A posteriori error estimates for the Lindblad master equation
Paul-Louis Etienney, Rémi Robin, Pierre Rouchon · 2025
Read A posteriori error estimates for the Lindblad master equation by Paul-Louis Etienney, Rémi Robin, Pierre Rouchon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2501-09607.txt.
Introduction
Paul-Louis Etienney, Remi Robin, and Pierre Rouchon derive in 2025 error estimates for simulating open quantum systems under the Lindblad equation. Simulation first truncates the infinite state space, then steps through time numerically, one small step at a time. Users need guarantees that both steps keep the result accurate enough for their purpose and their task.
Their bounds can be computed explicitly from the simulation itself, with no extra guesswork or side tests. Numerical examples show the upper bound is tight in practice, close to the true error in each case. They extend adaptive time stepping to adaptive truncation, resizing the space as the run proceeds. For large simulations, that can cut computing time and remove guesswork in setup.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paul-Louis Etienney, Rémi Robin, Pierre Rouchon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501-09607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A posteriori error estimates for the Lindblad master equation Paul-Louis Etienney, Rémi Robin, Pierre Rouchon Abstract We are interested in the simulation of open quantum systems governed by the Lindblad master equation in an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space. To simulate the solution of this equation, the standard approach involves two sequential approximations: first, we truncate the Hilbert space to derive a differential equation in a finite-dimensional subspace. Then, we use discrete time-step to obtain a numerical solution to the finite-dimensional evolution. In this paper, we establish bounds for these two approximations that can be explicitly computed to guarantee the accuracy of the numerical results. Through numerical examples, we demonstrate the efficiency of our method, empirically highlighting the tightness of the upper bound. While adaptive time-stepping is already a common practice in the time discretization of the Lindblad equation, we extend this approach by showing how to dynamically adjust the truncation of the Hilbert space. This enables fully adaptive simulations of the density matrix. For large-scale simulations, this approach can significantly reduce computational time and relieves users of the challenge of selecting an appropriate truncation. Furthermore, as a special case, our method naturally applies to Hamiltonian (unitary) dynamics. 1 Introduction 1.1 Presentation of the problem and main contributions In this article, we focus on simulating open quantum systems obeying the Lindblad master equation [ 20 , 12 , 8 ] . This equation models the evolution of an open quantum system weakly coupled to a Markovian environment [ 4 ] . We are particularly interested in the case where the underlying Hilbert space \mathcal{H} is infinite-dimensional, with a particular focus on bosonic modes, also known as quantum resonators, or cavities. More precisely, the Lindblad equation reads as follows: \displaystyle\mathcal{L}(\boldsymbol{\rho}) \displaystyle=-i[{\bf H},\boldsymbol{\rho}]+\sum_{i}\mathcal{D}_{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i}}(\boldsymbol{\rho}), \displaystyle\frac{d}{dt}\boldsymbol{\rho}(t) \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}(\boldsymbol{\rho}(t)),\quad\boldsymbol{\rho}(0)=\boldsymbol{\rho}_{0}, (1) where \boldsymbol{\rho} is a density operator, that is a self-adjoint positive semidefinite operator of trace one, {\bf H} is the Hamiltonian of the system, which is a self-adjoint operator, the bracket denotes the commutator, and the dissipators \mathcal{D}_{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i}}(\boldsymbol{\rho}) act on \boldsymbol{\rho} as \mathcal{D}_{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}}(\boldsymbol{\rho})={\mathbf{\Gamma}}\boldsymbol{\rho}{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}}^{\dagger}-\frac{1}{2}\left({{\mathbf{\Gamma}}}^{\dagger}{\mathbf{\Gamma}}\,\boldsymbol{\rho}+\boldsymbol{\rho}\,{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}}^{\dagger}{\mathbf{\Gamma}}\right). (2) In the case of infinite dimensional Hilbert space and unbounded operators {\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i} and/or {\bf H} , special care is needed to define the solution of the equation, we refer to [ 9 , 6 ] for the general case or [ 11 ] for the specific case of bosonic modes. We are interested in computing an approximation of the solution \boldsymbol{\rho}(T) of Eq. 1 at a final time T>0 . To this aim, two intermediate steps are classically performed. Step 1. We begin by selecting a finite-dimensional subspace \mathcal{H}_{N}\subset\mathcal{H} . Our goal is to define a finite-dimensional approximation of the solutions of Eq. 1 within this subspace. Let \mathbf{P}_{N} denotes the orthogonal projector onto \mathcal{H}_{N} . We consider the corresponding truncated operators: \displaystyle{\bf H}_{N}=\mathbf{P}_{N}{\bf H}\mathbf{P}_{N},\quad{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i}}_{N}=\mathbf{P}_{N}{\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i}\mathbf{P}_{N},\quad\forall i\in\mathbb{N}. (3) For a single bosonic mode, the Hilbert space is given by \mathcal{H}=\{\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}u_{n}\ket{n}\mid\sum_{n}|u_{n}|^{2}<\infty\}\simeq l^{2}(\mathbb{N}) , where the canonical orthonormal basis is provided by the Fock states (\ket{n})_{n\geq 0} , and the corresponding dual basis is (\bra{n})_{n\geq 0} . In this setting, a common method is to truncate the Fock basis, namely consider \displaystyle\mathcal{H}_{N}=\operatorname{Span}\{\ket{n}\mid 0\leq n\leq