Planetary Rhythms: Synchronous Circulation on Variably Irradiated Asynchronous Planets numpy ( Harris et al. 2020 ) , Dedalus3 ( Burns et al. 2020 )
Deepayan Banik · 2025
Read Planetary Rhythms: Synchronous Circulation on Variably Irradiated Asynchronous Planets numpy ( Harris et al. 2020 ) , Dedalus3 ( Burns et al. 2020 ) by Deepayan Banik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09644.txt.
Introduction
Deepayan Banik studies how a planet with a moving hotspot can end up acting like a tidally locked one, in a 2025 paper. On locked planets the hot spot stays fixed; on freely rotating ones it drifts ahead of or behind the noon point. Banik shows that if the planet's day matches the rhythm of changing starlight, the hotspot can stay fixed anyway.
Small mismatches make the hotspot creep slowly east or west, at a rate set by the difference of the two rhythms, like the beat of two near-equal tones. Timing constraints from radiation, rotation, waves, and drag bound when this beating occurs. Two circumbinary planets from Kepler and TESS stand out as candidates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Deepayan Banik |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09644
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Planetary Rhythms: Synchronous Circulation on Variably Irradiated Asynchronous Planets numpy ( Harris et al. 2020 ) , Dedalus3 ( Burns et al. 2020 ) Deepayan Banik Abstract Tidal locking of planets to their host stars results in an atmospheric circulation with a hotspot fixed to the frame of reference of the planet. On the other hand, asynchronously rotating planets feature moving hotspots either lagging or leading the corresponding substellar point as it translates along the surface. We show that a planet falling in the latter category could mimic the circulation of tidally synchronous planets under the influence of time-varying instellation, possibly provided by pulsating or multiple star systems. This happens when the planet’s diurnal period is in resonance with the period of instellation variation, leading to a planet-frame-fixed hotspot. Slight differences in the above periods lead to East-West or West-East creeping hotspots with a period significantly longer than both. The rate of hotspot motion is given by the difference between the diurnal and instellation variation rates, similar to the lower envelope frequency of beat patterns formed by two superposed waves in linear wave theory. We call this phenomenon ‘beating’. A combination of the radiative, rotational, wave propagation, and drag timescales establishes dynamical constraints on beating. Based on this we classify a set of Kepler and TESS circumbinary planets with two candidates exhibiting climatic departures from the no-variation scenario. In general, hotter and faster-spinning planets are more susceptible to climatic departures. Beating, if it occurs, may additionally create optimistic extensions of habitable zones for corresponding systems. I Introduction In recent popular science fiction literature, the Three Body Problem, Chinese novelist Cixin Li portrays a hypothetical variably irradiated world that exhibits chaotic weather patterns, quite the opposite of our experience of the Earth. Notwithstanding the extreme scenario, the major takeaway is that a planet’s climate is strongly influenced by the type of radiation it receives. At first order, this is primarily linked to its rotation and orbital periods. When equal, the planets have a permanent day side and are called tidally synchronous, otherwise, the day and night coverage shifts continuously resulting in asynchronous planets like the Earth. Spatio-temporal variation of irradiation may also arise from the planet’s precession, orbital eccentricity, or axial tilt leading to well-known Milankovitch cycles ( Deitrick et al. 2018 ) . All these effects have been extensively studied in the literature ( Pierrehumbert & Hammond 2019 ; Penn & Vallis 2017 ; Ohno & Zhang 2019 ) . The discovery of planets around binary stars ( Borucki et al. 2010 ) added another source of variability to the list, the circumbinary “gyration” effect — the planet-relative orbital motion of binary stars ( Haqq-Misra et al. 2019 ) . Additionally, stars like RR Lyrae variables, Delta Scuti variables, or short-period Cepheids ( Dambis et al. 2013 ; Handler 2009 ; Csörnyei et al. 2022 ) are known to feature stellar pulsations, another potential cause of inherent variability. Planets around such systems are envisaged to feature interesting phenomena due to resonance