} for V_{t} solutions near the CdL one (red), which ends with V_{t}^{\prime}=3V^{\prime}/4 . Pseudo-bounce solutions (green) flow to V_{t}^{\prime}=0 while BoN solutions (orange) diverge to V_{t}^{\prime}=-\infty . 4 Bubbles of Nothing Bubbles of nothing, first discussed by Witten [ 7 ] for the M^{4}\times S^{1} Kaluza-Klein (KK) model ( 4d Minkowski times a circle), are a qualitatively different decay channel for theories with compact extra dimensions. A BoN describes the tunneling from a homogeneous spacetime (with constant size of the extra dimension) to an spacetime with a nucleated bubble/hole where the size of the compact dimension goes to zero at the surface of the bubble. Inside