N\},\quad\mathbf{P}_{N}=\sum_{i=0}^{N}\ket{i}\bra{i}. (4) Next, we define the following Lindbladian for both density operators on \mathcal{H} and on \mathcal{H}_{N} . \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{N}(\boldsymbol{\rho}) \displaystyle=-i[{\bf H}_{N},\boldsymbol{\rho}]+\sum_{i}\mathcal{D}_{{{\mathbf{\Gamma}}^{i}}_{N}}(\boldsymbol{\rho}). (5) Thus, we can define the approximated solution {\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t) by \displaystyle\frac{d}{dt}{\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t) \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{N}({\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t)),\quad{\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(0)=\mathbf{P}_{N}\boldsymbol{\rho}_{0}\mathbf{P}_{N}. (6) It is important to keep in mind that \mathbf{P}_{N}\boldsymbol{\rho}(t)\mathbf{P}_{N} is not equal in general to {\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t) ; but we expect {\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t) to be an approximation of \boldsymbol{\rho}(t) . For the sake of simplicity, we assume that \boldsymbol{\rho}_{0} has support in \mathcal{H}_{N} , that is \boldsymbol{\rho}_{0}=\mathbf{P}_{N}\boldsymbol{\rho}_{0}\mathbf{P}_{N} (see Remark 1 for the general case). Step 2: Approximate the solution of the linear differential equation Eq. 6 using an Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) solver. In the following, we will denote by \mathcal{F}_{\delta t} one step of the considered scheme. Let us give an example with the first order explicit Euler scheme, which reads as follows \displaystyle e^{\delta t\mathcal{L}_{N}}(\boldsymbol{\rho})\approx\mathcal{F}_{\delta t}(\boldsymbol{\rho})=\boldsymbol{\rho}+\delta t\mathcal{L}_{N}(\boldsymbol{\rho}). (7) Taking N_{step} and \delta t such that T=N_{step}\delta t , we compute iteratively \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{n+1,\delta t}=\mathcal{F}_{\delta t}(\tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{n,\delta t}) with \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{0,\delta t}=\boldsymbol{\rho}_{0} , that is \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{N_{step},\delta t}=\mathcal{F}_{\delta t}^{N_{step}}(\boldsymbol{\rho}_{0}) . At this point, we expect \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{N_{step},\delta t} to be close to \boldsymbol{\rho}(T) . These two steps are completely standard and can be easily performed using a library for quantum simulation like Qutip [ 16 ] , Qiskit dynamics [ 23 ] , Dynamiqs [ 14 ] , QuantumOptics.jl [ 19 ] , etc. The time solver scheme is usually more complex and powerful than a first order explicit Euler scheme. For instance, it can be a Runge-Kutta scheme or a structure preserving one, like [ 5 , 1 , 26 ] . The space discretization method we employed in step 1 is commonly known as a Galerkin approximation. For a detailed study of the convergence and limitation of this method to the Schrödinger equation, we refer to [ 10 ] . In this article, we do not consider non-linear space discretization methods, such as reduced rank or tensor network methods, nor do we address stochastic unraveling schemes and cumulant expansions. This paper focuses on providing computable bounds on the distance between the approximations {\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(T) or \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{N_{step},\delta t} and the true solution \boldsymbol{\rho}(T) . The error \|{\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(T)-\boldsymbol{\rho}(T)\|_{1} is referred to as the (space-)truncation error, while \|{\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(T)-\tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{N_{step},\delta t}\|_{1} is the time discretization error. Previous works, such as [ 30 ] , have addressed (while not being the main contribution of the paper) the space truncation error for finite-dimensional Hamiltonian systems coupled to chains of bosonic modes, using time-adaptive density matrix renormalization group (t-DMRG) methods. Our approach differs in several important ways. First, our proposed method applies to systems that are themselves infinite-dimensional, such as bosonic modes. Second, it is suitable for Lindblad dynamics, not just closed systems. See Appendix B for details. Other works focus on a priori error analysis, typically for specific Hamiltonian systems (e.g. [ 28 , 22 ] ); an exception is the recent study of Lindblad equations in [ 24 ] . However, these studies do not provide explicit usable computable estimates, but rather asymptotic convergence rates. Even when constants can be found, they are typically not explicit and the resulting bounds are not sharp. Conceptually, a priori estimates use bounds depending on the exact solution \boldsymbol{\rho}(t) or its regularity (for example the norm of \boldsymbol{\rho}(t) in a well-chosen Sobolev space), whereas a posteriori estimates only depend on the computed solution {\boldsymbol{\rho}_{(N)}}(t) or \tilde{\boldsymbol{\rho}}_{N_{step},\delta t} . While the first allows proving convergence and rates of convergence, the second is much sharper in practice to control the error of a given simulation. Many examples considered in this work are motivated by the bosonic code community, a subfield of quantum error correction devoted to the robust encoding of quantum information in bosonic modes. In this setting, one encounters a broad class of Hamiltonians and dissipative generators, frequently expressed as polynomials in the creation and annihilation operators. In the experimental platform of circuit quantum electrodynamics, sum of unitary operators of the form e^{i\eta{\bf q}}+e^{-i\eta{\bf q}} naturally arise, where {\bf q} denotes the position operator. Such terms originate from the Josephson junction nonlinearity, whose interaction energy is proportional to the cosine of the flux. The simulation