effects ( Forgan 2014 ) , yet, much is left to be understood so far as climate modeling is concerned. Figure 1: a. Schematic of a circumbinary habitable zone (green) with regions of therminator habitability inside it (red shade) and, possible optimistic extensions within (blue) and beyond (yellow) the inner and outer edges, respectively, in the case of beating planets. b. Schematic of the shallow water model used in the simulations with different relevant heights serving as a proxy for atmospheric temperature affected by a periodically varying instellation source. The red line corresponds to the radiatively forced profile, while the blue represents the steady-state equilibrium height. Previous atmospheric studies of variably irradiated planets (VIP) have used 1-D Energy balance models (EBM) owing to their simplicity and cost-effectiveness ( Forgan 2014 ; May & Rauscher 2016 ; Haqq-Misra et al. 2019 ; Yadavalli et al. 2020 ) . However, EBMs apply well to planets with a zonally averaged circulation, thereby precluding periodic variations in the local climate engendered by instellation variation. This has likely led to the conclusion that the atmospheric dynamics of gaseous circumbinary planets (CBP) differ little from the equivalent single-star case ( May & Rauscher 2016 ) . Additionally, global climate models (GCM) for circumbinary Earth-like planets have shown only minor effects on the surface climate ( Popp & Eggl 2017 ; Wolf et al. 2020 ) . Moreover, the computational expense of GCMs allows for only a small survey of the parameter space excluding regimes of potential climate variability and extremes. Consequently, concerns of habitability are limited to these cases ( Komacek 2020 ) . Given the above, we ask the following questions: Can time-varying instellation alter the atmospheric circulation of planets significantly? If yes, under what conditions, and to what extent? What is the nature of the resulting climate variability, and how does it differ from the no-variation scenario? In this paper, we present a first survey of variably irradiated planetary atmospheres using a shallow-water model (SWM). Principally, we demonstrate that the atmospheric circulation of Earth-like and gaseous VIPs could differ significantly from the no-variation case, contrary to previous research. This happens in a specific regime of parameter space where the diurnal and irradiation variation frequencies are close or synced. In such cases, an asynchronous rotator may mimic the circulation pattern of a tidally locked planet with a permanent planet-frame-fixed global temperature maxima or hotspot , resulting in local temperature extremes. We define a new term called the ‘therminator’ to demarcate regions of thermal opposites. Minor deviations from the aforementioned synchronization lead to long-term climate variability, with the therminators slowly creeping across the planet surface. The gradual motion of the polarized global climate occurs at a rate given by the difference of the diurnal and irradiation variation frequencies, much like the lower envelope frequency of beat patterns formed by two linearly superposed sound waves. We refer to this dynamical phenomenon as ‘beating’. The current work points to multiple directions of further research. Fig. 1 a shows the traditional circumbinary habitable zone (HZ) in green, where a beating planet might carve out a relatively uninhabitable region due to the creation of thermal extremes on opposite sides of the planet. The therminators of such a planet could however be habitable ( Lobo et al. 2023 ) . On the other hand, beating might lead to optimistic extensions of HZs on both the inner and outer edges, with habitable cold and hot sides, respectively. Thus, the potential for diverse climates on VIPs opens up a new area of exploration for atmospheric dynamicists and habitability experts alike. Additionally, the synchronization of planetary diurnal/rotation periods with the instellation variation period of their host stellar systems requires investigation. A potential role may be played by thermal tides, already known to cause Earth-like planets around single low-mass stars to rotate asynchronously ( Leconte et al. 2015 ) . In § II we briefly describe our two-layer spherical shallow-water mathematical model. In § III we discuss the results: the beating phenomena and therminators are defined as relevant to the work. Additionally, we provide a first-order analytical reasoning for the occurrence of beating. We also obtain limits on known dynamical timescales to map out